Climbing Up NP-Hard Hills D. Duvivier* and Ph. Preux ... - GRAppA

Talbi***. Abstract. Evolutionary algorithms are sophisticated hill-climbers. .... entry, it schedules as soon as possible the next not-yet scheduled operation of the .... application of the crossover is often destroyed by the mutation applied afterwards. .... It is noteworthy that for big instances, the research space is huge and only a.
158KB taille 2 téléchargements 178 vues
 

 !" #%$&#('&)+*,)+*,-.0/21436587:9;$-'&?4/@/A1B3&5ACEDGF2$+H1BIKJ6* /@/@/ +sLNZ cegvVMPs&q=ORq>Q_bhS@€=‚,U4_tq(Q ^&WYv4g!ceX[fbpmu>vZ]_b\!q>pm^`„r_bp(adujadce\!nbceq>fbqftg!a[ghjyViknbc`q>^`g!ce_Va0^ehmi l cepm\\!adhmce‚ceuRadp…n+adntoYamce\}pƒpNpmu>\!g!^e^eg]hjZ]qrpmq‡p(pm†‡\\‚[sVˆ‰nt^exŠ\4n+cepmu@gadghjce^=u@v(g pmstamqRqRhjg!vw\!hjytumnnV^eq@c`^`og!^`x0^ep@u>l]^`{b\!cKoz‹…hmcead_Vynbh;q>ohjv4p@p(ce{}pmu>am|~_b\rfpmsVpdadcenthj\!\cef px ce^ep[q@oNc`^`^`{t_+‘pmadhjq‡g]‚~am\4q@u>v2_+pE\!f%\!f2q@Œ adsnbq>q‡hmceuRo\ o(q>fts&am\pf+g!qjceftoamc`p‡f+\!l‚’g]ada[n+pmq}\X[^eZ “c`f+€4lrs&ad\!nbc`ftq[adŽmc`fb\yVlNx0\pdnb_+\!a=stadx0nbpmq…uGnbceq@ov4s&_V\!^`c`hjfbamlgf+stu@hjq\!yt\!x‚ s&adadn+n+q>qq=hmcefbo\!q@ytq>q@Žmftvq@amuRp\ad‚+ceu>Z nt^eqqRi g!‚,yVhm_thm^eiNf+cev%u@pdadg!nbce\^e\l]f ”\!hmg]adcep‡adn+nbq}=oq>qjp@„r^`^;€tu>g g cepƒp;qjf+=adu@nbq>irq(^`^b\og ‚Pp;g^e\4adfVn+u@fbqgq>^‰hZ pmqjadq@hjnbgi(q(hjuGl]\n%\4s&\4oq>v–hjq@g]sadamnbq>\!hm\4hj‚Špvt\!p:hjg!oYc`hjf•qg!fbadg!nVu@stqcesVp\!^`ceu@ybq@\v&amftg!{‰amc`q@fbX;Œ4q@Œ a@v x € yt‚Šgi‘Z \!pdhjceo(gyVst^e^ei%q=ntcec`ad^`^`n x0u>\ ^`cKadoznbq>ythc—fbsVl_tyVg!^`^ecel]pd\!nbhmq@cev‘adnbhjoqRpdp@_V{=^e amp@{ qrg!^epm\2pdnb\!˜adn+g]a(\_VhYhjq@pd_V^eampu@\]o(s+ghjq ™ tš ›…œ&&žƒŸ (¡Pœ¢>ž› £ '&.(¤}¥V.j¦A1B*,§ ¨ƒ14©Y1B¨j¨>-¨j¨>*K36ªA¤ƒ9P14©YC:«¨Y1B.j-rªV¥+¥b58¬0¥t.ƒ*,3 ©j9&-N­¥V3b©>-?+©¥B¬:­!¥t§2J&*,3*Š14I ¥V®&©j*,§ *,¯]1B©j*,¥t3”¤ƒ*,©>9°.j-ª+14.>5&¨ ©j¥±¥V©j9&-!. ¨j- 14.j­@9²§‘-©j9&¥+5&¨³´J9&*,3&¦ ©>9©j¥+­@9©j*,­%I,¥+­]1BIE¨>-]14.>­@9¹1BIKªV¥t.>*K©>9&§ ¨‡­]1B3J&.j*,3&ª‘¨j¥V§ -©>9&*,3&ª2©j¥‘©j9&*,¨(º9&¥+5&¨r14.j-NI,*,§ *,©j-5 *,3©>9&-2¨j*,¯-2¥B¬}©j9&-2®6.j¥tJ6IK-!§ ¨©>9&-»­ 143w9- ¥B¬¨j¥t§‘-2I,*K§‘*,©R14©>*,¥t3&¨(*K3¿©j9&©>9&-¥t.>-©j*,­]1BI=.j-¨>'&I,©j¨r©>¥A14¨>¨j-¨>¨r¨j¥VI,'&©j*,¥t36¨‡¬0¥t'&365¤ƒ*,©j9I,¥+­]14I[¨j-]1B.j­@9&-¨ $;À(¥4¤}-!)t-. Á9¥%.>-IŠ14?‘*K3‘¨j¥V§ -§‘-]14¨>'&.j-©>9&-¨j-N©j96-¥t.>-©j*,­]1BI;I,*,§ *,©R1B©j*,¥43&¨]$ H=¥•1B­@9&*,-)t-r¥V'&.ƒªt¥+14ImÁ+¤‡-Y­!¥t3&­-!3b©>.R1B©j-N¥t'&.>¨j-I,)t-!¨¥t3éj9&-.j-!¨j¥tI,'&©>*,¥t3¥B¬E©j96-}Ä@¥tJDŨ>9&¥t®+D ¨>­R96-5&'&I,*,3&ª®&.j¥VJ&I,-§Æ³´ÇbÈ&7…·ÁV©j9&-ƒ©>.R1 )t-!IK*,3&ª(¨R1BIK-!¨j§A1B3r®&.>¥tJ&I,-§É³ŠHÈ&7·!Át143652©j9&-ƒ½+'*Kª+14©>-k9&¥4¤©>9&-”-)t¥VI,'&©j*,¥t3P14.j»¶®¥t®&96*K¨>©j*,­]1B©j-5w¥t3&-!¨]Á‰C=«¨r1B.j-r9&*,I,I—D ­I,*,§2JP-.j¨ Ñ4ªt*,)t-!3 1­¥tI,I,-­©>*,¥t32¥4¬‰®P¥t*,3+©j¨‡¥4¬‰©j9&-(¨j-]1B.j­@9 ¨j®§ ¨13&-!¤¾­!¥tI,I,-­@D ©>*K¥V3%143652¦t--®6¨]ÁV5&-©j-!.j§ *,3&*,¨>©j*,­]14I,I,»¥V.3&¥V©]Á ©j9&-ƒJP-¨>©}®P¥t*,3+©j¨14§‘¥t3&ªƒ©>9&-¨>-©m¤‡¥Y­!¥tI,I,-­©j*,¥V3&¨]$ Hƒ9&-N5&*,¨j­!.j*,§ *,3-@D ­¥V§2J&*,3*,¥t3N¥t®P-.R1B©j¥t.>¨]$+À(-3&­-tÁP­¥V§ ®©R143655A96*KI,I—Dm­I,*K§NJP-.'&¨>*K36ª ¥V3&I,»A§2'6©R14©>*,¥t3+DmI,*K¦4-2³d14¨j-!?b'P14IŠ·ƒ¥V®¥t.j¨§A1 » ¨>9&-5”¨>¥t§ -IK*,ªV9b©>¨¥V3k©>9&-%*,§‘®-­¥t§2J6*K3P14©j*,¥V3k14¨r¤‡-I,I}1B¨r*,©j¨-@Ô ­*,-3&­!»b$[À¥4¤‡-)t-!.]Á[­]14.>-29¥JP-2©R14¦V-3”¤ƒ9&-3¿5&.R1 ¤‡D *,3&ªw­¥t36­I,'&¨j*,¥t36¨2¥t3©j9&- -@Ô ­!*K-!3&­»Â¥4¬.j-­¥V§2J&*,3*,¥t3±JP-­]1B'&¨j-Ã¥4¬Y©>9&-§‘*K?+-5”-ÖՒ-­!©A¥B¬ §2'&©@14©>*K¥V3•1B3&5 .j-­!¥t§2J&*,39&*,¨%®P14®P-.]Á=¤‡- ¤ƒ*,I,I.j-!¨j©j.>*,­©2¥t'&.>¨j-I,)V-¨2©j¥w¥t3&-‘®&.j¥VJ&I,-§kÁØ39&¥t®+D ¨>­R96-5&'&I,*,3&ªw¥t3±¤ƒ96*K­@9¿¤}- 99&-r§A1B­@9&*,3&-¨ƒ©j9P14©§‘*,3&*,§2*K¯!-¨©j96-%©>¥t©R1BI;§ 14¦t-!¨j®9-]14I,*,¯]1B©j*,¥t3”¥B¬Y©j96- kÄ@¥VJ&¨]$=Hƒ9&*,¨N®&IŠ143&36*K36ª*,3&5&*,­]14©>-¨]Á[¬d¥t.N-]14­@9±©>*,§ -2¨jI,¥V©]Á=©j96¥t®P-.@14©j*,¥V3”*K©(*,¨Y®6.j¥+­-¨>¨j*,3&ª¥AJP- 14­!©j*,)t-N*—Õ±3&¥t3&-N¥4¬ƒ*,©j¨¥t®P-.@14©j*,¥V3 §A1 »NJP-r¨j©@14.j©>-5-]1B.jI,*,-.ƒ.j-!¨j'&I,©j*,3&ª2*,3 1N.j-5&'6­©j*,¥t3 ¥B¬:©>9&-¥4)t-.@14I,I‰§A1B¦t-¨>®*,)t-Ë F–HÏtÎ!Ðj$ «¾­!.j*,©j*,­]1BIb¥V®*,¥t3N*K¨=¥V3&-}©>9*,©j9&§‘¨}¤‡-99±©j96-AJP-¨>©2.j-¨>'&I,©j¨ ¦+3&¥4¤ƒ3¿¨j¥w¬Å1B.]$[H=¥kJP-14J&I,- ©>¥k­!¥t§ ®P14.j-‘¥t'&. .j-!¨j'&I,©j¨N¤ƒ*,©j9”¥V©j9&-.>¨]Á[¤}-2'6¨j-5¿©j9&JP-3&­@9&§A1B.j¦+¨ Ë £ .jI—ÐjÁP©j99&-k-!3&­¥+5&*,3&ªt¨ ¥B¬•¨>¥tI,'&©j*,¥V3&¨ ©>99&§ ¨ $4ÌÍ1B¨j*,­]1BIKI,»+Á4©m¤‡¥r­IŠ14¨>¨j-¨(¥4¬;-3&­!¥b56*K36ªt¨ƒ§A1 »J*,5&-.j-!5 ¬0¥t.‡©j96-ÇbÈ67=$+Hƒ9&-» 14.>-r½+'-­© $ $

13254

%

'&)(

#*,+.-/+0(

687:9.;=< >#? @>A7:? B.90;=7DC

¸°9&-!3 '&¨>*K36ª–1B32*,3&5&*,.j-­!©}-36­¥+5&*,3&ª'&­©>'&.j-*,¨3&¥V©}1®&IŠ14363&*,3&ª.j'&­!©j'&.>-tÁb1‡56-­¥+5&-.=*,¨;.>-½+'&*,.j-5N©j¥ƒ-?+®&.>-¨j¨…©j9&-®6I~1B3&3&*,3&ªP$@«­­¥V.j5&*,3&ª(©j¥(©j9&-*,3+¬d¥t.j§ 14©>*K¥V3 ©j9P14©N*K¨®&.j-¨>-3+©2*,3”©j9&-25©j.>'&­©j'6.j-tÁ…©j9&-‘5&-­¥+5&-.29P14¨N§ ¥t.>-%¥V.rI,-¨j¨N¤‡¥t.j¦w©j¥Ã5&¥©j¥ JP-–1BJ&I,-©>¥%5&-!.j*,)t-1r®&IŠ1B3&3&*,3&ª©j.R1B*,3b©>¨Í1B.j-99&-5&-!­¥+5&-.Y1B3&5 ªV'9&-r®&IŠ1B3&3&*,3&ªN©j9.R1 »+$‰Hƒ9&-‘5&-­¥+5&-.N­¥V3&¨j*,5&-.>¨2©j9&*,¨%1B.j.@1 »¬0.>¥t§Û©j9&-¿ÒjI,-@¬0©©j¥Ã©j9&-‘.j*,ªt9+©jÓP$ 6¥t.r-]1B­@9 -3+©j.>»bÁØ*K©¨>­R96-5&'&I,-¨214¨r¨>¥+¥t3”14¨®*KJ6IK-2©>9&-23&-?+©r36¥t©mDm»t-!©Y¨>­@9&-5&'&I,-5¿¥t®P-.R1B©j*,¥t3w¥4¬ƒ©j96Ä@¥VJ81B¨j¨>¥b­!*~1B©j-5 ©>¥2©j9&-r§ 14.>¦t-.‡©j9A`>²B#®'@D>’Q³



Ÿ Ÿ

µ µ µ



:¶:·

¶Œ¸



S¶0¹ ·



¶:·

¶D¸

¶0¹ ¸



T32ȼ

'¶.¹ ·

¶0¹ ¸

^r•ŽbD< ;P9k]«XaCˆB”< ;=@Œ`k[

}1B.j*,¥t'6¨ƒ9b»+J&.>*,5&*,¯]14©>*K¥V3 ¨>­R96-§ -¨14.>-r®*KJ6IK-‘³Š¨j-!-AË`7=HÎ !д·!$&¸”-9*K¥V3 ¥V®¥t.]$ £ 36IK» 5&*,.>-­©-3&­¥+5&*,3&ªV¨9-5±12¨>*,§ ®&I,-9&*,I,IeDm­I,*,§%JP-.r³´À ƒ·14¨(©j9&-2¨>-]14.>­R9”14I,ªV¥t.j*,©>9&§Æ*,3©>9&-N9b»+J&.>*,5 5&-36¥t©j-!58C:« (À ÂJP-I,¥4¤r$4×m©‡*,©j-.@14©j-!¨Í1­!-.j©@14*,3A1B§ ¥t'63b©=¥B¬’§‘¥4)t-¨ Á4¨j©@14.j©>*,3&ª¬0.>¥t§ 1®&IŠ143D 3&*,3&ªN¤ƒ9&*,­@9A*,¨‡©j9&-*,3&5&*,)+*,5&'©j.@14©j-!ªt»+Á*K¥V3-I,-­©j*,¥V3;$‰F«Y¼VFH˜*,¨1B®&®&I,*,-5 ¤ƒ*K©>9®&.>¥tJ3%©>¥Y©>9&-‡.j-¨>'&I,©j¨¤‡-}9P1 )t-‡¥tJ&©@14*,3&-5r¤ƒ*,©>9r®&.j-!)b*,¥V'&¨jI,»r.>-)+*K-!¤}-5214I,ªV¥t.j*,©>9&§ ¨ ³ ‰©@14J&I,- ·$6×m3¥t'&.(J'&*,©j-tÁP¤‡-r'&¨>-%©>9&- '&©>9k14365Hƒ9&¥t§‘®&¨j¥V3 ¨}*,3&¨>©R1B3&­-¨ Á ©j96- ƒ1B.jI,*,-. ¨=*,3&¨j©@143&­!-¨]Á+14¨=¤‡-I,I1B¨Ï [1 ¤ƒ.j-36­- ¨*,3&¨j©@143&­!-¨]Á+143&5 (H14*,I,I~1B.j5 ¨‰*,3&¨>©R1436­-¨ ¥4¬J&*,ªN¨j*,¯-t$6Hƒ9&-¨j*,¯-r¥B¬E©>9&-r*,3&¨j©@143&­!-¨.@143&ªV-¨‡¬0.j¥V§ÆÏ Ïr©>¥ 6$ F-!3&-.R1BI,IK»”¨>®9&-%14I,ªV¥t.j*,©>9&§ ¨ $ 6¥t.(©j9&-*,.(®©j¨]ÁØ©j9&-N9+»bJ6.j*,5C=«%Á ÃÈ+À Á‰14365 1BI,IE14­@9&*,-)V-%©>9&-N¨R14§‘-¦b*,3&5Ã¥4¬ .j-!¨j'&I,©j¨ Á=I,»b*,3&ª ¤ƒ*,©j96*K3”1‘¬0-!¤®P-.>­-3+©j¨N¬0.>¥t§Û©j9&-‘¥t®&©>*K§ 14I[®&IŠ143&3&*,3&ªP$‰¸°9&-!3”­¥t3&¨>*,5&-.j*,3&ª ©j96-25&*,¨j©j.>*,J&'&©j*,¥V3¥4¬ƒ®¨(¬0¥t'&365*,3¹1 ¨j-.>*K-!¨%¥B¬}-?+®¨Y¤ƒ*,©>9¹1‘ªt*,)V-3k14I,ªV¥t.j*,©>9&§kÁ *,©ƒ­I,-]14.>I,» 14®&®P-]14.>¨©>99&-¨j©R1B3&5*K¥V3 ¥B¬E¥t®6©j*,§A1BI¥t§¥V3&-A1BIKªV¥t.>*K©>9&§©j¥”143&¥V©j9&-!.]Á14365”¬0.>¥t§¥V3&- ¨>-.j*,-¨‘¥4¬*,3&¨j©@143&­!-¨2©j¥±1B3&¥t©>9&-.]$=Hƒ96È+À µªt-36-.R1BIKI,»29©R1B3&555&-)+*Š14©>*,¥t3;ÁV©j9&-NC=«ü143&5 ©>9&-9b»+J&.>*,5 C=« À ˜1§ ¥+5&-!.R14©>-ƒ¥t3&-VÁ+©j9&-H=«Ì ˜96-'&.j*,¨>©j*,­½b'6*K©>-Y196*KªV9 ¥V3&-t$ &'&.>©j9&-!.j§ ¥V.j-tÁV¬d¥t.}1BIKI 9&-'6.j*,¨j©>*K­!¨]Á+©j96-¨j©@143&5P14.j5256-)+*~1B©j*,¥t3N¥tJ6©R14*,3&-!52¥t32©j96- ƒ14.>I,*K-!. ¨=*K36¨j©R1B3&­-¨‡*,¨§2'&­@9N9&*,ªt9&-. ©j9P143©j9&- ¨>©R143655¾56-)+*~1B©j*,¥t3¿¥tJ&©@14*,3&-5¿¬0¥V. 8'&©j9°14365±Hƒ9&¥V§ ®&¨>¥t3 ¨2143&5 ;1 ¤ƒ.j-!3&­- ¨ *,3&¨j©@143&­!-¨]$ƒÀ(-3&­-VÁ¥V3°©j9&-w©j-!¨j©mDm¨j'6*K©>-tÁƒ©>9&- ÃÈ+À Û14I,¤Í1 »+¨Nº9&-)t14.>*K¥V'&¨}1BIKªV¥t.>*K©>9&§ ¨ Á ©j9&-()t-.>» ¨j96¥t.j© ©j*,§‘-}¥B¬’-?+-­!'&©j*,¥t32¥B¬’©>9&- È+À ¿*K¨=3&¥V©j-¤‡¥t.>©j9+»+$4Hƒ9&-C=«(¨³ŠJP¥t©>92®&'&.j-143&5N9+»+J&.j*,5*K§‘-¨N¥4¬Y-!?b-!­'&©j*,¥V3;$ 6¥t.N©j9&- H=«Ì %Á=36¥k¨>'&­@9°­¥t36­I,'&¨j*,¥t3¿§ *,ªt9+©rJP- -]14¨>*,IK» 5&.@1 ¤ƒ32¤ƒ*K©>9%.>-ªb1B.j5&¨‡©j¥©>9&-¨>*K¯!-ƒ¥4¬‰©j9&-(*K36¨j©R1B3&­-‡¬0¥V.=©j9&- H ¨]$4×m©¨>9&¥t'6IK5NJP-®P¥t*,3+©j-5N¥t'&© ©j9P14©‡©j9&-C=« (À ¤Í1B¨.j'&3‘5&'&.>*K36ª ªV-3&-.@14©j*,¥V3&¨]$VÀ¥4¤‡-)t-!.]ÁV©j9&-(J©ƒ®&IŠ143&36*K36ªY©>9¥Nº'&3 *,¨ƒ'&¨j'-5&¨ ªt-!3&-.R1B©j*,¥t3[$4À-36­-tÁ4©>99-.1‡¬0-¤¿9+'&3&5&.>-5&¨ ¥4¬‰ªt-!3&-.R1B©j*,¥t36¨¤ƒ*,©j9&¥V'&©=IK¥V¨j*,3&ªPÁ]§‘¥t¨>©E¥B¬’©>9&-ƒ©j*,§‘-¨]Á ©j96-ƒJ©¨j¥VI,'&©j*,¥t3N©j9P14©*,©=¤}¥V'&I,5r9¥‘º9&-2.j'63;$‰×m©r14I,¨j¥ §‘-]143&¨©>9¥ ¥VJ&©R1B*K3 JP-©j©>-.¨j¥VIK'6©j*,¥t3&¨ƒ¤ƒ96*KI,-'&¨>*K36ª ©j96¯Ä=Å_Æ



´

Q‘¥E



¥R







²F

¥½



!²FtS

E



´

²FG



8



{





"

´



S#

¨F

¥E

!S

S!

S«

! 

F

!S

S!

ŠŒ‹Žˆ

E



E

ȉ

A"

¥E



É´





OR

¥E

ȉ

E



E

Ê"

ȉ



¥½

¥½

¥E



S!S

¥E



¥E

Ë

œ

S



~| fbpmamg!fbu@q ý c @q \!sbadceoƒ_+o X[“ X;“ Íæ ý ƒæ oooa@ajáamä 㠌4Œ+Œ ãá á ä 㠌4Œ+Œ ãá á]â]á@þ ã â á@å þ ä á á]â áþ àå á á]áâ à 4à ä á á]â]á@þ ã ] á u@u@g!g!hhRäá á á@þ]áRŒŒ àà4á@þ ã åã à4à á àá ã ã á àà4á@þ]ã]åã àà4á@þ]ã]åã àà4á@þ]ã]åã u@u@g!g!hjh þ áá ]䌌 åàþVáþä åà 4âäþ åàþVáÖþä åàþVáÖþä åàþ â]âþ á u@u@g!g!hhjã á å Œ4Œ4â ã å]à]þVà á@þä åå]ã â]âà à]å]à þVä áRþ à]å]à!þVþ]áRå þ à]å]à þVä áRþ u@u@g!g!hRhjåà å à!ŒtŒ4åà ãåä!ã å å ã ã]à å ä ãåä!ã å åã ä!â å åã ä!â å ^e^egg äá áá ŒŒ ã]ã ã ã ã ã]à4ã á á ã ã ã]ã ã]ã ã ã ã]ã ã ã ^e^egg þ áá ŒŒ â4â à ããää ââ à â4â à â4â à g!^e^egg]y þ ã à äá á Œ+Œ+Œ áá ã áÖä!€+â ã þã]å ã á â]à þå à á]á áÖä!ââ]ã]ä þ å ä áÖä!â åtã]þ å4á ä á áÖä!âtâ ã á þ åä ä amamg4g þtä4áá þä ŒtŒ+äá ááÖà!þ ã âtt€P€PáRáÖãà!ã åã äá@â]â ã åå áá@âà]äBàá áá@åà]ä à ááà4à]àáä amamgg táá þ ŒtŒ+äá áRå ä]âtà!€&ã ä ä!ã þä ä ä á á äâ ä äâ ã4ä ä]à!äBã á þ ä]à àäBã á]áà á amg4à4á á Œtä ã ã ã á à äþ à ã â þ c`Z[f”g!Tb^`_bMadnbq(q \‚;‹…VadWhmn+^`c`=qyPnV{\!=cesbprn+adceq amozgyVpm_bq@^eo q u@\f+pdc`‚‰_+vkoYceau@p(ce\!p ^`_V_b4s¹o(fb\!f±\!=_thrlfqNfbf2u@c`ceq@f+a=p%pmceampg!ghjf+_VqNuRf q 4cevt{ f+q>=\ft=n+adcfcec`Z hru@\!q@fbp%^`_bg o(adon+f qq hjnVl!q@cec`Z]^`pd^`_tq@x0u>p^ea…^`ceadoƒ\n+y+qyy&gh c`q@f+pmqRa= v2hjý q@:pdƒ_tceadæ ^en•a…\€]ady+n+adn+amq‡gqntc`pmf+i q@qRytZ]vNhmq>ceft_+v2adpdn%X;c`fb“=lce…adadnbnNntq‡c`ad^`^`nbq@xdZ]ujq ^`\!ce^`oz_bady\!‰h fb{tg!|,hjX;f i2“ g!^e€]l]́=\!hmæq=ceadn+nb€goNadZ n+q{ qƒc`=f+pdcen+v4Œ4qceadu@n•V‚g]am~:adq@nNvNceadn•uRad\!nbad^`q…_bn+o(s&qƒqjf oƒhju@_tl!q>^eceftadZ]c`a[q@xdppm‚,hjamadg\]n+hjo qa adadn+ceoqq@\!p@sb{ adceoƒ_+o adnbqƒy&q@pma‡‚Š\_VfbvNsV^egfVftc`fbl ^`ceq@pƒc`ff hm_Vf2‚Khj\ o á am\%ä »Ì

'ÍÈÎ



Õ

Õ

Õ

Õ

Õ



Õ

¨Ô5ÕjÖ

Õ



 

Õ

Õ



8× ×



ÔPØ

Ö

Õ



Õ

Õ



Õ

Õ





Õ ×

Õ





Õ



Õ 



Ô5Õ Ö

Ô ×

Ö

Ô5Õ Ö

Ô5ÕjÖ

Ô ×

ÕÕ

Ô5Õ Ö

Ö

Ô

Õ



Õ

_Õ

ŽÛ…Ül†

Ô5ÕjÖ

Ô



Ô





Ô5ÕjÖ



Ô5ÕjÖ

Ô5Õ Ö



ÔaÙÈÕjÖ



ÔaÙÈÕjÖ

Ô5ÕjÖ

Ô5ÕjÖ

¨Ô5ÕjÖ

¨Ô5ÕjÖ

Ô5ÕjÖ



Ô5ÕjÖ



Ô5ÕjÖ



ՀÔ5ÕjÖ



Õ²Ô5ÕjÖ



Õ²Ô5ÕjÖ

Ô5ÕjÖ



Ô5ÕjÖ



Ô5ÕjÖ





Ô

Ö

ÔPØ

Ö

Ô

Õ

ÉÔ

Ö

ÉÔ

Õ Ö

Õ



ÔaÖ

 ××

ÔaÖ



Õ

ÔPØ

Ö

ÔPØ

Ö













Ö

Ö



ՀÔ5ÕjÖ

ÔPØÊÖ

»Ì

Î

ÔPØ

Õ

Œ‡

Ô Ï

Ö





Õ

‡

Ô5ÕjÖ

Ô5Õ Ö

Ô5ÕjÖ

Õ

Õ



ՀÔaÙÈÕjÖ

Ô5ÕjÖ



Ö

 × ×

Õ

ÔaÙÈÕjÖ

Ö Ö

Õ

Ö

Ô5ÕjÖ

ÉÔ5ÕjÖ







ÕÕ

Ú





Õ



Ö

Ô

ÕÕ



Õ



Õ





Ö

Ô5ÕjÖ Ô5ÕjÖ

Ô5ÕjÖ

Ô5Õ Ö



Õ

ÕÕ

Õ²ÔaÙÈÕ Ö



Ô

× Õ



Õ

× Õ



Õ

 ×

ÔaÖ

ÉÔ5ÕjÖ

Ô5ÕjÖ Ô5ÕjÖ

Õ



Ô

Õ

Ô5Õ Ö

Ô5ÕjÖ



Õ²Ô5ÕjÖ

Ö

Ö



Õ

Ö

ÉÔPØ

Ô



Õ

Ô

Ö

Õ

ÔaÖ



ЎÑ#ÒAÓ

¨Ô5ÕjÖ



Õ ×

Õ

Ô

Î

¨Ô5ÕjÖ



ՀÔ5ÕjÖ

Ö



ÕÕ

Õ

Ö

Õ²Ô

×

¯×

Ô



Ï

¨Ô5ÕjÖ

Ô

'ÍÈÎ

ÊÐ3Ñ#ÒAÓ

ˆ‡

:

Ö

ÔaÖ

Õ

Õ

¨@14§ -1B§ ¥V'&3+©¥4¬=­¥t§‘®&'&©R1B©j*,¥t3P14I+.j-¨>¥t'&.>­-¨ $‰À¥4¤‡-)t-!.]Á+©j96-Y.>-§A1B.j¦2¨>9&¥t'&I,5‘J9&-r¬m14­©r©>9*K¥V3k9P14¨­@9'&I,©j*,3&ª *,3 1­@99&-r9*,3&ª%­!.j*,©j-.>*,¥t3;$6Hƒ9b'6¨]Á&©>9&-rªV-3&¥t©m»+®&*,­5&*,)t-!.j¨j*,©m»2¥B¬:©>9&-r®P¥t®&'6I~1B©j*,¥t3‘*,¨ 3&¥4¤²JP-©>©j-.©R1B¦t-3w*,3+©j¥ 14­!­¥t'&3+©©j¥‘¨j©>¥t®w©j9&-214I,ªt¥V.j*,©j96§ ¤ƒ9&-3w©j9&-wÒj3P14©j'6.R14I,Ó2-)V¥tI,'&©>*K¥V3 ¥B¬E©j96-Y®P¥t®6'&IŠ14©j*,¥V3 9'©j9+»”©j9-¨j- 14.j­@9°¨>®9A1®P¥t®&'6I~1B©j*,¥t3 6Á+¥t. %©>*,§ -¨J6*KªVªt-.‡5&¥+-¨ 3&¥V©=*K§‘®&.j¥4)V-©j96-ƒ½b'P14I,*,©m»Y¥B¬’JP-¨>©=¬0¥t'63&5%®6I~1B3&3&*,3&ªV¨]$ Hƒ9&-ƒ.R1B®&*,5%I,¥V¨j¨¥B¬’5&*,)V-.j¨>*K©m»®&.j¥VJ©R14.>©R·=96*KI,I—Dm­I,*K§2JP-. $Hƒ9&-(J©¬d¥t'&3&52®6I~1B3&3&*,3&ªV¨:1B.j-ƒ-*,©>9&-.‡©j9&-(¥t®&©>*K§ 14IV®&IŠ143&3&*,3&ª¥V.)t-.>» ­I,¥V¨j-r©>¥ *,©]$PHƒ9&*,¨®6.j¥t§‘®&©j¨ƒ'6¨Y¤ƒ*,©>9©m¤}¥2.>-§A1B.j¦+¨]$ [*,.j¨>©]ÁP©j9&-5&-¨j*,ªV3k¥B¬:©>9&-N9&*,IKI—Dm­I,*,§2Jft! &aNß="!$g]uG')nbq>(*^eq@a@€+ˆ‰,-nt!$c`,.^`c`#ƒsVs&€ qq>ˆ‰hjpmhjg!q>c`_b^`^eŒÃqRp@€Pgf+èVv”hjgf+X‰uR^`xq …€ n+2g g@hjg!uG^`nAc ‰á@â gâ]^`yVãVcŠ{ {    `æ=ˆ;å â V2{bæ=# g!hm^`' ceqj h3 g!fb! v‘'X@{t€ ˆØc`fbpmä \!f8cef4ad?y&n+Vq>o€ hjå ltp@4 {{%]å4ýBà ‰am\4q@umumntn+þVfVg]€‰cepmu@adáRgceâ u^ã âtnVû{c`^`q>^esu>^`\!cKhjoƒa2yVu@cef+pmv4lAx0â g !pƒx0å]gþ y+Vg]€}pmú…q>^`ftc`fbceZ qNqjohjpdceq@adadi±nb\4\!v ‚ ‡wâ ±“æ=_ hg!^eg!^`c`c`‚~f_\!hm‡'ft'ceq>gVhj€‰a '-á@ â]g!â#fbtv { ' 2,{=g“hmc`f+_+\2am\]og cevVadceoYÝ _bq>q h€‰{ˆ‰[ hj\\4v4#^_+u@] adceÝ _b_ q €E`a|~H;ft‚ŠbK\hjEoc g ad5ceÝ _bq%!$+|~,SfbvB] _bpmad,ehmd;ceq>B^`^eq € f Cg # CJ ƒ‹ }â rgý ^el nV€B\!cesbl]hmg q>ceadl]fbnbq@\!o p‡yt_ þ ‚Š\ƒþ h;4\Žmþ4y+\!ày•gåVi]€‰pdg n+áRpd\ntâ s cŠâ €‰pm|Š{ uGpmnbg q@\%v4‹…_V^`f+c`fb\tl €+gstf+hjv \!yt2^eq@og pmp@g{}i _ |,f 4c Ú [g!g]hmhjoi g Voƒ{+_VX;hjpdgtn+{‡qj“^eof2g!f„–€&q@u>v4ceq>ceftam\!aƒhl {Kqj7f+q@8adceu   ýB“ € )!3_t^e!Xi‘d iáRâ =?â ' { 2?' \hj"l !$gf' ƒSg!(*_t‚Š'jo g!ft fhý4u>ceq>fbu@qˆØ_tyt^`cepdn+q>hjp@€ } “ ˆ[‹…â hm^ ß=‹…J qjhmhm^`@c`f+y_^egf teyV ' ^e{qqr#E(*Z !$ce+gr'., Jg!C"fbJ 5\!,-ft %i4"!$o ]'.\_+J  p"! ?2‚ŠJ>ad s2{5] 2 \ˆ‰f "n !$n CJvB_ cepmth pmö‰q>8hjñ_amg]‰'adceñ@' \!ì f$hjJ pdceDø aVêq ÿ ,-vtK{ q _ Z…JfbfZ\!1ytJ^eq5 |GJ € ˆ ⠈‰amáR\ â nPâ {tpm{ˆ‰\!^ehjZ q>q _bŒÂn+g!gfbhjvµv X‰stx hj(\!yt{ ^eq@‰og^`p@yV{ cŠ{ “‡|,pmfu pmqRpmpd(*c`f+'-l°J "ad nbqw!A' q@vZ]\!^`_badce \!CfbJ?g!JChj!$'wi²2wsyg!^el]x*\!hm8ceadzenbJ{o5|sbg!hjg]'}vBcel] o Z1 Ú | Ú Jjxd â nx !A'2 €%‚,hj\]ýBo q>sbamq@adoƒnbq y&q>Úhg!yá@â \!hjâ g am{ \c`“…hjq fÆv&q@Ü`Œ4|,fVamqj‚Š\f+hjvtoq@v g adceÝ Z _bqjhjq pdce\!v4f _ cep°Ú ceamgamZ!\!ghjc`g^`x ^ gyV^et~qüø  g p°8_Vhjøq>Bs&8\!hjf a #} ýB\]g â Þftæ‡÷4ce{tu@ô g!ý4^Y\ gûhj q@q>÷4p@s&ô {=\hjX;ó4a‘Z ðV\ú}ì^`ð _+ú…adøxÅce\æê f+ýgxjhjøá@i2â]îtâ í@u@êt\ x ùo(äBstø €_bö amú}ø g í adadîhjce\!q@uGf24ntðV‚~a2ì\!ð]húóadfVnbce€ q[Z]óeq>Žm‰hj\pdñyVceø adx0i]fbhml^eg!fbsthjvV\!p@yt€ ^eq@‡oNq@u@{ qR‰ozq@y&umnVqjh x ‰g!^eâ þ XáR_â !I{ J â ("t5{!A{ f‰,Sg] @^`yV{&cŠˆØ{ƒn HÂadnb q@pd"ce!$p@€^eq=g]p:sthj\4u@q@pmpmqRv _bpdc`f+lradnbq XÚ † -X ‡ oYg u>hj\(sbg u ]g l]q(=ceadn ÚPÚ †ƒæýpmadi ^eq ‡

‡



ð



î