1 Mauroy et al reply: In the comment by Butler and ... - Benjamin Mauroy

as shown now. To justify our approach, we compare the results in [1] with hydrodynamic computations under imposed flow at the outlets. Note that those last BC ...
470KB taille 3 téléchargements 275 vues
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`3  5 $ + (  " +   +  + ("  ! #   $ 2  !   +  # %$97     "  * a] ^ b ` c ` d   9>;>?    >e fc e b d g B .% " +    (8 +   $+ 9        * + 85)# ( ,  %$: 5)+   + L B . ! +  +   B .% " +    # !) %  "  # +   +  (    >   2  ' # .  " ) ,   3  5-ZK[ \ ] ^ _ `#   K\ ` k g f%l7    " #  +  4 ,) + , "  #  +  8*# .   ( +  # !(   .4 %# + ( !  # " ! 1+ ( ( +  71+ 4    B .% " +     T    $'+ K  !  "># %$1&)( %$ # Q ()      ? m1 " 7    " # ! !  *    ( (    + # ! "  ( ! +  / 0 + (  , #  8 %# 

%n„ o € p q { r … s)s>t † us ‡ v{ ˆ%r s { w … w s>q r { sr s x sw y p z9s } zzs s { { r r y)y | q} z9w s ~ q o { €'s ){ … q s€ w o s zr8q o z9† x ~ { o } } w € s w >ƒ ‰8} …‚)s ƒ ‚} o {‚ …o ‹w>s o y z9€ ~ } }†  w sw Œ>'t Š  y Ž Ž{ … o €>s{ z9… s} { q o } ~ €1~ s } r‡Š { r … } s€ | ~ … o wo x{ } ƒ8€ ‰8w… x s{)| sq x r | …Ks} } €>q { { † … s s{ r} o q p { … † {%s { w w … ˆ} ‚‘ ’8w“{ … ”4s’x w • y – z— ‘ z9’8“8s { ˜Ar y’} • ‡ – {  …ˆsx w~ r x9s w ‡ w q q € r | s { wo }  €1o w { } r ‡o Š { q … { so } r €} { x x {%{ {o }… € s x € p † s9™ t š ƒ 3  5›   C    7    +    B + (  (K 2  ,  "AT %# ( + C (     " +  (  (   '( ?œ&  + .% "  # %  ,  "="  ( . + " #  +  H+ (A   , #    %# Wb ] `W^ e d a^ Ÿž ` e f i ^b d ` `=\  \ b `  9¡ ^ f a` ^ ¢fg f [ ] g   g i ` f%` e b 1ae j j%£ f%^ j j Kž ¤ e j l1^'\ b d g f i j '¤ f%` c ` f=^ e d l e \ [ b d e ž ¤ b e g f': + ', #   !  + , " #   # !/ ¥ 0 * # (  >    ( ( # "    %(  C T  %  ,  9 !  + . ! +  #  + 2 . "    ( ()+    "    ! '! +  R  $'  # "  (  " %  "  < ?¦>(  >7     " +  # !# " " #  7      ,    "  %  + # ! "    ,'# '# ! (+ (9# ! 5)#  (( %U     $K 4(    .   ( +  !  7 +  # !2 # " + #  + ! +   *+ '# . .% # " (9%#  " # ! =T  (  +   5)     "'#A(  # ! !)  $ + Y% #  +  L ,  4(  " %  " K$ + (  " %(   13  5§$ + (  " +   +  8?L& + (  .%1 ,> B  "  K(  %( +  + 2 +    ,)  1(  (   › K7     " 4%# (# ! ( K%  L$    %(  " #   $ + A#      "     B  / F 0 ?¨ % KY %$ +  71+ (    .%  ,! + 7    %# '.   ( +  (1 # W(   $L W#   B  "   !     . !  BL. "   C !  ©# ( + 1$    %(  " #   ( %#  .   ( +  !  7 +  # !"  7 ! #  +  L+ (    $  $?K& + (9"  7 ! #  +  4'# K%1#   +  2  $4  "  7 =# $  C T %#  .  . +  7' # ! (   1# $ # .  #  +  1 ,# + " 5)# 1$ + #   C   " ( * #, #  )R   5)'   B + (  ? >?mK# "  %ª *mA?M8+ !     ª « ¬ *­%?%¨?¦)%$ " # $  ­ " ? ª « ® *# %$K>? ¨ # .% 2 # ! ª « ¬ ª ;>? mA? ¯? ¦9? * °  ! V) " '# ! ¨ .) ± " +  " $ >;#  %# 8* ;V>S)¨* ;#  %# 8* M " # %  ¬ ²? mA? ;>? * °  ! ² !       + T  *%;V>S)¨*%²# ! # + (  # 8* M " # %  ® P> .%# "  #    >$ M)³ ± ( +  # * ´) + 2  " ( + $ # $ M  $  " # ! $ ; # "%# ± * M  "  # !  µ # * " # µ + ! S   + 2  $'¥ F ¨  .   9% ">¥ G G F ¶ .  ! + (   $1· · PX> @ · · ¸ ²  ( S) 2 ¯   ? ¹ G ? º » G ²¦>;¨  % " ( @ º ¼ ? I G ? ½)+ * » ¼ ? ¹ ? ´)2 ™ t š¾v… ƒ y ¿ w ƒx q‹r s }  y ƒ ˆ ÿ's ƒ{ { n%s o r † w} | Ä … Å s ˆ%ˆ tÀ Æ ƒ Ç Á t ƒ Ž Ât€ ‘   r Ž x Ž  È s– ƒ À r ƒ ˆ x € ¾ƒ Á x ~ }  x † ˆ ™  š¾t Ö ƒ Ö Á × x – ~ ƒ }  x † ˆÉ Ê Ë Ì Í Î Ï Ð Ñ Ë Ò Í Ó Ï>Í Ò Ô Î Ð Õ Ò Ð Ñ Í Ï)‘ n%† x z9z9x r o } € ˆ vx r o w ˆ ™ È šÚ)¾ƒx { ¿ q r x s q ˆ r Û } Üy ˆ)Ý ˆ ¿'Þ ÈƒÈ n%o‘ †  } Ž | Ž … Æ s – ˆ)ƒ ؃‹)ƒÙ1s o Š s † ˆ)x € A¾ƒÁ x ~ }  x † ˆ