Biosensors, biocompatibilization of materials, and surface science require the investigation of the sorption processes and the 3-D organization of proteins at solid/liquid interface.
Many qualitative methods but few quantitative methods and even fewer real-time measurements ! Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
http://www.aad.org/education/CollagenFigure1.htm
Collagen
Fibrinogen
Fibrillar protein of the extracellular matrix
Blood protein
Triple helix 300 nm long 1.5 nm diameter Weight ~ 300 kDa
Three globular domains linked by fibrillar segments Weight ~ 340 kDa
Forms elastic fibers
Causes blood clotting
How to investigate in liquids the behavior of adsorbed proteins ? Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
A novel biosensor platform integrating Love mode acoustic wave and surface plasmon resonance for the investigation of protein layers Laurent FRANCIS*1,2, Jean-Michel FRIEDT3, Carmen BARTIC2, Patrick BERTRAND1, Andrew CAMPITELLI2 1 PCPM,
Université catholique de Louvain, Belgium 2 Biosensors Group, IMEC, Belgium 3 LMN, Université de Franche-Comté, France
Biosensors 2004 – Grenada, Spain – May 26th, 2004 Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
OUTLINE
Introduction
Love mode surface acoustic wave (SAW) Structure and characteristics Sensitivity enhancement
Surface plasmon resonance (SPR)
Combined SAW/SPR Technique Method Application to collagen and fibrinogen
Conclusions
Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
SURFACE ACOUSTIC WAVE
SAW
SURFACE PLASMON RESONANCE
SPR
Label-free sensing on a common surface increased system integration fast analysis low analyte volume identical event simplicity of sample preparation Real time measurement adsorption kinetic dynamic evolution of the layer Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
LOVE MODE SAW SENSOR: STRUCTURE Overcoated SAW delay line is a mass sensitive device. Shear horizontal polarized acoustic wave that results in low loss with liquid loading. Substrates: α-SiO2, LiNbO3, LiTaO3 Guiding layers: SiO2, polymers/epoxies, ZnO Delay line structure
Experimental transfer function h
I.L.
Phase
φ
Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
LOVE MODE SAW SENSOR: CHARACTERISTICS The dispersion of Love mode is ruled by - the acoustic velocity V2 = µ / ρ - the acoustic impedance Z2 = ρ ∗ µ Mechanical properties are function of - the selected guiding materials; - the structure (processing parameters, i.e. PECVD).
Experimental phase velocity (m/s)
Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
Normalized thickness h/λ
LOVE MODE SAW SENSOR: MASS SENSITIVITY Mass sensitivity
λ
∆φ ⋅ S= 360o D m
λ acoustic wavelength D sensing length m surface density
Strong dispersion = high sensitivity: - H-rich PECVD SiO2 (reduced stiffness); - Gold (low velocity). Gold (50 nm) PECVD SiO2 ST-cut Quartz
S (cm2/g) Solid line = simulation Dot = experimental Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
Thickness SiO2 (µm) with λ = 40 µm
SURFACE PLASMON RESONANCE SENSOR Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) is an optical method where collective electromagnetic modes are excited by a light source at metal-dielectric interface. SPR is sensitive to the thickness d and the refractive index n of dielectric added layers above specific metals (gold, silver, …). Simulated SPR signal Buffer Gold Prism Laser
θ Light intensity (a.u.)
∆θ SPR Angle θ (degrees) Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
COMBINED SAW/SPR: SET-UP
EC cell SAW
SPR
SAW
SPR
modified IBIS II SPR (IBIS Technologies BV)
ST-cut quartz substrate 1.2 µm H-rich SiO2 10 nm Ti/ 50 nm Au wavelength 40 µm SU8/glass IDT capping
670 nm laser light Kretschmann configuration Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
Cu-calibrated mass sensitivity of –260 cm2/g
COMBINED SAW/SPR: EXPERIMENTAL EXAMPLE Collagen 30 µg/ml adsorption on hydrophobic surface
SAW Phase φ
∆φ
SPR Angle θ
∆θ
Time (s) Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
SAW/SPR MODELING
Au sensing surf. SAW
SPR
d = thickness of the layer (protein + water) d x = proportion of proteins in the layer ρ = density n = refractive index
Linear combination of the protein and the water: density refractive index
ρ ( x ) = x ρ PROTEIN + (1 − x ) ρWATER n( x ) = x nPROTEIN + (1 − x ) nWATER
The SAW shift ∆φ gives the surface density m of the layer:
λ m= ∆φ = ρ ( x ) d o 360 DS The SPR shift ∆θ is simulated from d and n(x). Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
SAW/SPR MODELING
x 100%
x 50%
SPR
x 10%
∆θ
d 1) Simulated SPR shifts ∆θ (d,x) 2) Experimental SPR shift 3) Allowed values for SAW shifts ∆φ (d,x) 4) Extraction of thickness d and protein content % Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS In-situ measurements of collagen and fibrinogen adsorbed on hydrophobic surfaces:
STRONG HYDRAT.
STACKED LAYERS
“DRY” LAYERS FOR SAW CALIB.
Analyte (µg/ml) Collagen 30 µg/ml Collagen 300 µg/ml Fibrinogen 46 µg/ml Fibrinogen 460 µg/ml
Surface density m (ng/cm2)
Thickness d (nm)
Protein content x (%)
1750 ± 150
16 ± 3
25 ± 15
2100 ± 200
19 ± 3
35 ± 10
750 ± 100
6 ± 1.5
50 ± 10
1500 ± 500
13 ± 2
50 ± 10
S-layer
560 ± 20
4.7 ± 0.7
75 ± 15
CTAB
135 ± 15
1 ± 0.1
100
Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS: ADSORPTION KINETICS
Normalized SAW
Normalized SPR The kinetic of the adsorption monitored by the two techniques is different: - wrong model ? Viscous effects neglected in the SAW ! - mass over/underestimation. Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
DISCUSSION: DRAWBACKS OF THE TECHNIQUES SAW drawbacks - high temperature sensitivity - rigid mass and viscous effects combined - signal distortion due to interferences - different phase and group velocities SPR drawbacks - temperature dependence - signal distortion due to birefringence - optical interferences for multiple layers - data extraction through modeling - limited to metal surfaces (gold, silver) Combined technique - no interferences between SAW and SPR - complementary information allowing extraction of coupled parameters (ρ, n → x, d) on a same layer
Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
DISCUSSION: LOVE MODE SAW MATERIAL COMBINATIONS SPR angle is function of n and of the light wavelength. Interferences and total internal reflection effects must be considered for a stack of layers. SPR sensitivity higher for θ closer to 90°. Conductive layers influence the SAW transfer function by shortcutting the transducers.
Light intensity (a.u.)
Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
SPR Angle θ (degrees)
CONCLUSIONS
Combined SAW/SPR technique: provides
information about the thickness and water content of protein layers;
real
time measurements, with some insights into the adsorption kinetics;
label-free
acoustic and optical method.
Ways to increase the Love mode SAW mass sensitivity: H-rich PECVD SiO2 Gold
Experimental results on collagen and fibrinogen adsorption demonstrate the potential and the limits of the combined technique.
Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS R. Giust (LOPMD, Université de Franche-Comté, France) for SPR simulation routines; M. Sára (Center for NanoBiotechnology, University of Vienna, Austria) for the S-layers; F.R.I.A. (Belgium) for financial support.
Slides of this presentation available at URL http://friedtj.free.fr/chua/biosensors2004.pdf or by e-mail :
[email protected] Laurent FRANCIS – Biosensors 2004