El 107
ACTA POLYTECHNICA SCANDINAVICA ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING SERIES No. 107
0DJQHWLF)LHOG$QDO\VLVRI(OHFWULF0DFKLQHV7DNLQJ)HUURPDJQHWLF +\VWHUHVLVLQWR$FFRXQW
JÚLIUS SAITZ Helsinki University of Technology Laboratory of Electromechanics P.O.Box 3000 FIN-02015 HUT Finland
Dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Science in Technology to be presented with due permission for public examination and debate in Auditorium S1 at Helsinki University of Technology (Espoo, Finland) on the 6th of November, 2001, at 12 o’clock.
ESPOO 2001
G 0'"&KB*LJ*!"#$%&'()*'%+,)-$"+./'/)01)2+%(&3'()!"(4'$%/)5"6'$#)*%3307"#$%&'()8./&%3%/'/ '$&0)-((09$&J*:/&'*M(23&$/,)"/'*0/')-")'?"/'B*A2$/&%"/'2*A).")$$%").*0$%"$#*F(J*;HNB*A#5(( GHH;B*;G3*5J*M742"#,$-*43*&,$*C"))"#,*:/'-$8"$#*(+*1$/,)(2(.3J O0PF*QR;SEEESRTUSNB*O00F*HHH;SETVR W$36(%-#X* $2$/&%"/* 8'/,")$#B* +$%%(8'.)$&"/* ,3#&$%$#"#B* +")"&$* $2$8$)&* ')'23#"#B* 2(##$#B M%$"#'/,*8(-$2#
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
\*:22*%".,&#*%$#$%?$-J*F(*5'%&*(+*&,"#*5742"/'&"()*8'3*4$*%$5%(-7/$-B*#&(%$-*")*'*%$&%"$?'2*#3#&$8B*(%*&%')#8"&&$-B ")*')3*+(%8*(%* 43* ')3* 8$')#B* $2$/&%()"/B* 8$/,')"/'2B* 5,(&(/(53").B* %$/(%-").B* (%* (&,$%6"#$B* 6"&,(7&* &,$* 5%"(% 5$%8"##"()*(+*&,$*'7&,(%J
U
;3%1"(% 1,"#* 6(%=* 6'#* /'%%"$-* (7&* ")* &,$* ]'4(%'&(%3* (+* A2$/&%(8$/,')"/#* '&* )"?$%#"&3* (+ 1$/,)(2(.3J* 1,$* 6(%=* "#* 5'%&* (+* '* %$#$'%/,* 5%(^$/&* /()/$%)").* 2(##$#* ")* %(&'&").* $2$/&%"/ 8'/,")$#J O* 6(72-* 2"=$* &(* $95%$##* 83* .%'&"&7-$* &(* M%(+$##(%* 1'5')"* L(=")$)B* /%&(#C!? #>/%&(#C!?
A
/
$%).*4#3(2*'(3#;CDIC?#-'#/%&(#GG
##ϕ "# #ϕ )
6'*)#,(+)-.5#*'#3*.(+)*-'5#&*,('#;/%&(#C!?#%'3#;EDKA?"#.(5/(+)*,(0
%+)*,(?#'-3(5#*'#%#2*'*)(#(0($(')#$(5:
6 +&
'6$;(.#-2#)6.'5#-2#%#+-*0#-2#):(#/:%5(#&
Q
63
'6$;(.#-2#3*.(+)*-'5#>5+%0%.#$-3(05?#*'+063(3#*'#%#,(+)-.#$-3(0#>7*&D#EDE"#/%&(#CQ?
6&
&0-;%0#5:%/(#26'+)*-'#*'#):(#2*'*)(#(0($(')#$():-3#+-..(5/-'3*'&#)-#):(#'-3(#&
6'
):(#)-)%0#'6$;(.#-2#'-3(5#*'#):(#2*'*)(#(0($(')#$(5:
$ 6 )-)
)-)%0#'6$;(.#-2#$(%56.(3#/-*')5#-'#%#0*$*)*'&#+6.,(#>/%&(#CI?
65
'6$;(.#-2#5EDKF?"#/%&(#CQR#)*$(#5)(/
4"#7#
+-06$'#,(+)-.#3(2*'(3#;CDEG?"##1):#+-$/-'(')#-2#4#3(2*'(3#;CDEK?#-'#/%&(#IF
:/%&(#CC?
51,
5+%0%.#:/%&(#EH?
X17T[
X1,(.5*-'#-2#7T[#>/%&(#EH?
MT9
M0%55*+%0#T.(*5%+:#9-3(0#>/%&(#KQ?
]T9
](+)-.#T.(*5%+:#9-3(0#>/%&(#KF?
!!
!""#$%&'()*%+'$ !,!"-.*/0&')$("'1"%23"4%)(5 "#$%&$'()'*(+#,(-'#./#'01#+.$$1$#*)#1+12'-*2#3(20*)1$#*$#'01#+.$$#*)#'01#*-.)#2.-14#5.-#$%221$$/%+ 61$*7)# ./# 1+12'-*2# 3(20*)1$# *'# *$# *3,.-'()'# '.# 71'# ($# (22%-('1# *)/.-3('*.)# (&.%'# '0*$# +.$$# ($ ,.$$*&+14# 801# *)/.-3('*.)# (&.%'# '01# 2.-1# +.$$# *$# 2+.$1+9# -1+('16# '.# '01# :).;+1671# ./# '01 3(7)1'*2#/*1+6#*)#'01#3(20*)14#801-1/.-1-*% $(1'/0
%$$E:
$E:
(" )
I"=UJ
( !)
I"=ZJ
$E:
% .+&%
$E:
% 1*/1*$*+0% $(.7.1% 56&*7$% B61C'+-*%$(.7.1%56&*7%
$
%)$*&%'+%0-'$%B61C%'$%0-*%(7.$$'(.7%;1*'$.(-%56&*7%
$
3%B-'(-%'$%.//7'*&%'+
0-*%1*:*1$*&%&'1*(0'6+ $
( !) = ( $ ( !))
>-*% '+:*1$'6+% 69%
−2
$
I"=[J
% '$% 1*.7'?*&% 84% .% (658'+*&% 8'$*(0'6+E56&'9'*&% S*-'$% 9)+(0'6+% '$% &*0*15'+*&% 9165% .% N,E9'*7&% 5*.$)1*5*+0
[
]
I#//*+&'G%TJ%.+&%'$%&*9'+*&%84%0-*%5*.$)1*&%/.'1$% " #5 3 !#5 3%B-*1*%#%1)+$%9165%2%0-16)-*% !E"% 1*7.0'6+$-'/% '$% (6+$'&*1*&% 06% 8* -4$0*1*0'(%'+%8*0B**+%0-*$*%:.7)*$3%B-*1*.$%.86:*%.+&%8*76B%0-*$*%:.7)*$%0-*%!E"%1*7.0'6+$-'/
!U
'$%56&*7*&%84%.+%.+.740'(.7%$'+-*%7'+*.1%'+0*1/67.0'6+ '$%)$*&%06%(65/)0*%0-*%:.7)*$%74'+-*%'+'0'.7%5.68'#=*
