SPORTPLANE BUILDER
AIRCRAFT WOODWORK BASICS BY TONY BINGELIS
R
ecently, my computer allowed me to stumble onto some online chitchat about homebuilt aircraft, wood, glues, designs to build and stuff like that. I was interested, and quite pleased to find the stuff because I seldom have much control over what my computer decides to do. However, I did feel like a Peeping Tom looking in on the conversations of strangers with them blissfully unaware as to who was reading their opinion-
ated words of wisdom. The familiar topics being discussed piqued my interest for a while until it became apparent to me that the basic information being passed around was sporadic and seldom developed in detail. Technical accuracy usually suffered because of that. I will probably be inviting contempt and possibly sarcasm from computer oriented builders and addicts, but I must say, in my opinion, the so-called
"information super highway" to worthwhile practical information for the average homebuilder simply is not there, yet. That highway may have been engineered but it is still under construction and has yet to be paved. Give me a good set of plans, a technical article, a "How-To-Do" book, or even a video anytime. Any of those options, for me as a builder, would be far more practical
This builder used FPL-16A epoxy adhesive in assembling his fuselage. It is a good glue but since it is a white glue an inspector might mistake it for an unacceptable white carpenter's glue... be prepared to prove that it isn't. SPORT AVIATION 75
LEADING EDGE STRIP
VERTICAL GRAIN
WING RIB GUSSETS (TYPICAL)
WING ROOT PLYWOOD SHEAR WEB ^ CORNER BLOCKS \ (OPTIONAL TYPE)
WING SPAR SECTION (BOX SPAR)
BUILT-UP PLYWOOD RIB
WING COMPONENTS (GRAIN ORIENTATION)
FIGURE 1 SOLID WOOD RIB SOLID WOOD REAR SPAR
and cheaper than the precious hours spent online hopefully scrolling for useful information.
NEW TOPIC Although much information has been printed in Sport Aviation and other EAA publications regarding the construction of wood aircraft, many of the letters I receive continue to raise basic questions similar to those I read online. There is uncertainty over the selection and use of acceptable glues and adhesives. In addition, questions regarding woodworking practices, in general, also seem to crop up.
This is understandable since many new builders and new EAA members who have joined the scene in the past few years have not had access to previous writings and older EAA publications. It seems that most of the new builders and would-be builders who write me are very interested in building some kind of wood aircraft from plans. The most frequently cited reason for their motivation is one of economics .. . that is, they say they cannot honestly justify the purchase of an expensive kit 76 SEPTEMBER 1996
for a homemade airplane. At the same time, many of them point out that they are comfortable working with wood and express the desire to get started with some simple plans-built wood design to gain experience. They go on to say they would then be better prepared to build their dream airplane later. I will, therefore, let this article serve as an open letter to briefly answer a few select woodworking questions these builders have raised.
WHAT GLUE? Most glues used by homebuilders
require curing temperatures of 70°F
and above in order to produce reliable joints. One exception isT-88 epoxy. It will cure, although somewhat slower, in temperatures as low as 35°F. This makes T-88 an ideal choice for builders who have to work in colder climates. As a builder you will be faced with quite a few options when selecting a glue for your project. Your first choice, and it would probably be an excellent one, is to use the glue recommended by the designer. If there is no such recommendation most any of the glues
listed in your aircraft supply catalogs would be O.K. to use (read the descriptive summary for each glue before you make your pick). Some glues are easier to work with than others. For example, glues that require an odd ratio mix of a resin and catalyst can be tricky to mix in small quantities. Ideally, a 1:1 mix is as close to being foolproof as you can get. A couple of good adhesives using this mix are T88 epoxy and APCP Structural Adhesive. Other popular glues include: 1. Resorcinol (Weldwood, Borden, e t c . ) . . . an excellent two-part waterproof glue. Mix by weight is 4 parts liquid to 1 part powder. Resorcinol glues require excellent joints and considerable clamping pressure to ensure good joints. Temperatures must be above 70° for a reliable cure. It is considered to be the most durable and best proven glue in the world.
2. FPL-16A . . . a 10:1 mix epoxy . .. tricky to mix in small amounts. (Since it is a white glue an inspector might mistake it for an unacceptable white carpenter's glue.) 3. Urea-formaldehyde glues have
lost favor in Australia. These include: a. Aerolite, a urea-formaldehyde resin. Good but tricky to use. The British built bombers using this glue in WW-1I. Mix powder with water to form paste. Apply paste to one surface and brush on a catalyst hardener on the other surface. If you forget to brush on the catalyst you may never realize it until a joint fails latef. b. Plastic Resin (Weldwood, etc.) is also a urea-formaldehyde glue. This tan colored powder when mixed with water is ready for use. This has long been considered to be a good, easy to use glue, but it is only water resistant, not waterproof. It is the least expensive glue and is available in many hardware stores. Plastic resin glue has been widely used in thousands of h o m e b u i l t s like the Fly Baby and Pietenpol. Unfortunately, as seems to be the rule lately, familiar old products are often "discovered" to be suspect and "no good no more." So it is with Aerolite and plastic resin. First it was Australia's CAA that determined acid catalyzed phenolic (ACP) or urea formaldehyde (UF) glues (as a class) should not be used in powered homebuilt aircraft because structural failure of ACP glue joints has been the cause of several accidents. The circumstantial evidence against plastic resin is not as strong although it is known that it too reacts chemically to changes in humidity and their long term durability under outdoor climatic conditions is suspect. Anyhow, now it seems that the FAA will agree with Australia that the glue should not be used in homebuilt aircraft because it could deteriorate badly in hot, humid climates. Therefore, if you want to use either urea formaldehyde glue in your project, check with your local FAA office to determine their current attitude about the glues use. Recent letters like the following one point up the quandary that exists in the minds of aspiring builders of wood aircraft. "My problem is in deciding what glue to use (he's building a Boredom Fighter). Many local builders swear by T-88, so I purchased some. I was surprised to read on the label that glued parts should not be used above 150°F. I can sure see the inside of the airplane, especially the wings, if painted a dark
STAPLE OR NAIL EDGES IF STANDARD SANDPAPER SHEETS ARE USED, ADD A DAB OF WHITE GLUE TO SEAMS.
SUGGEST 180 GRIT
k
LEVELING SANDING BLOCK FIGURE 2
color, getting pretty hot in the summer. I also read a recent article in Sport Aviation that sounded a bit negative concerning epoxy glues in general. I sure like working with T-88 and would be very interested in hearing what your thoughts are." I told him of two Boredom Fighters
that were built locally several years ago. They were assembled with T-88 epoxy and plain oF Weldwood Plastic Resin glue. The plastic resin was used for building the wing ribs and attaching gussets and small parts. The major structural components were assembled using T-88.
Designed To Perform, And Out-Perform.
SUPER
ES
Lancair— a company with a ten-year tradition of proven engineering and solid customer support— brings you the spectacular new Lancair Super ES. With its increased horsepower, the Super ES offers a 225-mph cruise speed, spectacular climb rates, and tremendous load-hauling capacity, all with the beauty of a simple, fixed-gear, spacious four-seat aircraft. Plus, you'll still have that very gentle, solid, slow-speed handling that has made the tancair ES so relaxing to fly.
Lancair is represented by Netco Aviation Inc. 2244 Airport Way, Redmond, Oregon 97756 Tel (503) 923-2244 Fax (503) 923-2255 For more information on the Super ES and the entire Lancair family of aircraft you may order our information packet for $15, or video for S20, or both for only $30. For information, use SPORT AVIATON's Reader Service Card
SPORT AVIATION 77
1/4" X 1/2" SPRUCE STRIP
LONGERON
VERTICAL GRAIN SOLID TRAILING EDGE LAMINATED LONGERON
1
FUSELAGE COMPONENTS (TYPICAL)
SADDLE GUSSET
POOR
CORNER BLOCK GRAIN ORIENTATION FUSELAGE CROSS-MEMBER
SADDLE GUSSET
FIGURE 3
LONGERO
HARDWOOD UPRIGHT. FUSELAGE CROSS -SECTIONS 1/8" PLYWOOD CUTAWAY TO SHOW STRUCTURE
-(Ti-if
BELLY STRINGER ATTACHMENT
SPRUCE BLOCK
(TOP VIEW)
MAIN COCKPIT BULKHEAD
they, like other glues, have their drawbacks. Epoxies, in general, are expensive and can be fairly toxic if used carelessly. A number of builders will surely suffer from skin rash and worse due to its use. Working in poorly ventilated enclosed areas is to be avoided. NOTE: Epoxies that most builders use cure at room temperatures and epoxied structures are generally sensitive to heat. That is, they tend to soften (weaken) with higher temperatures. As cited above, T-88 begins to soften
There is no doubt about it. Although properly used resorcinol glue is the most reliable in the world, it can also result in one messy looking structure.
One plane has since been sold and now resides in California (not a cold climate). The other remains in Texas enjoying frequent 100° summer weather. Both aircraft are doing fine, thank you. I think epoxy adhesives are remarkable glues. Quite a few of them are 78 SEPTEMBER 1996
used in the construction of a variety of aircraft, including composites, wood and mixed construction. These glues are cohesive and tough, and adhere tenaciously to most materials. Good reliable joints usually result even with poorly fitted parts and very little clamping pressure. However,
at temperatures above 150°F. Notice I said "soften," and not "comes apart." With that dumb observation still in mind, I recall a builder who wrote how he screwed up part of his T-88 assembled tail structure. He tried to take it apart using his wife's hair dryer, a sun lamp, a heat lamp, etc. All he succeeded in doing was charring the wood, the
structure remained intact, so he said. Anyway, the decision is yours. Whatever glue you use, I suggest making test samples of each batch
used and later demolish them with a hammer to see if the glue joint sepa-
rates or the wood fibers fail. The wood fibers should fail, not the glue line.
GRAIN ORIENTATION This is another area of uncertainty for some builders. The grain orientation in wood parts, plywood webs, gussets and the like is important especially in components like wing spars and other highly stressed locations. Usually, the designer will indicate on the drawings the preferred orienta- When Pete Bowers designed the Fly Baby, he chose to use plastic resin glue in its astion of the surface grain. However, if sembly. Since then hundreds of Fly Babys the world over have been completed using that information is not depicted con- the same adhesive. This is but one nice example of that popular easy-to-build design. sider the merits of the following: In general, plywood bends easier craft joint that must be reinforced with An old government publication along the direction of the surface grain. corner blocks or plywood gussets (see (ANC-19), long out of print, was acThis is because three layer plywood Figure 3). cepted as an authoritative source for will have the grain of the two surface Box spars are enclosed by gluing fabricating wood aircraft. It recomplies running in the same direction. plywood shear webs to each side of the mends that 45° plywood shear webs on Only the center ply will be oriented in solid wood structure. a box spar or I beam spar have the a crosswise direction. It is, therefore, This plywood web is generally laid grain oriented in the direction which sometimes called 90° plywood. on with the grain oriented at a 45° an- will provide stiffening against buckling Plywood whose surface grain runs at gle to the span. There is some due to compression loads. In effect, an angle is termed 45° plywood. Be- difference of opinion as to the most ef- this means the face grain in the plycause of its grain orientation it is stiffer fective grain direction. wood would run from the bottom and doesn't bend easily in any direction. It is more expensive but only slightly stronger than ordinary 90° plywood. Forty-five degree plywood is used for box spars and wing and fuselage skins where stiffness is important. It is EXEC 162F less likely to show signs of bulging or sagging between ribs and uprights due to changes in humidity — an annoying cosmetic condition that does not affect the plywood's serviceability. Tn general, plywood is somewhat stronger along its external grain direction. This is taken into consideration when fitting and attaching gussets and plywood webs to wing ribs and other structure. Grain orientation in solid wood parts You can build an Exec 162F in only 300 hours!... it's fast, easy, and step by step manuals show you exactly how. No special tools no special skills. We can even train you to fly it. Then the exciting world is equally important and can affect the
strength of a glued assembly.
Keep in mind the fact that when joining (gluing) two solid wood pieces together, the strongest joint results when the grain in each part is more or less parallel. When the grain in one piece doesn't parallel the other part, more end grain, is introduced in the joint and a weaker joint results. Obviously, the weakest type of joint is an unreinforced butt joint. For example, trying to glue an upright against a longeron always results in a weak air-
of helioflight will be yours! Take off and land nearly anywhere...hover..fly backwards! The Exec 162F is backed by 25 years of design and manufacturing. Complete kits feature the advanced, liquid cooled powerplant utilizing redundant, electronic fuel injection and ignition (patent pending). Unmatched performance (95 mph cruise), reliability and cost efficiency will be yours at half the cost of any production helicopter. Operating costs are like a fixed wing,
but the extraordinary versatility will allow you into landing sites a fixed wing pilot can only dream about.
Insurance and financing are available. The thrill of rotary flight is unbeatable! We make it affordable! Call now for information: (602) 961-1001; fax (602) 961-1514.
ROTORWAY INTERNATIONAL, 4140 A W. Mercury Way, Chandler, AZ 85226 Yes rush me your a Video $15 J Info pack $153 Both $25 U.S. Overseas add $5
a Check enclosed or a bill MC or Visa# _________________ Exp __ Name______________________ Phone ____________ Address _____._______________________________ For information, use SPORT AVIATION'S Reader Service Card
SPORT AVIATION 79
outward to the top inboard of the spar. They go on to say that if 45° plywood is used it could result in a structure five times stiffer although only slightly stronger. However, it is conceded that the spar webs are often laid on with the face grain perpendicular to the long axis of the spar simply because there is little or no reduction in strength and because of cost considerations. You will find in most wood designs the plywood shear webs on stabilizer, elevator, fin and rudder spars, to be oriented at 90° to their center lines.
,
when you assemble the wing structure, slight vertical rib misalignments may occur and a second line-sanding will be necessary. Unfortunately, this will remove even more of the rib s capstrip weakening it, and possibly altering the wing's aerodynamic shape. Therefore, resist the impulse to linesand the ribs until the wing is finally
Center, Box 3086, Oshkosh, WI 54903-3086,1-800-843-3612. Major credit cards accepted.
-Sportplane Builders (Aircraft
LINE SANDING AND PROFILING
When a wooden wing structure is to be plywood covered its underlying frame usually has to be trued and profiled so that the plywood will contact each rib and wood part smoothly without causing bulges or sags in the plywood skin. Because all of the ribs come from the same rib jig(s), very little profiling will be necessary. A longstanding practice is to use a long sanding block (3' or 4' in length) that spans at least three ribs to "linesand" the ribs in an assembled wing structure in order to level any high spots. NOTE: After wing ribs have been
built, some builders assemble all of the ribs on a short dummy spar and linesand them to a uniform profile. This is not a good practice. Here's why. Later,
assembled and you are readying it for the installation of the plywood skins. Use a rather fine grit for the sanding block as very little material will have to be removed. A sanded soft wood surface in preparation for gluing is considered to be inferior to a smoothly planed one but those amazing epoxies don't know the difference. 4
Construction Methods, 324 pages) #21-30140-$21.95
-Firewall Forward (Engine Installation Methods, 308 pages) #21-13950-$21.95.
-Sportplane Construction
If you wish to contact the author of this column for additional information, please send a SASE to: Tony Bingelis 8509 Greenflint Ln. Austin, TX 78759
Techniques (A Builder's Handbook, 372 pages) #21-01395 $21.95. - Tony Bingelis on Engines (Practical Engine Information) #21-15691-$21.95.
POSTAGE AND HANDLING
Add $6.50 postage and handling for 1 book, $8 (2 books), $11.75 (3 books) or buy all four books (#PLU BOOKSBY TONY 21-15692) for a special price of The following books by Tony $75.95, plus $12.50 postage and Bingelis are available from the EAA handling. Wisconsin residents add Aviation Foundation, EAA Aviation 5% sales tax.
The Original Sport Utility Vehicle
HUSKY
The 140 mph-two-place-carryanything-go-anywhere-easy-tofly FAA certified airplane
A VIA r AIRCRAFT, INC.
is at 7,100 feet
"New
even aboi (208) 524-8924 lax
K.D Johnson
820-D E. Santa Maria SI. Santa Paula. CA 93060 (805) 525-0111
Aero Mark, Inc.*
Bob Holl (Husky only)
1940 International Way Idaho Falls. ID 83402 (208)524 1202
Dent-Air, Ltd.' Bill Finagin 6 Romar Dr.
Annapolis. MO 21403 (410)956-0047 (410) 263-4693 tax
Eagle AirTom Collier (Pins/Husky) 105 Woolman Lane
Griffin, GA 30223 (770)707.1111
Fly For Fun Bill Thomas
400 E. Airport Ave. Venice. FL 34285 (8131493-5896 (813) 485-7410 tax
Flight Dynamics. Inc. Mike Tendick
4900 N. Lilly Rd.
Menomonee Falls. WI 53051
(414)781-7097 (414) 781-6774 fax
Pompano Air Center* Brian Becker I Pitts/Husky) 1401 N.E. Tenth St.
Pompano Beach. FL 33060 (305) 943-6050 i305l 943 0829 tax
For information, use SPORT AVIATION'S Reader Service Card
80 SEPTEMBER 1996
Company. Better Than Ever"
Box 1240. 672 S. Washington Afton. WY83110 (307) 886-3151 • Fax (307) 886-9674 e-mail:
[email protected] Parker Aviation* Jim Parker (Pitts/Husky) Box 311 Sugarbush Airport
Warren. VT 05674 (803) 496 3473 (803) 496-6235 fax
Scott Erickson Aviation* Scott Erickson (Pitts/Husky) N. Omaha Airport
12121 N. 72nd St. Omaha. NE 68122 (402) 573-3333
Attitude Adjusters* Randy Gagne (Pitts/Husky) 16700 RoscoeBlvd Van Nuys. CA 91406 (818)376-1457 (818) 376-1468 fax
