Search for Gravitational Wave Transients - Rencontres de Moriond

Quasi-normal mode oscillations. GW. Both Hanford detectors were up at that time. Ringdown signal is searched → No detection. Upper limits on GW energy ...
4MB taille 3 téléchargements 174 vues
Search for Gravitational Wave Transients Florent Robinet On behalf of the LSC and Virgo Collaborations

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

1

Gravitational Waves Gravitational waves = "ripples" in space­time Weak field approximation :

g = h 

∣h  ∣≪1

Wave equation, speed c Solution with 2 d.o.f. :  h= h+  hx Dimensionless amplitude given by h Black hole merger

Signal strength: h rss=

2 2 ∣h t ∣ ∣h t∣  dt ∫ x  -∞ + +∞

Production of gravitational waves 2 6 5 R c 2 s v ℒ = G R c

  

A good GW source : ­ is compact and massive ­ is asymmetric ­ has a relativistic speed Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

Lab production : 

h ~ 10 – 39

Astrophysical sources :  h ~ 10 – 21 2

Florent Robinet

Gravitational Wave Sources Supernovae (asymmetric core  bounce) 

Pulsars (asymmetric rotations,  instabilities) 

Compact binary  coalescence of neutron  stars &/or black holes Cosmic strings

The unexpected Stochastic background Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

3

?

Florent Robinet

A Network of Detectors Virgo (3 km)

LSC – Virgo collaboration – Full data sharing since May 2007 – Common analyses and papers – Common tools

Livingston (4 km)

Geo (600 m)

Hanford (4&2 km)

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

4

Florent Robinet

A Network of Detectors SOURCE POINTING ● Source location within ~ tens of square degrees ● Serious candidates follow­up (EM, neutrinos...)

tVirgo

SOURCE

tLivingston GHOST

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

tHanford

5

Florent Robinet

A Network of Detectors Hanford sky coverage – Antenna pattern

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

6

Florent Robinet

A Network of Detectors Livingstone sky coverage – Antenna pattern

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

7

Florent Robinet

A Network of Detectors Virgo sky coverage – Antenna pattern

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

8

Florent Robinet

A Network of Detectors Network sky coverage – Antenna pattern

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

9

Florent Robinet

LIGO / Virgo Science Runs

S4

2006

2007

2008

commissioning

2005

S5

VSR1 Many Publications

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

2009

2010

2011

2012

S6 Advanced Detectors

VSR2 VSR3 VSR4? Analyses in progress Publications in preparation

10

Florent Robinet

LIGO / Virgo Science Runs

S6 - VSR2

S5 - VSR1

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

11

Florent Robinet

Analysis Groups

? Compact Binary Coalescence (CBC)

Short Signals (Bursts)

Continuous Waves

Stochastic

See C. Palomba's talk

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

12

Florent Robinet

Analysis Groups

? Compact Binary Coalescence (CBC)

Low Mass

Short Signals (Bursts)

High Mass

All sky Multi-Messenger Astronomy

GRB-triggered Parameter Estimation

Inspiral-MergerRingdown (IMR)

Supernovae

SGR Flares Pulsars Glitches EM Follow-up

Binary Mergers Cosmic Strings

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

Florent Robinet

CBC vs. Bursts Burst Signals

Compact Binary Coalescence (CBC) The Signals ● Modeled signals ● Inspiral – Merger – Ringdown

The Signals ● Short-duration signals (8)

Specific vetoes based on auxiliary channels have been produced to remove specific glitch families Veto safety have been carefully checked (we don't want to flag real signals!)

10

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

21

SNR

100

Florent Robinet

CBC Searches

BNS BBH BHNS

S5/VSR1 data have been analyzed and results are published "Realistic" observable BNS coalescence rate ~ 0.02 per year (large uncertainty)

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

S6/VSR2-3 analyses are in progress Preliminary results are released See T. Dent's talk 22

Florent Robinet

CBC: Low Mass Search Description of the search:

No Detection

Non-spinning templates ● Post-Newtonian up to the innermost stable orbit ● Mass region 2 < M < 35 Msun total ●

Phys. Rev. D 82(2010) 102001

BNS/BBH Upper limits

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

NS/BH Upper limits

23

Florent Robinet

CBC: High Mass Searches High-Mass ● Effective One Body (EOB) waveforms ● Inspiral-Merger-Ringdown is covered ● No spin ● Mass region 25 < M < 100 Msun total ● Uncertainty on the waveforms ● LIGO only search (Virgo is not sensitive enough for High mass systems)

arXiv:1102.3781 Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

24

Ringdown search ● In progress for S5 ● LIGO only search ● Mass region 75 < MBH < 750 Msun ● Spin is included ● The ringdown contains most of the GW energy ● More reliable waveforms Florent Robinet

CBC & Burst Signals: GRB Triggered Searches Powerful bursts of highly energetic gamma rays Two populations: short and long duration Short: possibly produced by the merging of binary objects → CBC colored search Long: possibly produced by violent stellar collapse (hypernovae)

Number of Bursts

Long-duration Short-duration GRBs GRBs 60

Use mainly Swift and Fermi triggers to get a source location a timing and sometimes a distance Background reduction Better sensitivity

40

During S5/VSR1 137 GRBs were analyzed by the burst coherent pipeline (short and long). See M. Was's talk

20

0.1

1 10 T90 (seconds)

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

22 GRBs were analyzed by a CBC pipeline. See N. Christensen's talk 25

Florent Robinet

CBC & Burst Signals: GRB Triggered Searches GRB 070201 Short and hard GRB detected by 4 satellites in Feb. 2007 in direction of the Andromeda galaxy

The binary merger scenario is excluded with a 99% confidence level! Astrophys. J. 681(2008) 1419 Inspiral Exclusion Zone 25% 50% 75% 90%

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

26

99%

Florent Robinet

Burst Signals: All-Sky Search Upper limit (sine-gaussian)

Description of the search ● Multiple Algorithms ● Broad-band frequency search ● Coincident and coherent searches ● Very large variety of waveforms ● Robustness

Rate (90% C.L.) vs. frequency (EGW = Msunc2)

No detection With a 90% confidence level, the rate of burst signals with 50 < f < 2048 Hz is lower than 2 events per year

1e-2 yr-1 Mpc-3

~8e-7 yr-1 Mpc-3

Phys. Rev. D 81(2010) 102001 Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

27

100

f(Hz)

1000

Florent Robinet

Burst Signals: Neutron Stars 2006/08/12: timing glitch observed in the radio emission of the Vela pulsar Quasi-normal mode oscillations

GW

Both Hanford detectors were up at that time Ringdown signal is searched → No detection Upper limits on GW energy released by monoharmonic modes Phys. Rev. D83(2011) 042001

Soft Gamma Repeaters (SGR) / Anomalous X-ray Pulsars (AXP) Neutron stars powered by extreme magnetic fields (magnetars) SGR 1900+14 SGR 0418+5729 SGR 1627-41 SGR 1806-20 SGR 0501+4516 AXP 1E 1547.0-4508

46

6 magnetars have been analyzed by a dedicated pipeline (excess power)

52

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

28

arXiv:1011.4079 Florent Robinet

Burst Signals: Cosmic String Cusps When 2 cosmic string segments meet they can reconnect and produce loops. The main mechanism for the loop to loose its energy is to radiate gravitationally.

GW radiation is the most promising signature to detect cosmic strings. GW

Points of the string can acquire a large Lorentz boost and form a "cusp" → GW burst

GW Well-modeled signal Template burst search Dedicated pipeline Upper limits on the cosmic string parameter space:

S5 Projection

Gμ: String tension

S4

ε: loop size parameter p: reconnection probability Phys Rev D 80(2009) 062002 Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011



30

10 –7

10 –6

Florent Robinet

Online Searches Hanford h(t)

Livingstone

Virgo

h(t)

Low latency searches took place during S6 / VSR2-3 for both CBC and burst searches

h(t)

Central Location h(t)

CBC pipeline MBTA event

h(t)

Burst pipeline Omega

h(t)

Burst pipeline Coherent Waveburst

event

event

Candidate Database

~ 30 min

Most significant events were sent to telescopes / satellites (14 events for S6/VSR2-3) Sky localization is performed with a resolution of ~tens of square degrees for events at threshold Image analysis is performed within the collaboration

Most significant Candidate selection

See M. Branchesi's talk

Swift

Zadko

ROTSE

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

Florent Robinet

S6/VSR2-3 Science Run

Improved sensitivity ~ 200 days of live-time with at least 2 detectors up Big challenge: run analyses online – 3 pipelines were running (2 bursts + 1 CBC) – The data quality was performed with low latency (< 1 min) – EM follow-up by partner telescopes Offline analyses are in progress (some results are released) Analyses pipelines and data quality tools have been improved for a better sensitivity Blind hardware injection challenge was successful (we detected it with great confidence). See T. Dent's talk

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

31

Florent Robinet

Preparation for Advanced Detectors Era Sensitivity improvement by a factor 10 This translates into a detection rate up to 40 neutron star binary events per year Science should resume in 2015 Design sensitivity achieved by 2019

What are we going to do in the meantime ? Virgo might run this summer (VSR4) along with the GEO detector Similar sensitivity at high frequency This run could be of some interest for external triggered searches Then GEO will run alone in astrowatch mode during the construction of Adv. detectors (2012-2015) Some mock data runs are planned to test and improve our searches A lot of work is required to optimize the EM-followup procedures

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

32

Florent Robinet

Summary - Conclusions A large variety of physical results have been produced from the LIGO-Virgo data There is no detection yet but upper limits can be used to constrain astrophysical models The first generation of detectors is close to the end. – Analysis pipeline have greatly improved over the last years to perform optimized and sensitive searches on GW data – Data quality is a great challenge. Multiple tools have been developed to reject noise events efficiently. – GW astronomy is on its way: online searches, Multi-messengers, EM followup Now, the big challenge is to be fully ready for the Advanced Detectors Era

Rencontres de Moriond - March 2011

33

Florent Robinet