Are Vanikoro languages Are Vanikoro ... - Alexandre Francois

hinua fiabasa ini. *pulu-ña his/her hair. *maturuR sleep bu mate die lü-nə huru-na mətür mauru met mae. *kamiu rua you two. *qatop sago palm kəmýr ɣamirua.
755KB taille 1 téléchargements 321 vues
Are Vanikoro languages really y Austronesian?

A.L.L.2 ~ UKARG Oxford, 3rd June 2006

Alexandre FRANÇOIS

LACITO — C.N.R.S — Paris

Presentation „

D Darrell ll Tryon T (1994: 635) says: “The status of the six languages of Utupua and Vanikoro is in no doubt. These are clearly y Austronesian languages g g by any standards.” standards.”

„

Focusing on the languages of Vanikoro Vanikoro, I'd I d like to show there is room for doubt on that assumption: ƒ either the languages of Vanikoro are not Austronesian ƒ or if they indeed are Austronesian Austronesian,, this is anything but ‘clear’, because most of their AN characteristics have disappeared.

„

This paper will not come up with definite conclusions: at least I'd like to show there is a problem to be solved by future future research —ap problem overlooked byy former accounts.

Meso--Melanesian Meso

South--East Solomonic South

‘Eastern Outer Islands’ ??

• ‘East East Papuan Papuan’ languages • Oceanic early migrations • Polynesian outliers

North Central Vanuatu

?

The three languages of Vanikoro „

The three languages of Vanikoro ƒ Teanu (Buma) ƒ Lovono L (Vano) ƒ Tanema

my text corpus

14300 words 1410 words od 1133 words

800 speakers 4 speakers k 3 speakers

„

Although these 3 languages share the same syntax, they show spectacular formal (lexical, morphological) diversity.

„

Example

‘We were in our garden, we've been planting crops.’ 1exc:pl-stay in 1exc:pl TEA LVN TNM

Pi-te Nupe-lu Tei-o

garden

our

1exc:pl-plant food 1exc:pl

ne sekele iupa, pi-wowo none. ne amenonga iemitore, nupe-ngoa nane. ini vasangola akegamuto, ti-oa bauva.

The three languages of Vanikoro „

Before even looking at the relations of Vanikoro with external languages, this spectacular formal diversity within Vanikoro is in itself a puzzle that deserves to be solved in the future.

„

This situation recalls (at least impressionistically) the diversity found between Papuan languages – much more so than between any two close AN languages. g g

„

For methodological reasons, I will essentially focus on one language in thi demonstration: this d t ti T Teanu. Teanu . It can be seen as representative of the 3 languages, at least regarding g their AN status. the difficulty of proving

Searching for Oceanic cognates „

Observing the lexicon of Teanu: ƒ Most lexical items seem disconnected from any known POc etyma.

ƒ Only 87 items (out of 1100) retained my attention as of possible Oceanic origin. ƒ 87 is not negligible l bl (indeed these items are often cited as evidence that Teanu is Oceanic) Oceanic)

ƒ but this corresponds to only 7.9 9 percent of the lexicon lexicon, which is close to the margin of error (chance and borrowing)

ƒ Moreover: M Among these 87 items, phonological correspondences are irregular and often require ad hoc hypotheses.

Searching for Oceanic cognates POc

Kahua

Teanu

Lo--Toga Lo

[S.E.Solomonic]

[Vanikoro]

[N.C.Vanuatu]

pepane

nənorə

yesterday

*nañorap

nanora

red

*meRaq

memera

snake

*mwata

mwa

abilo

ŋwetə

village

*panua

hi hinua

k l kulumoe

ß ü ßənüə

bamboo

*qauR

ɣau

die

*mate mate

mae

*maturuR

mauru

his/her hair

*pulu-ña

huru-na

sago palm

*qatop

sleep

you two

*kamiu rua

məmi

ɔ -bu

met mətür

fiabasa ini

lü-nə

ao

et

ɣamirua

kəmýr

Searching for Oceanic cognates POc

Kahua

Teanu

Lo--Toga Lo

[S.E.Solomonic]

[Vanikoro]

[N.C.Vanuatu]

yesterday

*nañorap

nanora

pepane

nənorə

red

*meRaq

memera

moloe

məmi

snake

*mwata

mwa

abilo

ŋwetə

village

*panua

hi hinua

k l kulumoe

β ü βənüə

bamboo

*qauR

ɣau

okoro

ɔ

die

*mate mate

mae

-bu

met

*maturuR

mauru

-mokoiu

mətür

his/her hair

*pulu-ña

huru-na

fiabasa ini

lü-nə

sago palm

*qatop

ao

otovo

et

ɣamirua

kela

kəmʊr

sleep

you two

*kamiu rua

Searching for Oceanic cognates POc

Kahua

Teanu

Lo--Toga Lo

[S.E.Solomonic]

[Vanikoro]

[N.C.Vanuatu]

yesterday

*nañorap

nanora

pepane

nənorə

red

*meRaq

memera

molloe mo

məmi

snake

*mwata

mwa

abilo

ŋwetə

village

*panua

hi hinua

k l kulumoe

β ü βənüə

bamboo

*qauR

ɣau

okoro

ɔ

die

*mate mate

mae

-bu

met

*maturuR

mauru

-mok mokoiu

mətür

his/her hair

*pulu-ña

huru-na

fiabasa ini

lü-nə

sago palm

*qatop

ao

( )otovo )otovo

et

ɣamirua

kela

kəmʊr

sleep

you two

*kamiu rua

Searching for Oceanic cognates menuko ma luro aele uo

‘bird’ ‘arm, hand’ ‘coconut’ coconut ‘leg, foot’ ‘yam’

< < < <