a^\ Zg] @nZg`anZ bg ik^&^qi^kb^g\^ kZgdbg`

Financial Times Global Masters in Finance 2012-post-experience programmes. The top ... Rank in 2012. Rank in ..... OTZKXTGZOUTGR JO\KXYOZ_ XGZK LUX.
252KB taille 5 téléchargements 240 vues
;>C6C8>6A I>B:H BDC96N ?JC: &- '%&'

*

ġ

Business Education: Financial Training Financial Times Global Masters in Finance 2012-post-experience programmes The top Masters in Finance programmes

1 2 -

125,481 71,250 63,147 57,000

55 55 59 48

1 4 3 2

3 1 4 2

84 90 83 88

3 2 4 1

84 (100) 91 (77) 33 (95) 31 (63)

22 30 22 33

24 35 48 22

25 12 25 27

84 24 14 56

95 66 88 51

72 2 2 0

1 2 3 4

1 2 2 2

100 98 99 84

12 12 12 12

Rank in 2012

Company internships (%)*

Course length (months)*

Faculty with doctorates (%)

International course experience rank

International mobility rank

International board (%)

International experience & research

International students (%)

International faculty (%)

Women board (%)

Women students (%)

Employed at three months (%)

Women faculty (%)

School diversity

Placement success rank

Aims achieved (%)

Master in Finance Master of Science in Finance Master of Science in Finance Master of Science in Finance

Careers rank

UK US US US

Value for money rank

London Business School George Washington University University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Florida International University: Chapman

Salary percentage increase

Salary today (US$)

Programme name

1 2 -

Country

1 2 3 4

School name

Average rank (2 years)

Rank in 2011

Rank in 2012

Alumni career progress

0 0 53 0

1 2 3 4

Footnotes: *Data in these columns are for information only and are not used in the rankings

Financial Times Global Masters in Finance 2012 - pre-experience programmes The top 35 Masters in Finance programmes

26 9 14 51 28 31 26 54 41 58 29 38 37 24 50 21 57 18 28 36 42 36 43 15 58 22 26 63 84 30 27 32 29 57 32

12 26 10 38 25 19 36 3 53 12 21 27 44 20 33 11 15 7 25 40 17 22 17 14 47 16 5 15 31 9 33 0 29 17 17

57 91 33 96 47 54 25 10 87 96 97 72 91 53 91 19 83 51 70 84 17 18 95 39 94 32 27 97 99 37 92 23 35 94 59

56 81 57 50 67 81 43 67 47 12 36 50 56 30 42 89 8 0 21 40 75 22 8 0 37 100 37 31 19 26 33 0 0 17 52

10 17 3 27 9 2 7 20 4 30 30 5 29 15 21 18 13 16 14 19 6 1 30 30 25 11 8 23 30 30 22 12 24 26 28

Faculty with doctorates (%)

5 15 3 1 18 6 8 32 7 19 17 9 13 11 12 25 2 4 10 14 33 28 20 29 23 30 16 21 26 35 24 34 31 27 22

Languages

International board (%)

International students (%)

International faculty (%) 65 54 45 56 78 52 68 12 43 60 47 38 81 80 65 51 39 15 39 51 25 42 36 35 65 25 29 40 52 32 38 18 51 48 39

0 0 1 0 2 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 2 2 0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

100 95 94 97 75 94 93 94 79 97 90 75 94 100 94 98 90 99 100 51 88 97 77 98 96 93 88 91 100 88 77 77 97 85 97

Rank in 2012

27 32 29 13 10 34 35 26 40 35 32 45 28 31 27 30 39 15 18 31 31 39 40 21 30 27 37 29 35 35 33 10 14 35 21

Women board (%)

Women students (%)

Women faculty (%)

Employed at three months (%)

1 96 (76) 11 94 (100) 6 92 (90) 19 98 (96) 2 100 (55) 5 89 (88) 9 94 (95) 3 100 (100) 29 92 (75) 17 88 (49) 32 81 (60) 31 93 (90) 10 87 (86) 18 100 (48) 16 83 (86) 4 85 (100) 23 62 (87) 22 93 (49) 14 92 (55) 33 82 (83) 8 87 (85) 7 97 (100) 27 94 (94) 13 89 (94) 26 86 (76) 20 93 (86) 12 100 (36) 25 78 (63) 24 92 (91) 21 72 (84) 15 94 (53) 34 100 (71) 30 82 (77) 28 91 (85) 35 90 (64)

Company internships (%)*

92 94 90 91 94 86 87 88 88 86 85 86 89 83 89 88 90 90 85 89 88 78 86 85 85 81 79 88 84 85 85 78 79 85 82

Course length (months)*

2 1 3 14 8 15 18 31 12 6 4 9 27 16 23 7 21 19 20 5 11 28 10 22 24 25 33 26 30 17 29 13 32 34 35

International experience & research International course experience rank

1 10 6 13 2 12 9 3 31 20 8 14 27 7 22 16 35 5 4 17 19 23 18 29 25 15 32 30 26 34 21 28 11 33 24

School diversity

International mobility rank

93,680 91,262 74,249 91,213 77,703 58,786 65,062 96,802 56,576 72,043 79,612 55,878 66,874 65,728 62,258 57,590 69,274 67,812 59,680 58,993 52,654 39,559 61,716 69,648 41,388 54,764 53,787 43,728 40,909 65,770 40,929 70,673 49,053 30,455 41,730

Placement success rank

Masters in International Finance Master in Finance Advanced Master in Financial Techniques MSc in Financial Economics Master of Arts HSG in Banking and Finance MSc in Finance Advanced Master in Finance Master of Finance MSc in Finance The Warwick MSc in Finance Masters in Finance and Management MSc Financial Markets and Investments MSc Finance Master of Science in Finance Masters in Finance Specialised Master in Corporate Finance Master of Arts in International Economics & Finance Master of Science in Finance and Accounting RSM MSc Finance & Investments Master in International Finance Master in Finance Masters in Science MSc International Securities, Investment and Banking Master of Science in Finance MSc Finance and Investment Master in Financial Management Master of Science in Finance MSc Finance MSc in Accounting & Finance Master of Finance Strathclyde MSc Finance Master of Finance Master in Finance MSc Finance and Investment MSc Finance

Aims achieved (%)

France Spain France/Singapore UK Switzerland France France/UK/Germany/Spain/Italy China France UK UK France UK Switzerland UK France US Sweden/Russia Netherlands Spain Poland Portugal UK US UK Belgium Italy UK UK US UK Germany Netherlands UK Ireland

Careers rank

HEC Paris IE Business School Essec Business School University of Oxford: Saïd University of St Gallen Edhec Business School ESCP Europe Peking University: Guanghua Grenoble Graduate School of Business Warwick Business School Cranfield School of Management Skema Business School Imperial College Business School HEC Lausanne City University: Cass EM Lyon Business School Brandeis University Stockholm School of Economics RSM, Erasmus University Eada Kozminski University Nova School of Business and Economics Henley Business School Washington University: Olin Durham Business School Vlerick Leuven Gent Management School Università Bocconi Lancaster University Management School University of Bath School of Management Tulane University: Freeman University of Strathclyde Business School Frankfurt School of Finance and Management Tilburg University Nottingham University Business School University College Dublin: Smurfit

Value for money rank

Salary today (US$)

Programme name

Average rank (2 years) 1 2 2 4 8 7 8 8 14 10 10 14 13 13 16 16 18 18 22 25 22 22 26 28 26 28 28 32

Country

1 2 3 4 12 7 6 5 18 9 8 13 11 10 14 15 16 17 22 29 21 19 28 27 23 26 24 30

School name

1 2 2 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 21 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35

Rank in 2011

Rank in 2012

Alumni career progress

8 10 12 9 18 8 11 22 21 12 11 12 12 24 12 7 21 22 12 10 21 12 9 10 12 10 22 12 12 10 12 24 10 12 12

98 14 100 0 57 100 100 91 79 0 6 100 16 65 0 100 45 0 28 21 37 59 0 0 0 100 100 0 0 0 9 63 15 1 16

1 2 2 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 21 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35

Footnotes: *Data in these columns are for information only and are not used in the rankings. Although the headline ranking figures show the relative postions of each institution, the pattern of clustering among the schools is equally significant. Some 193 points separate the top programmes, HEC Paris, from the school ranked number 35. The top 7 participants, from HEC to ESCP Europe, form the top group of pre-experience Masters in Finance providers. The second group, headed by Peking University: Guanghua, spans schools ranked from 8 to 23, a range of some 37 points in total. Differences between schools are small within this group. The remaining 12 schools headed by Washington University: Olin make up the third group.

>]a^\ Zg] @nZg`anZ bg ik^&^qi^kb^g\^ kZgdbg`l FZlm^kl bg ?bgZg\^ I^dbg`Ìl `kZ]nZm^l Z\ab^o^ ma^ ab`a^lm Zo^kZ`^ lZeZkr% pkbm^l EZnk^gm HkmfZgl

M

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

OT ZNXKK UZNKX IXOZKXOG 2UTJUT ([YOTKYY 9INUUR ZUVY ZNK XGTQOTM LUX \GR[KLUXSUTK_ OTZKXTGZOUTGR SUHOROZ_ GTJ OTZKXTGZOUTGR IU[XYK ' T[SHKX UL KTZXGTZY LKGZ[XK OT HUZN XGTQOTMY TUZGHR_ +JNKI ([YOTKYY 9INUUR OT ,XGTIK GTJ ZNK -[GTMN[G 9INUUR UL 3GTGMK SKTZ GZ 6KQOTM ;TO\KXYOZ_ KTZKX ZNK VXKK^VKXOKTIK XGTQOTM LUX ZNK LOXYZ ZOSK OT YO^ZN GTJ KOMNZN VUYO ZOUT XKYVKIZO\KR_ -KUXMK =GYNOTMZUT ;TO\KXYOZ_ GTJ ZNK )NGVSGT -XGJ[GZK 9INUUR UL ([YOTKYY GZ ,RUXOJG /TZKXTGZOUTGR ;TO\KXYOZ_ SGQK ZNKOX KTZX_ OT ZNK VUYZK^VKXOKTIK XGTQOTM OT YKIUTJ GTJ LU[XZN VRGIK XKYVKIZO\KR_ /+ ([YOTKYY 9INUUR OT 9VGOT OY XGTQKJ YKIUTJ OT ZNK VXKK^VKXO KTIK XGTQOTM ZNK YGSK VRGIK GY OT  /Z OY XGTQKJ LOXYZ LUX IGXKKX VXUMXKYY 5T ZNK UZNKX NGTJ UTR_  VKX IKTZ UL OZY YZ[ JKTZY GXK ]USKT ZNK RU]KYZ VKX IKTZGMK OT ZNK XGTQOTM /+ YNGXKY ZNK YKIUTJ VRGIK ]OZN +YYKI ([YOTKYY 9INUUR LXUS ,XGTIK ]NOIN MGOTKJ UTK VRGIK LXUS ZNK  XGTQOTM (XGTJKOY ;TO\KXYOZ_ OY ZNK NOMN KYZ XGTQKJ YINUUR LXUS ZNK ;9 GZ T[SHKX  OT ZNK VXKK^VKXOKTIK XGTQOTM /Z IUSKY YKIUTJ LUX OTZKX TGZOUTGR SUHOROZ_ GTJ YO^ZN LUX GOSY GINOK\KJ .U]K\KX ]OZN  VKX IKTZ OZ NGY ZNK RU]KYZ XGZK UL KSVRU_SKTZ ZNXKK SUTZNY GLZKX MXGJ[GZOUT 6KQOTM ;TO\KXYOZ_ OY ZNK UTR_ YINUUR LXUS )NOTG ZNGZ LKGZ[XKY /Z OY XGTQKJ ZNOXJ LUX \GR[KLUX SUTK_ GTJ VRGIKSKTZ Y[IIKYY GTJ NGY G  VKX IKTZ KSVRU_SKTZ XGZK ZNXKK SUTZNY GLZKX MXGJ[G ZOUT .U]K\KX OZ NGY ZNK RU]KYZ

Class of 2009 Distribution of those studying overseas Half of students surveyed studied abroad

Three years after graduation, a third of all alumni work overseas France

UK

Key to the table Weights in brackets (pre-experience), [post-experience]

Distribution of those working overseas

90

US

41

UK

40 298

40

Switzerland

39 66

Switzerland

34 26 21

Netherlands

180

France Netherlands

US

120

Other

Other

Average salary three years after graduation

International Diversity Percentage of non-international students

By seniority ($’000)

100 60

Graduate trainee

50 Junior manager/professional

51

63 Senior manager/executive

68 9

Department head and above

81 UK

US

France

China

Source: FT research

OTZKXTGZOUTGR JO\KXYOZ_ XGZK LUX LGI[RZ_ GTJ YZ[JKTZY (GYKJ UT V[XINGYOTM VU]KX VGX OZ_ XGZKY [YKJ ZU IUT\KXZ GRR YGRG XOKY OTZU ;9 JURRGXY YZ[JKTZY LXUS 6KQOTM ;TO\KXYOZ_ GRYU IUS SGTJKJ ZNK NOMNKYZ G\KXGMK

$58,700 6kZgV\Z [ZbVaZ hVaVgn i]gZZ nZVgh V[iZg \gVYjVi^dc

$63,300 6kZgV\Z bVaZ hVaVgn i]gZZ nZVgh V[iZg \gVYjVi^dc

GTT[GR YGRGX_ GZ  ZNXKK _KGXY GLZKX MXGJ[GZOUT TGXXU]R_ XKRKMGZOTM ZNK YZ[JKTZY LXUS .+) 6GXOY ZU ZNK YKIUTJ NOMNKYZ :NK YZ[JKTZ Y[X\K_ YNU]KJ ZNGZ SUXK ZNGT  VKX IKTZ UL OZY MXGJ [GZKY ]UXQ OT LOTGTIK OT )NOTG 9USK  YZ[JKTZY ]NU

GZZKTJKJ VXUMXGSSKY GZ ZNK  YINUURY OT ZNK VXKK^VKXOKTIK XGTQOTM IUSVRKZKJ ZNK ,: Y[X\K_ :NK XKY[RZY VXU\OJK [YKL[R OTYOMNZY UT ZNK VXULORK UL ZNK G\KX GMK YZ[JKTZ NK OY SGRK GTJ KOZNKX ,XKTIN UX )NOTKYK =NKT YZGXZOTM ZNK IU[XYK NK OY  _KGXY URJ GTJ NGY HKKT ]UXQOTM OT LOTGTIK LUX G _KGX SUYZ ROQKR_ OT GIIU[TZOTM UX OT\KYZSKTZ HGTQOTM SKXMKXY GTJ GIW[OYO ZOUTY GY G MXGJ[GZK ZXGOTKK ]OZN G YGRGX_ UL GHU[Z þ :NXKK _KGXY GLZKX MXGJ[GZOUT NK OY ROQKR_ ZU ]UXQ OT 2UTJUT OT OT\KYZSKTZ HGTQOTM SKXMKXY GTJ GIW[OYOZOUTY GY G P[TOUX VXULKY YOUTGR ]OZN G YGRGX_ UL ˆ 2UUQOTM HK_UTJ G\KXGMKY ZNK JGZG YNU]Y YOMTOLOIGTZ JOLLKXKTIKY LUX YZ[JKTZY¹ SUHOROZ_ ,UX K^GS VRK  VKX IKTZ UL YZ[JKTZY OT ,XKTIN YINUURY ]KXK LXUS ,XGTIK H[Z UTR_  VKX IKTZ UL YZ[JKTZY OT ;1 YINUURY ]KXK (XOZOYN 'TJ UTR_  VKX IKTZ UL U\KXYKGY YZ[JKTZY ]NU YZ[JOKJ OT ,XGTIK XKSGOTKJ ZNKXK OT KSVRU_SKTZ

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´ ZNK RGZZKX HKOTM HKZZKX Y[OZKJ ZU LOTGTIOGR ZKINTOW[KY

HVaVgn idYVn JH '% P'%R/ I]Z VkZgV\Z Vajbc^ hVaVg^Zh i]gZZ nZVgh V[iZg \gVYjVi^dc! JH EEE Zfj^kVaZci# >cXajYZh Vajbc^ hVaVgn YViV [dg i]Z XjggZci nZVg VcY i]Z egZXZY^c\ nZVg! l]ZgZ VkV^aVWaZ HVaVgn ^cXgZVhZ c$V P'%R/ I]Z VkZgV\Z Y^[[ZgZcXZ ^c Vajbc^ hVaVgn WZilZZc WZ[dgZ i]Z B76 VcY idYVn# =Va[ d[ i]^h [^\jgZ ^h XVaXjaViZY [gdb i]Z VWhdajiZ hVaVgn ^cXgZVhZ! VcY ]Va[ VXXdgY^c\ id i]Z eZgXZciV\Z ^cXgZVhZ gZaVi^kZ id egZ"B76 hVaVgn à i]Z ÅhVaVgn eZgXZciV\Z ^cXgZVhZÆ [^\jgZ ejWa^h]ZY ^c i]Z edhi" ZmeZg^ZcXZ iVWaZ KVajZ [dg bdcZn gVc` * P(R/ 8VaXjaViZY jh^c\ i]Z hVaVgn ZVgcZY Wn Vajbc^ idYVn! XdjghZ aZc\i]! [ZZh VcY di]Zg Xdhih! ^cXajY^c\ i]Z deedgijc^in Xdhi d[ cdi ldg`^c\ [dg i]Z YjgVi^dc d[ i]Z BVhiZgh egd\gVbbZ 8VgZZgh gVc` &% P,R/ I]Z XVgZZg hiVijh d[ Vajbc^ i]gZZ nZVgh V[iZg \gVYjVi^dc# Egd\gZhh^dc ^h bZVhjgZY VXXdgY^c\ id aZkZa d[ hZc^dg^in VcY i]Z h^oZ d[ XdbeVcn ^c l]^X] Vajbc^ VgZ ZbeadnZY 6^bh VX]^ZkZY  * P(R/ I]Z ZmiZci id l]^X] Vajbc^ [ja[^aaZY i]Z^g \dVah dg gZVhdch [dg Yd^c\ V BVhiZgh ^c ;^cVcXZ# I]^h ^h bZVhjgZY Vh V eZgXZciV\Z d[ idiVa gZijgch [dg V hX]dda EaVXZbZci hjXXZhh gVc` * P(R/ 6ajbc^ l]d jhZY i]Z XVgZZgh hZgk^XZ Vi i]Z^g Wjh^cZhh hX]dda lZgZ Vh`ZY id gVc` ^ih Z[[ZXi^kZcZhh ^c i]Z^g _dW hZVgX] :beadnZY Vi i]gZZ bdci]h  * P(R/ EZgXZciV\Z d[ i]Z bdhi gZXZci \gVYjVi^c\ XaVhh i]Vi lZgZ ^c ZbeadnbZci i]gZZ bdci]h V[iZg \gVYjVi^dc# I]Z [^\jgZ ^c WgVX`Zih

h]dlh i]Z eZgXZciV\Z d[ i]Z XaVhh [dg l]^X] i]Z hX]dda lVh VWaZ id egdk^YZ ZbeadnbZci YViV LdbZc [VXjain  ( P(R/ EZgXZciV\Z d[ [ZbVaZ [VXjain# ;dg i]Z i]gZZ \ZcYZg"gZaViZY Xg^iZg^V! hX]ddah i]Vi ]VkZ *%/*% \ZcYZg Xdbedh^i^dc gZXZ^kZ i]Z ]^\]Zhi hXdgZ LdbZc hijYZcih  ( P(R/ EZgXZciV\Z d[ [ZbVaZ hijYZcih LdbVc WdVgY  & P'R/ EZgXZciV\Z d[ [ZbVaZ bZbWZgh d[ i]Z VYk^hdgn WdVgY >ciZgcVi^dcVa [VXjain  * P*R/ EZgXZciV\Z d[ [VXjain l]dhZ X^i^oZch]^e Y^[[Zgh [gdb i]Z^g Xdjcign d[ ZbeadnbZci >ciZgcVi^dcVa hijYZcih  * P*R/ EZgXZciV\Z d[ hijYZcih l]dhZ X^i^oZch]^e Y^[[Zgh [gdb i]Z Xdjcign ^c l]^X] i]Zn VgZ hijYn^c\ >ciZgcVi^dcVa WdVgY  ' P(R/ EZgXZciV\Z d[ i]Z WdVgY l]dhZ X^i^oZch]^e Y^[[Zgh [gdb i]Z Xdjcign ^c l]^X] i]Z Wjh^cZhh hX]dda ^h WVhZY ;VXjain l^i] YdXidgViZh  + P+R/ EZgXZciV\Z d[ [VXjain l^i] V YdXidgVa YZ\gZZ >ciZgcVi^dcVa bdW^a^in gVc` &% P,R/ 6 bZVhjgZ WVhZY dc X]Vc\Zh ^c i]Z Xdjcign d[ ZbeadnbZci d[ Vajbc^ WZilZZc \gVYjVi^dc VcY idYVn >ciZgcVi^dcVa XdjghZ ZmeZg^ZcXZ gVc` &% P,R/ LZ^\]iZY VkZgV\Z d[ [djg Xg^iZg^V i]Vi bZVhjgZ ^ciZgcVi^dcVa ZmedhjgZ Yjg^c\ i]Z BVhiZgh egd\gVbbZ AVc\jV\Zh * Pc$VR/ CjbWZg d[ VYY^i^dcVa aVc\jV\Zh gZfj^gZY dc \gVYjVi^dc [gdb i]Z BVhiZgh egd\gVbbZ 8djghZ aZc\i] bdci]h I]Z aZc\i] d[ i]Z BVhiZgh egd\gVbbZ