Towards a General Definition Of Trust and its Application to Openness in MAS PhD student paper G. Muller [email protected]

L. Vercouter [email protected]

O. Boissier [email protected]

Dpt SMA/SIMMO, ENS of Mines of Saint-Etienne 158, Cours Fauriel, 42023 Saint-Etienne, France ABSTRACT


   !"#"$"%!&
' "&(
"% )+*-,./,01/ "*-2"3/"
4"!/
' 1/"*5768"#9*/
7683"#
4:;5*51/

(
 ,
' -!@? AB*,2;- 
"*5C6A*-
)D=,E
*5F"#G@/
!CH/EC*-,3
/   
1'JI7$$/KD
' -1L"%&M (,0/6N1*5*-:*5"!O*M//
"868 .1/*51/P
Q"%R - S*-J?PAJIT6RU"% ,0*-
S 4/H"#"*5V*-,Q
I:
' >"%*- M1*-H:1/91*-1

(
/E >=
*!1  ? J*8,0*-
S %"W4P/H""*-I6A4
*5:*5 Q A,0
' /6A*
)U   *-B+ -1/*
=*,X
 Y
% Z
*!1  ?[A"(,E
' -/6R*-
)  /U&-/
' \*5&-C*S"%1$6R*-
)D],E
*5^ *!1"% -4 1"1

+/ 1*5/
1/5?9_5IJJI,
"H1"% -J *!1"/"? dfs,t 1/I4SDs s*D/%"&M*-,8
   sI "D;T*-%;5$*-
 *
9
  >
1L/
$,0
*5u;- 
"*5X*5S "? d P"%7
 2 U1*-/KX1*51P -3*O1*-  4 7!/4:

,
"%*-$"% 1/"%"%Sk z ƒDI4€!I wDI:x>|
&52 -/7*-,./H"#"%*-O&5 /
M,0
*5 ;- 
"*5U*5S -"U C;- 
"*5g
;D"/68]"%M :/1"#H1H%]*,P
L   >
1Lc*-
=*>;T/
% -"&e ;5/
' -tIO /1/"*5…wV/KD
' -1/(1*5*:*5"!8*-,\ $LH"#"*5? † ";T"\ - "1R L7*-,1*51J
\"\ - $*5X*-
‡
%  *I6A$68"%\"%skt 1/"*5ƒ-qg &5//
' ‡,0
' /6A*
)C!C"%" &5" "&$]"#G@/
!R -1/*
A"( /;T/
' - " "*5I% 5"&X*

AH
‡$"%X/H"%&.,
' "*5I1*5H:/1

-b"#
]
*!1  ? A/JI>6AP
"/ˆ
 /DJ4
*-‰*-,*5: J"%X1 
' -"W3"# a &5!QIT*5&-/L
R68"#S  *5"*5S -  *5(O
;D"%*-gLH"#"*5.*-,7

/E >(1/*51/? Š #*5&-JIg+ -"‹*-,X"(,0*-
S -"W >"%*-‰6A -=*Œ ;T+ ,0
' /6A*
)O,68&5=/H"#"*5J? 
  ”   k zwƒ>|0qJ' " ‡ -":*-
' !\"%"1/"*5:/f6A   pLn o 

 o -ofp8m Ro  oQkt:"&8
a!I*g ;T4
‡"X *-/ *->q] -C  Tl/o]m Xo  o < n ek5I] "%1V"#("bM *5
1V*-,$M"!!"*5i*s
( - *,] =
aD : >;D"*-3
24"#3""X
2 9 Π-1/"*-e
*!1 ? }=*
*>;T/
I -g' ="sz ƒ| I
g -] 9: ;"*
]"]"#r1#g* ""%&5"% (,0
*5 1*!*-:/
' "*-J? 4]*6A;TL
IQ *-(&-L
' -."% 2 >
=1*-*5s"e*- (;- 
"# *-3/H"#"*56 ? 5\"#
I\2

 /D' >"*5e 9 C:"/,$kq3 "2;T/%c8k 7 1 -Œ
:  9 *
  -OO;T/J;- -O
/&- % 
#2*
Q682"#P,< -  R"P' -%" = ? 5\" !I5. *!1"% - 1/*5:*5!$*-,.
Skt"Zz#wL| IP e -&-!?> 1 -*5#+
3

&5!A@ ,0*-A
BDCRI‡68/
:  BŒ"$ =&5*5 -R -ECZ" 1/"*5F> 6A -!G  @`**I"= 9&5/
' -‡&5 "*5C,E
' -/6R*-
)qL?

1.2 Different Kinds of Trusts

H7
;D"*5‡ 1/"*-X *6AO41*-*5O:*-"DJ*-,;- 
"*5\L,0 """*- C >U
U *-%M:9 S:/
 *5 -4 > 
"%5I@"# != -V &5!g, /
O1 -I  *!1/"E ]
% >"%*- "%:/a6Ri -&5/DMk5IA1/*- *-:/
' "*-JI.1*-:/"#"*5JI??/?'q"ˆ19
9
% "*-K,C,0*-
LK 5I@"#,P3 -&5/DL>  >O&T ;TM  @ "#g
O" )*68?  @‹"#268"Ae*+:b*-
( -11
' ("%e ","*5C"#g&5";Tg :*5L  N8? hD1*-I7+l'mnofpLnoXQm bSo Rpbo -Tn UM
S"b 1*5/K 1/*51/?e™P/
s,0/6 *,Ub*D/%3"% ""%&5"% S - =  "%W/e*-"*-
/ !Π-:*>;T5? }=*
*>;T/
IR


V
' "*5e >
*-,E;D"/6As -X = "&-1*51IJ68 6RA >
&5-I-,0*5*>68"&Mg‘  *! ”‘ #&%@“! -Z‘  %$ • #  k z#w/|0qLI5 -

 ‘ [ ‘   ”Ž c“  ”:”‘ z#w>| Ig >b"("= s3#"# f" "*- - 1*-1?

2. MODELING TRUST

_s= 
&-5IA,0*5*68"%&\8$ ‘   "! ” ‘ #%“g -]' *+ $ • #  k z ƒ|0q  >U
US = -#!I:*O*5#=*b  "%&52 &5!I:*S&-
*- *-,g;- 
"*59 "WIQ  >2*V*-3!/
3"e1*5 "E/
' "*- " LH"&31/*51/? h"17
J"%J;D"%L6A \ . *!1"% -!1*-1/I>"#‡:/H *-% *O:X"%"#=*3"";"% -tL ? ^R*5 "E/
"&S' 
&-/$ 

:L
 *5Œ6A*5% :(
1/"%&+=1*- "%L
' "*52*s V S -  /U*-,Q1 - I68L
3*-X1 -+ - 1L
"%:9"%!!"*5I:*-";- "*5I "!/
ID
 - *-C &5*5 -A*X]' >
&5/?QhD"%1=–a -&-! —2 
 M S %/="#*s
/,"%*-IJ1*53 -"U -V"""*5I6A368"%4
L,
2*
R/  `U /
;T/
?4A R"%P*R8,0*!1Q*-,@"P :/
I S"#= *5%i
*5 -# :V - -#Wi1 >
/, 
"=C=*,R &5!7E "&8"J
*-A"Akt"#,:*-  "%>q f p < n Cm f p .g-Wp VMD( *5P  hPikjKd cml0d c"j$"M"#U"!/
' -1/"*-]68"# *-/
] -&-!Xkk C4qL? A.
*-%]*-, J~0j3j3tS‚sd cDjU"P*
'  "#R","*5S*-,@
 *-
8
% >=1*-1.*9O://H1"% 
!?

2.2 Definitions 2.2.1 Trust Relation aIcD}ƒjKe$"U f p  pV"%V *-*5X/% "O O -1/"*5 -1‚D"#
MD V" p l/ogWp „wp YpLn:l'p ? h"1C"#b"%b :/%"/,fI8"#(1 -Z:=,< - 5?j}=*-
*>;TL
I8*5=1
  *5S*5"P:"/,aIS -)D"&"#Q:*5  "g*X:L
, )D*>688 >†  @`
]"CI68 U*!g"# "#b"# , >^:/
,0*-
g -1L"%*-6‡ X h"1O"#8"] 1‚!"#
bDb"#
1/g/K:/
"1/I"#8"g 3
*5:/
f *-,Q2*68/
X -+*(*-21 "!/
,@? :BA$CD

    "! #$

9Q[ E :;< 9a[ ET:b < RTS != $'UV9ZW: #H M S "! \  S ]6^`_ 6$'UV#=M S "! F "! GH=!0 >YX E :ZA$? CD GtSB0}ocmddceMhPcmBbnotgfYbTeKtS~0nz~/h ec"}ojKeWi cmd*|SbTeKdkj\r~nƒrd ‚ƒe3j 

% O † *5  ":/
$
*-%S M68+9 -&5/D % O „Q/H1"% 
V
*5  *=% U?`U /
;5/
$ -C2˜4;- - >*-

*-? 5\"&-
9ƒ *68U
% "*-:/f6A/V
*5U,0*-
O*-X" ' 1(*-,U*5(*-,gSa6R*+
21*-
1L"%*- 
*!1  VkY/  1L
"%:s 1/"*5 ƒ!? ~5qLI7,0
*-u:*5"!X*-,8;D"/6[*,8*5S„RLH 1/"E >
!? c".U /g*-,P -@$ &5!?

Vl

m

9ONQP I 8 /+/ 2J7+) *02K1L254M-75. 7+)58&

2.2.2 Reputation Relations :d ‚k}oebTe3tS~nj"%91*5*-#s;D"/6Ai -(oSRp:3!p6…"m"mw R*" Sm 1-n "*5""#68"&5*-  "%ikt&5*5  "s1 -:9:*5 "#";T5I8"#("b*-S

"1/i*1 -!q3"#b"(1*- #i
%  *X"#G@ "*5(*-,‡
 Y
% b*-"*-A68"1'C >
$ 1/
":  /1/"*5+ƒD? ~D? hD"1g
' "*5("%."#A
*-&-(*- /
;- "*5.!S 3&
*5 *,A &5!2ktS :"1"&SX„R/H1/"E >
V" #,'qLI@"#"#,0

,*-
? ADI
g"U 9

"1/"*-M*-,4
' "*5C -(1*5E=C: LH -\ V–ada";D"%  ' "*5—$zw|YI68/
44&-
*- *-, `U /
;T/
8 (˜P;- - >*-
] 
""#b*9 -&-!g" /,f? h*X,t >
U A
' "*5("g1/*51//
@IDO /
8*,\]",
&5/?

sq i m p 3 6i m tr n dr

A tSe3n$d j3j 1d ‚k}$eKbTe3t ~0n68"::]/H2 Q.
' > "*5b"%#.:*5b",
g*-,4OH&5
Xƒ-qL?Rdf!"#";T#!I *21  >
"%#!IQ_B"#  ' "*5e *5%Œ:(*
= 11
' X  ]"&5D:*-
' "*5?A`]/
U)D"%O*, ^R*-%/1/";T/ ' "*5] >

*- -#(:*-  "*/H5?

n

n

j

2.2.3 Confidence Relation ;~0n$p od*nƒr"d31 2:.;D"/6A9 -7
P"9""#"%*-gk z {|0q\*-
"+S 
)D9k z#w{|0qL?XdfO"O*-@ >C;T/
 ! ? ^R*5H:/13"% $\ 
&-/(–f—2,
' 1*DV;- -3O"V3/ !M"#/ "%&-/
?3A 1/*5H1$"U' " C
*-&-M *5$)D"%=*-,P  
C;D"/6 *,7O (]*9  1*-, † *-  ":/
? 5\"&-
XƒX *688O")D.:/a6R=J
I ' "*58 - ^R*-H1O,0
*- $„R/H1/"E >
=:*-"D8*,4;D"%L6? d S"*5D;D"%*- >26AV/HC  S g L(*,1*-12
/ &5 
'"%&+*C(:*-  """"*G@/
s!,0
' -L6A*-
)ikt 1/ "*-VƒD?w>qL? d ,
"OX /*,A &5!O% "&S$
*52*, `U /
;T/
I 2 /$,p *,
I4I8I R???kYDIQw-I‡ ;5/
' -P -&-!???'qLM ? 5*
$/K -5I:6R 1 - 2
Q 9
' "*-S"#G@/
468"2
/&T 
'2*OgD2 :L
*-,R -&-!O"s*

I*-
3So RpS"m g-p  .wYw;T/
Y
' >"%&. -O/
>*;5/
;5  "*-kt/

' >"&U -J,
&5/I-68" /
;5  "*-Ž -( -11
' -1/Ž*,9VH -;- -  "*-:qL?

n

n

n

r

2.3 Trust Construction

r

]*6` >M -O+
*-%/M ;T+:c
 /DIg,
!IO 1*-(,E
*5 A  `U /
;T/
? d ,aI,"*5JI"#,

Π-&-!3*!*-)X,
&5/U,qU"#$:";T/O*= ;T391 - ""#a+""1*-!/KD?2df,  † *5  ":/
O"g*U 
]*-,4$˜4;5  *
O = -g**!1 - /;5 % "*5= ;5 "%% 5I"#. *5E( - )S C˜4;5 % *
.*91*- A;- -]kt%")E :(wqL?7AA˜P;- - >*-
I-68"1L3\",0*-
S >"*5U*5V2‡ 
&5LI‡1 &-/O
' 6 *5 /
;5 >"*5O,E
*5 `U  L
;T/
R*
A
/ 1*59;- -P,E
*5*-L
A˜4;5  *
Okt")D % :Vƒ9 -=~9"=H&5
9w>qL? AS*-L
X6A 
*!1 31 -' -)TS% 15I7"I7,9!+*5S*-
*
A  `U /
;5/
$k
 "#G@/
!Uf:/U*-,Q  &52/H"&X
*!1/ *-,Q&5*5  ""%& kt*-8

"1/b*21 -DVz ~>||"%*-?h"1V–f—("%C*O*5 /
;TC3"#
1/g/K:/
"1I"g1 M*] O",0*-
S >"%*-=*2"%="# 
?Adfg1 -M"#/
] $"#g*"%C"#g_Z"  /' >"*5  "13–a&-—]"‡*-JP*5#O˜P;- -*
7*-,DQ",0*-
S >"%*-$"\ -  / *5?Pdf] -&-&-
&5 g O
1/*5 "*-A*2"%kt*-
g*D "#,0qR" U"&5D:*
' "*-kYLHb 1L"%*-VƒD? ƒ!? ƒ!Idf"#
1L ' "*5zw|0q8 -:*58 > 
"%  Cs*,7‡ 
&5L=– —?

n

n

n

n

sr

n

2.4 Reasoning on Trust

‡*1*5(
 Y
%  *-"*-IA/
="b  *,U* 1'*!*5 X 2 ' 9
1/
U1*5%"% D.68"#=O*D/‡ :*;55? h"1./
8 >
]"#G@/
!R;5Q*,
gkY -S -&-!R1 -2


-*-/L
Dm p] b "#
'S*-g,/x
Dm p= Z - *!11  "*5 O*55IA *= L  *-%="1/%""%1/g:*5 "#";T$ -(&T >"%;5;5 %? Ag /Oz w5I z 2|EI 3w/|@ /R /,
U1*-D" *-I:LK
  "&b -M"H"#$D3:/
8*-,P;- -I: -= -*>68"& ] ]*-,\*
U "gS S "1 :‚! "*-R,0*-
8""#"% -"W/ "&I@ "&2*-
g "&9O;- -5? ‡*M

 !3,t -1L2 >2 Π-&5/D9 9*+"
/1/9LK:L
"1/268"\ >
&5/IJs–f)*68—C;- -91 -: @? A/JI! X*5#$/JI-"P"4:*5  "A* -$†  O * O-;- -A68"%1'  K,–adO 5e"#
1L3LK:L
"%/1Tkt'qO68"#sS\ >
&5/I4Xd

-  O*2//
"O"#,7dR1 -=
8"#]*
g*-—? A7

 !' "*-X"@1/*5U"z w5Iw/|Œ–a)D*68—I

-IH
I -*>68J*8""&5" X:La6A/O$–a)D*68O' >—

-OX–a/
' -!' >—Xkt;T$"P
 !#*
Q1*-/ ˜7 f1/*5/
1"% .*DOz#wIUw|8"""%1/"*5 "%9*-2' - " q 2@ 1*5M:/a6RMV–a
' 7' —b CV–a&T > ";T' / —ek"*5$ -^R*5H:1q >
Q O!U 1L$ &5!? A9"%:*
' -19*,R3 >
"%1/% 
V–f)D*>68—(;- -368"Q: /
"S"Sg 1 
"*9
 !"b /1/"*5C~D? ƒD?QAg
# ;- -1*-,7O
g;5 $/:g*-=D9:/
8*,7
' "&-

-( *5%=
*5 -#(/:b*5="#
g;D"% "*5k zw€>|0qA*!*?

r

n

n

3. TRUSTY OPEN MULTI-AGENT SYSTEMS J
2"2*-,E  e*V;5  bb*-fe*-,O - -&-! 68/2"#R1*-"#\*:/
,C"#,$ -i -&5/Db:";T/SC1*-D/D2*-,$ /  -&5  >9"#9 !?M_sb 
bS -"#"DL
s"eS/K1L -&5S*-, ",0*-
S "*-$,
&5/8 *-U1 >&5*
"%/]*, 1 - ""#"%/R,;5*5"%s -&-!M7 *M
/ !$" /,8*C/;T/
*-L
9 &5!I 6R("!
*D11/
"#/
"*5Œ*-,g"!&-
' >"%*-  3LH/X

*5D*,)D*>68&54 >\ $ -&5/DJ/J -:*-J*-L
7 -&-!? 5*-
./K 5ID &5!-7 S 99*X)D*\ 6 d l0d cmuC*-/
. &5!  3 9 C1  ""fs*
2 =
‚!"
/! X"3
/%/;5 D$,0*-
"#?=ADI7 9 &5!M9 "X"D/&-
' *=b} Š h@I"#X1 -e 1/

C s"%/ f -&5/DS,0*-
C *-M1 - -"%"#"skt*
(
‚!"
/!'q :/1 - 1  9 )D*68O >$"#$)*68;T/
+*-/
X -&-!
;- -!

< threshold 3

4

4

Distrust intention

 eK~ bT‚o‚k|Su eM od  e~ jod*|

,A"#."Ag*5b &5!A R1 *3K?PAJI -&-!/9["%=*-8*!*5)S,81 *2KC -=
*- -&5 C"%g"3"M"#]*68V -;D"1*S$ -&-! 7M? A,6‰*6c],0
' -L6A*-
)b
/ !("= /1/ "*5Vƒ!?w$1 -(: S* 1L
"%:O"g 1/ >
"%*? JL3 O 81*- "%L
O M -&-!VI ;"& 3
‚!"#
/D. -:*58K

-9!I568"%1'"R:"&$ 53*g} Š h@?TA"A &5!R -#
 5D )D*68gk"*5B68"# ;S? A/JI -  ;…1*5!"DQ*91% -"[ ."#."A]*-#b -&-!.   9(1 - -"%"#aeK@ I  1 - /1L9("%=:1 - ="#S % * )D*68SM/K"1/M*-,X -*-/
C &5!8k {Oq9 >b1 -B*sK@?

agent B Requirement : x

agent C

Representation of others

Capability : x

C Cap : x

Representation of others

2. advice

1. presentation

B Req : x

agent A Requirement : x 3. presentation

Capability : y

...

Representation of others

GtSB0}ocmd
  {$b  k‚ |Sdx~ /h eM $dx‚ƒcmd jKd*n&eKbTeKtS~0n ‚ƒcm~rd*j3j  agent B

... step 4

agent C

SCENARIO

... agent A

...

step 3 step 2

step 1

agent E Capability : x Representation of others D Req : x

agent D step 0

Requirement : x Requirement : y

0. previous presentation 1. presentation and advice (A advices to D to contact C for x) 2. presentation, advice (C claims that it is the only agent that can do x) and lie detection (D knows that it is false) 3. negative recommendation (A updates its witness−reputation about C with the trust of D about C) 4. negative recommendation (B updates its neighbor−reputation about C with the witness−reputation of A about C)

Representation of others E

Cap : x

GtSB}ocmdLj3tn$B eM od…eKcD}ƒjKe;h cmb  Hd A~c  Š 0, /
g"]//1/"*5JI `@ >g"8
U -:*-;N,0
*-^ –f)*68—=;- -9*M =&T >"%;52;5  *!$*3:/%";5 8 5;"1-? Š &5/D   *
*5 -&5 P"Q","*52*U

&5!g"#8)*68$  , 7  {X? _O68"%J*6Ž,68—.;5 ,"*5 :*5I  ;S?5„Q9/,< -IT"4
:  ;1O Q 5;"1-? Š ,E/
b
/1*5 >"%*-,0
*- VI7"#368"#  Y
' >"%*-e,qR *5%b: ' )TV O 2D/
"1"g*-,431" "*5M,
Q,0/6 -&-! *O"!
*D1A*I5* &5!46A*-%9!/
7./CI5 *U. N6A*5%(*.:O (*-:b*5-I68"1Lb".1/
"#"%1 -@"(*-
.1  5? df("=/c -c*5%"&5 "*5c* ""&5" ‰:/f6A/c 
'  ;- -g

 /D"&3
I /' >"*5S*-
^R*-H1O 2

- 1/*-,8)D*68&-Mkt*-
X*6
"% -"%"#fs*-,R;TP;- ->q

-:*-]"DL
' -1/"*5C68"#C$\ 
&-/?8A"g
S 
)S
/ ,0*-
1/ 1/*5/
$

/ !' "*5e*,g
 Y
% 1/*51/X
* :*5 ="C 1/"*5MƒD? ?

n

4. RELATED WORKS 4.1 In E-Commerce

A$ • %“%‘   ”  (*D7k z#w>|0qR
 !S!=$ ‘ [ ‘   ” - S“  ”:”‘= >4g˜ Š hhh&O 5~U"S„A >
1*5 $ -:*5Q
/' >"*5 "/ S >
)T/E 1$"$*-
21*-/ V*-' -#1*5%"% D 68"#3*D7
;D"*5 #V
 !@?XdfO"O9*5O;5# *5:2*D,0
*5N*6i*5S -9
"R*- *!1"% -: 1"1R6R*-
)D? }=*-
/*;5/
IT"#4 7 ;T/
' 1/*5*5,0 
768"XA*DT6A

H\*-"%!g*-,4™]"/6 Š

kY„R//H1"% 
q

˜P;- - *-


‡ 
&5L

† *-  ":/


`U /
;TL




^ 





^

Š k q



^ 

˜



„



^



 

Š  
"%


k ^]I C4q 
k ^]I C4q 
k ^]I C4q   / k ^]I C7q

aIb ik|Sd@
aa odFj3r"d $n bTcDtS~]cmd ‚ƒcmd*jKd*neKdkj :tSeM (eM od E~Kj$d |dq od cmd C tjeM $d bTiktS|tSe.u eK~ jKd*n jzbjol$trd*j6tnzeM odF~T‚=d*nƒn$d j3j cmd*r~ d*n jobTeKtS~0n ƒ‚ cm~rd*j3j?bn j eM odYtno‚k}$e3j r"~ d h cm~ eM od ƒtjKe~cmu]~htn&eKcm~ejƒ}ƒrYtn$B]tn&eKd cmbreKtS~0nƒj  /;D" -&-]*$ g"g1*5!/KDQ*-,8*5: R
*5C?P• ) %“E‘   ”  + "G@L
!U)D"U*-,P
' "*-?AXH
 *-P"‡1 %V–adf"%;D"% - ' >"%*-—?‡d \"‡% -:/%M–f"%";D"%  -—2:1 - "#g /AO -g/K:/
"1/A,0
*- C–f *5
1/—

&5!$kt*-
.:/H1/"E >
qL?Ph*I "1]O -&-!. /."R*>68(/KD :L
"%/13kt*5 /
;5 >"*5'q8 -C;- - >]O' 
&5LO"# #,aI: –fda";D"E  ' "*5—1 -M:S :S**5
OJ
?.A  /1*5C)"=*-,4
' "*-ekt1 -Z–f_Z"  ' "*-—!qA"

(*-
2 *!1"% R*5Mk"*5M". -$ ]*-
]*68=_B"#  ' "*5C - ,0*-
S %"WSS 26. 68"#"sJ  `U /
;- *
IP˜P;- - >*-
I ‡ 
&5LI8„R/H1"% >
 - † *5  ":/
S
*-%/?ZA="#
'e *-
S*,
/' >"*5 "%1 -– U"&5D:*-
*!*D ' "*5—IQ2"# ;5/
&5Q1*5 ‚!!#U,E
*5 *-
U"&5D:*-
/' >"*5J?JdaI "#
]"&5D:*5
*!*D ' "*5U 
% "*5\*-,D7' >
&5/I 68C*-
U"&5D:*-
/' >"*5= .
% "*5U*,7O:/ H1"% 
!?UA U"&-:*-
*!*D /' >"*5M"O1*-=!M /"%S >"*5i*,O=: ;D"*5
9=' >
&5/SS Π;Tb
*-&5 *- /
;- "*-i*-,U=:/ ;D"%*-
S*, -&-! *!1"% -#Z1*- C*"# kt /Mz I4~|Q,68.*6B1/
*-"1OS 
)5/R% -1.")T]„A S1 :O
/
 !b68""C*5
]&-L
' -‡,E
' -/6R*-
):?AA$J
g*,

O!L
P"9. ""#a2*, U /
4"P"#P:*-98"
/1/ LK:L
"%/1O/S -C
"%&3U
' - -1/"*5? Š */
8!L
]1 (' " ="#R_B"#  ' >"%*-( - S*5S8
' "& &5 >;5(* 
"&M"#
91*5*-e/K:/
"1-?sdaŒ„R & O  CI-"7
' "&1 -2:A,0*59"9R1*-

 :*-"%&"%8"% O $
' - 1/"*5Œ"*
!… ? 5\" -#!I7 ]"&5D:*-
' "*5 "PS 5A68"38 -&-&-
&5 "*5b*-,:
' >"&54,0
*-;- 
"*-4!/
? J* .. ./K -kt„R q\.&-%*- ;5 5I51*5 ,0*-
gO*>;TL
' -J
'  -1L"%*-g*-,4 3 %L
I1 C: @? • %“E‘   ”  b*!/Q*-R
/
 !PS–a)D*68—' 5I 683 -3 -&5/D7*8*7)D*6s*>6ek * _a&-A *-/
7*-5I-&5/


34*U 8% -1')*-,LK:L
"%/1? Š \"#7"\ *>68X"3 /1/"*52~D? ƒ "#US !I*6R;T/
I@
*;5$
 -#M":*-
' -!g"V *5$1 - /2kt"%)5 "=O*5:// g
*5%/bqL?

n

n

n

n

n

r







r

ar

 

 

n

r n n

r

n

n

n

4.2 In Social Sciences

 

;r

n

g$• #0  -?'‘:• 
%%“:$
' "*5"2DS -X *!1"/a!? A"#
9*DR $
2
*-%/K,˜4;5 % *
IR‡ 
&5LIP„RLH 1/"E >
( -2U
*!1/ .*-, † *5  "k z ~|0qL?QA]
*!1/ .*-, † *-  "

"\ >
"1% 
#X"$ -Of6A*g :1"#H1P
\ /‡*]//
&5 "C*5
8 *!1"/a!? dfJ *5D;D"*5J >J"‡*D/51 X:7

 !U68"#" *5
7,0
' /6A*
)kt A 1/"*-Sƒ5qL?‡da@I2–˜4;- - >*-
 —U
*-% " ] • #0  - '‘• 
%T% “ O X*D7"$ "#+ (/
&-9*,A
*5g% -:Z–a˜P;- - *-
 —IA– `U /
;TL
 —S - – † *-  "%:L
 —(" *5
g*Dt? AQ
*!1/ 7*-,A– † *5  "—]/X >
A  ' 1L*O/ 1/
":R
L 1" # kt "%1"#I\""#
$D93*-""*5I71*-D
"9% >
&5# *3"#G@/
!"% U"#
.*D/,0
*5 † -OA*-
L"%1 -:*5"!.*-, ;D"/6]q31 i:bS -:e*+*5
S"#G@/
/D2 *-
*-,g
1*-  >"*5b
*!1/  ? 4U*6R;T/
I. M
S,;5R:X
"/ˆ
L  !@?S}= D68"%-I7 -6R21% -"` >"*D/7"%&-L
' -

-=
*5I6R3(*2H=*
X -(*-
X -"1 "*5]*

-#b*5
]*D:*2"C*-
'/
8*9
*;5"? }=*-
/*;5/
I. "1(=*D8 2:i 1/
": " /
 *-,2 -&-!V -B
*5I$"#C6R*5EŽ:
 Ž"!/
"&Œ*
L ,$"]"V 29%"# f -&-!8*-
&5 -"W >"*5 4*Dt? 5*-
]/KD

-5I-8x } ` d h˜  *D@k z y>|0qLI568"1L9 -  "&5R _a*5X*U 1L
*5] -2 *5.*5"%&5 "*5A*-
R:/
"  "*5Q -  *!1/"E >*O*5  _*-I A*2:$ 3
 -#=
*5" "&9*!*-Y? A+ "% *,$*5
b6A*
)i:"&s*s1*5V 
( L
;"1 68"#"9*-
7,0#91!
' %"W9 -3*-:3%  ,"*5i
%/kt&5*-  ":qL? daIP6AV -  ( S"#,U/
M 
C"#G@/
!
" *5
DS C *!1"/"2kt5? &?]+–f
1—*53"ez ~|Y? qLIJ -=  L 
g*R "3#' -*5 2 -"1 -%-I! R"Q:1 - 8L

-#O*g"#G@/
/DJ "# >"%*-?PhD*I>6AP/O*]//
"768"%1'
Tkt'qR68"\ #b"C*5
81 - -? dfR"8 - *91*- "%L
b*X ]  "1"*-(*$

 /DR]6A 
' "*- *-%V"%1/
  Mk :";TQ*3:]1L /
Uk;TL
A
% "*5 *-,.
% >"%*-.*, >(q7*$:] 6A 
]*-,N:*5  "#1' "&



H\*-"Dg*,7™U"/6

˜4;5 % *


kY„Q/H1"% 
q

  

   

\ 
&-/







`U /
;5/


† *5  ":/
da!/
L _s f "# da!/
L _s f "# da!/
L _s f "#



k 


   

  q

 
"

  k 
C7q 
 k 
C4q 
 k 
C4q

aIb ik|Sd d ceMd*9Mb ueiW|t d u$jKeKd 
*-,f?QdfID/3 O 8 :*5 U/
U"8*5O &5! —-
* a &5!=@C— $
. &5!4—51/*5 f &5!=@C—?-df,A&
*5 *,\
/U"8"%b1*5 O
/E >"*5JIS' -)D"&3"D*9 -11/*5!8 
' >"&5ID68"#b O6A"&5!.*,J X‚! 
/
R -1'JI!68":*A&5";T] OH - ,< -"#
g
' "&2* , @+?

5.

n

REFERENCES

zwL|A^]?&^A #,0
' 1'"\  ? 5 -1*-5?H4
"1"g*-,\
8"% S -K , ^R*-&5"";TX  *-3!I *!1"% -J":*-
' -15I - ‚! D"#H1 "*5?dfI ml'pWp V"< n " 3m  5I &5 y5!ƒ yxI\wx5x5{D? z ƒA | ^]&? ^A #,0
' 1'"\  ? H\*-5? Š
/;"/6‰*5b
g" ",0*-
S "*-=1'*-*5&-!? ! $  ,  -#,"*5=
:*
"&21' " ?da I ml'pUp VD< n " 3m OSo R/ p ."WV012Pm3n p  pLn:l'p9m- n 3- %pl/o m-Tn tl P"m MSp  l'5 p 463)87:9=I: &5wyD>w w>yxI UL@ 6 ?Q*-
):I `U1/*-:/
w w>ySƒ--w-? Š ^.} H4
 ? z €|$U? †
' "% *-J?J
g :1/"H1 "*-M -C - -# "%8,"*5? z >| 3? † ":/
? ‡ 31*5H: -1O=S 
)T/"& ,7, 6.6.6? 1C? *-
&q>  "&51*-J /K1' &5/. ;T* % ~ kY5ƒ5qW ~?w/ ah  >/
? @,a? z#w>y|3h@?h= -Br3?h 3_S_ ? n *5 .*-,7
' >"%*-    
34 , :*!*5 M1 - -?daIQb9|M] ^ ?\ >
'"? ‡ 31*5H: -1OD;TL
g "#O6A/MO  !

" 5?1*5/DA"% "#
/
g1*-H: 1L8&5 -&5L
U
% "*5V -.*5&2/
 ;T1U%/]"!/
 >5X I@ƒ55D? D ,  :L
 *? 6.  5*!*? ,0
> 1/:/
S 
)5/"&q> 1*5H: 15? !C? z#wx>| P?™Q/
1/*5L
?-3An "0 n@pp0 n f  ml  pLo  p L|1M?

Kr

*5:C3#"# f -&5/DA/I -&-Oƒ-€P!~5{?  Š dAƒ-ƒ--~? h
"&5/
Iƒ--w5? z ƒ->|X„R"?R( -M}? H\?:hD"%&5? Š =;D"%!"% -*D/*, "
"b
' "*-CS - -&5/!?DdaI ml'pWp V"
"E DI Š ?:}=*-)- -I - H\?:}C &? ^R*-%% :*-
' ";T
' "*5C/1L -" A"C/%/1/
*5"%1S >
)T/8E 1?da -mlLpWp V"