The Implementation of the Cilk-5 Multithreaded ... - BigBozoid

that generalizes the semantics of C by introducing linguistic constructs for ... design of earlier Cilk systems, but Cilk-5 exploits the prin- ... consult the Cilk-5 manual [8]. .... a solution is found by one of the searches, one wishes to abort ... bles "Brent's theorem" [6, 15] and is optimal to within a ..... Recent work by Arora et al.
309KB taille 5 téléchargements 242 vues
                 !"# $% &##' (! ) % *'+"" ,- &./ 0 123 45'5 676 -5!'"/ 483 1.+9 ##5!3## :; ?@ABCD@ EF CG EH @DI@GGJKG FL MNOA MCIP bd^ _`]Za] ie_jq{ ^Z_Z`aZ “” a]e__ daZa ` ]YZb^Z]es`__n ZvseZg] asYZfd_Z^t md] ]YZ _`ghd`hZ Y`a mZZg aec k _e[Zf sbgaefZ^`m_nu ] Zc k _bna s`__ù^Z]d^g aZc`g]esa \b^ k `^`__Z_eac `gf \Z`]d^Za ` _eghdea]es`__n aec k _Z oeg_Z]r cZsY`geac \b^ gbgfZ]Z^cegeaq ]es sbg]^b_u ie_jq{ ea fZaehgZf ]b ^dg ZvseZg]_n bg sbg]Zcq k b^`^n anccZ]^es cd_]ek ^bsZaab^a úû~ü€aýt p YesY \Z`]d^Z Y`^f p `^Z ad kk b^] \b^ aY`^Zf cZcb^nu þZ Y`lZ sbfZf c`gn ` kk _es`]ebga eg ie_jt egs_dfegh ]YZ ÿûbs^`]Za `gf ie_jsYZaa sYZaaq k _`negh k ^bh^`ca p YesY Y`lZ p bg k ^exZa eg eg]Z^g`q ]ebg`_ sbc k Z]e]ebgau XYZ k Ye_bab k Yn mZYegf ie_j fZlZ_b k cZg] Y`a mZZg ]b c`jZ ]YZ ie_j _`ghd`hZ ` ]^dZ k `^`__Z_ Zy]Zgaebg b\ it mb]Y aZc`g]es`__n `gf p e]Y ^Za k Zs] ]b k Z^\b^c`gsZu g ` k `^`_q _Z_ sbc k d]Z^t ie_j sbg]^b_ sbga]^ds]a `__bp ]YZ k ^bh^`c ]b ZyZsd]Z eg k `^`__Z_u \ ]YZ ie_j jZn p b^fa \b^ k `^`__Z_ sbg]^b_ `^Z Z_efZf \^bc ` ie_j k ^bh^`ct Ybp ZlZ^t ` ang]`s]es`__n `gf aZc`g]es`__n sb^^Zs] i k ^bh^`c ^Zad_]at p YesY p Z s`__ ]YZ   úb^ cb^Z hZgZ^`__nt ]YZ    ý b\ ]YZ ie_j k ^bh^`cu ie_j ea `   Zy]Zgaebg b\ it mZs`daZ ]YZ i Z_eaebg b\ ` ie_j k ^bh^`c ea ` sb^^Zs] ec k _ZcZg]`]ebg b\ ]YZ aZc`g]esa b\ ]YZ k ^bh^`cu ~b^ZblZ^t bg bgZ k ^bsZaab^t ` k `^`__Z_ ie_j k ^bh^`c oas`_Za fbp gr ]b ^dg gZ`^_n `a \`a] `a e]a i Z_eaebgu  g_ejZ eg ie_jqt p YZ^Z ]YZ ie_j asYZfd_Z^ p `a `g efZg]e[q `m_Z k eZsZ b\ sbfZt eg ie_jq{ mb]Y ]YZ sbc k e_Z^ `gf ^dg]ecZ ana]Zc mZ`^ ]YZ ^Za k bgaeme_e]n \b^ asYZfd_eghu Xb bm]`eg Z\q [seZgsnt p Z Y`lZt b\ sbd^aZt `]]Zc k ]Zf ]b ^ZfdsZ asYZfd_egh blZ^YZ`fau ûbcZ blZ^YZ`fa Y`lZ ` _`^hZ^ ec k `s] bg ZyZsdq ]ebg ]ecZ ]Y`g b]YZ^at Ybp ZlZ^u z ]YZb^Z]es`_ dgfZ^a]`gfegh b\ ie_j€a asYZfd_egh `_hb^e]Yc ‘t {” Y`a `__bp Zf da ]b efZgq ]e\n `gf b k ]ecexZ ]YZ sbccbg s`aZau zssb^fegh ]b ]Yea `mq a]^`s] ]YZb^nt ]YZ k Z^\b^c`gsZ b\ ` ie_j sbc k d]`]ebg s`g mZ sY`^`s]Z^exZf mn ]p b d`g]e]eZaw e]a   t p YesY ea ]YZ ]bq ]`_ ]ecZ gZZfZf ]b ZyZsd]Z ]YZ sbc k d]`]ebg aZ^e`__nt `gf e]a     t p YesY ea e]a ZyZsd]ebg ]ecZ bg `g egq [ge]Z gdcmZ^ b\ k ^bsZaab^au úie_j k ^blefZa ega]^dcZg]`]ebg ]Y`] `__bp a ` daZ^ ]b cZ`ad^Z ]YZaZ ]p b d`g]e]eZauý þe]Yeg ie_j€a asYZfd_Z^t p Z s`g efZg]e\n ` helZg sba] `a sbg]^emd]q egh ]b Ze]YZ^ p b^j blZ^YZ`f b^ s^e]es`_q k `]Y blZ^YZ`fu ~dsY b\ ]YZ ZvseZgsn b\ ie_j fZ^elZa \^bc ]YZ \b__bp egh k ^egsek _Zt p YesY p Z aY`__ ƒda]e\n eg ûZs]ebg ‘u

QRSTUVWT XYZ [\]Y ^Z_Z`aZ b\ ]YZ cd_]e]Y^Z`fZf _`ghd`hZ ie_j daZa ` hbbf op b^jqa]Z`_eghr asYZfd_egh `_hb^e]Yc aece_`^ k]b^bl`m_n ]YZ [^a] ana]Zct md] ]YZ _`ghd`hZ Y`a mZZg sbc k _Z]Z_n ^Zq fZaehgZf `gf ]YZ ^dg]ecZ ana]Zc sbc k _Z]Z_n ^ZZghegZZ^Zfu XYZ ZvseZgsn b\ ]YZ gZ ec _ZcZg]`]ebg `a `efZf mn ` s_Z`^ a]^`]Zhn ]Y`] `^baZp\^bck ` ]YZb^Z]es`_p`g`_naea b\ ]YZ asYZfd_egh `_hb^e]Ycw sbgsZg]^`]Z bg cegecexegh blZ^YZ`fa ]Y`] sbg]^emd]Z ]b ]YZ p b^jt ZlZg `] ]YZ Zy k ZgaZ b\ blZ^YZ`fa ]Y`] sbg]^emd]Z ]b ]YZ s^e]es`_ k `]Yu z_]YbdhY e] c`n aZZc sbdg]Z^eg]de]elZ ]b cblZ blZ^YZ`fa bg]b ]YZ s^e]es`_ `]Yt ]Yea op b^jq[^a]r k ^egsek _Z Y`a _Zf ]b ` k b^]`m_Z ie_jq{k ecq eg YesY ]YZ ]n es`_ sba] b\ a k `p gegh ` k `^`__Z_ k _ZcZg]`]ebg ]Y^Z`f ea bg_n mZ]pp ZZg | `gf k} ]ecZa ]YZ sba] b\ ` i \dgs]ebg s`__ bg ` l`^eZ]n b\ sbg]Zc k b^`^n c`sYegZau ~`gn ie_j k ^bq h^`ca ^dg bg bgZ k ^bsZaab^ p e]Y le^]d`__n gb fZh^`f`]ebg sbc k `^Zf ]b Zdel`_Zg] i k ^bh^`cau XYea k ` k Z^ fZas^emZa Ybp ]YZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Z p `a Zy k _be]Zf eg ]YZ fZaehg b\ ie_jq{€a sbc k e_Z^ `gf e]a ^dg]ecZ ana]Zcu g k `^]esd_`^t p Z ie_jq{€a gblZ_ o]p bqs_bgZr sbc k e_`]ebg a]^`]Zhn `gf ke]a^ZaZg] ‚eƒ ja]^`q_ejZ cd]d`_qZys_daebg \b^ ec _ZcZg]egh k ^b]bsb_ ]YZ ^Z`fn fZdZ eg ]YZ p b^jqa]Z`_egh asYZfd_Z^u k „…†‡ˆU‰S i^e]es`_ k `]Yt cd_]e]Y^Z`feght k `^`__Z_ sbc k d]eght k ^bh^`cq cegh _`ghd`hZt ^dg]ecZ ana]Zct p b^ju Š ‹ŒTUˆ‰WTŽˆŒ ie_j ea ` cd_]e]Y^Z`fZf _`ghd`hZ \b^ k `^`__Z_ k ^bh^`ccegh ]Y`] hZgZ^`_exZa ]YZ aZc`g]esa b\ i mn eg]^bfdsegh _eghdea]es sbga]^ds]a \b^ k `^`__Z_ sbg]^b_u XYZ b^eheg`_ ie_jq ^Z_Z`aZ ‘t ’t “” \Z`]d^Zf ` k ^bl`m_n ZvseZg]t ^`gfbcexZft op b^jq a]Z`_eghr asYZfd_Z^ ‘t {”t md] ]YZ _`ghd`hZ p `a s_dcant mZs`daZ k `^`__Z_eac p `a Zy k baZf omn Y`gfr daegh Zy k _ese] sbg]egd`]ebg k `aaeghu XYZ ie_j _`ghd`hZ ec k _ZcZg]Zf mn •–—˜ ™š˜š›™œ– ›˜ ˜žŸŸ ™¡š¢ —£ Ÿ›™¡ ¤¥ ¡–š ¦š§š£˜š ¨¢©›£œš¢ ªš˜š›™œ– «™ ¬šœ¡˜ ¨­š£œ¥ ®¦¨ª«¨¯ ž£¢š™ °™›£¡ ±²²²³´µ¶´µ³µ²¶·¸¹ º »Ÿž¡—£­ §›œ—¼—¡—š˜ š™š Ÿ™ ©—¢š¢ ¤¥ ¡–š ½¾• ¿ ¼›˜ «™ ¬šœ¡À ¡–›£Á˜ ¡  › ­š£š™ ž˜ šÂž—Ÿ»š£¡ ¢ £›¡— £ §™ » Þ£ ½—œ™ ˜¥˜¡š»˜¹ ÄÅ ÆÇÇÈÆÉ ÊË ÌÍÎÏÐÐÑÒÓÔÕ ÎÖ ×ØÐ ÙÚÚÛ ÜÝÞ ßàáÌâÜã ÝÎÓÖÐÍÐÓÏÐ ÎÓ ÌÍÎÔÍäååÒÓÔ âäÓÔæäÔÐ çÐÕÒÔÓ äÓÑ àåè éêÐåÐÓ×ä×ÒÎÓ ëÌâçàìí îÅËïÉÈÆðí ñÆËÆòÆí óôËÈ õöö÷ø Š

C DEFGHIJ KLMIGDN OPQ C DEFGHIJ KLMI DR OPQ C DEFGHIJ KFDGS OPQ

                                                   

FDGS DEM T DN UDEM E V W DT UEKXV YJMHYE E Z JGLJ W DEM [ \ ] Z [ ^ L_`aE T DN UEbcV Z ] ^ L_`aE T DN UEbXV Z L]EF Z YJMHYE U[d] V Z e e

XYZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Z k _`nZf `g ec k b^]`g] ^b_Z fd^egh ]YZ fZaehg b\ Z`^_eZ^ ie_j ana]Zcat md] ie_jq{ Zy k _be]a ]YZ k ^egq sek _Z cb^Z Zy]ZgaelZ_nu XYZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Z ega k e^Zf ` o]p bqs_bgZr a]^`]Zhn \b^ sbc k e_egh ie_j k ^bh^`cau d^ !"# $ sbc k e_Z^ |‘” ea ` ]n k ZqsYZsjeght abd^sZq]bqabd^sZ ]^`ga_`]b^ ]Y`] ]^`ga\b^ca ` ie_j abd^sZ eg]b ` i k ba]abd^sZ p YesY c`jZa s`__a ]b ie_j€a ^dg]ecZ _em^`^nu XYZ i k ba]abd^sZ ea ]YZg ^dg ]Y^bdhY ]YZ % sbc k e_Z^ ]b k ^bfdsZ bmƒZs] sbfZu XYZ !"# $ sbc k e_Z^ k ^bfdsZa ]p b s_bgZa b\ ZlZ^n ie_j k ^bsZfd^Z& ` o\`a]r s_bgZ `gf ` oa_bp r s_bgZu XYZ \`a] s_bgZt p YesY ea efZg]es`_ eg cba] ^Za k Zs]a ]b ]YZ i Z_eaebg b\ ]YZ ie_j k ^bh^`ct ZyZsd]Za eg ]YZ sbccbg s`aZ p YZ^Z aZ^e`_ aZc`g]esa advsZu XYZ a_bp s_bgZ ea ZyZsd]Zf eg ]YZ eg\^ZdZg] s`aZ ]Y`] k `^`__Z_ aZc`gq ]esa `gf e]a sbgsbce]`g] mbbjjZZ k egh `^Z ^Zde^Zfu z__ sbcq cdges`]ebg fdZ ]b asYZfd_egh bssd^a eg ]YZ a_bp s_bgZ `gf sbg]^emd]Za ]b s^e]es`_q k `]Y blZ^YZ`ft md] gb] ]b p b^j blZ^q YZ`fu XYZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Z `_ab ega k e^Zf ` ‚eƒ ja]^`q_ejZ ”t aY`^ZfqcZcb^nt cd]d`_qZys_daebg k ^b]bsb_ `a k `^] b\ ]YZ ^dg]ecZ _b`fqm`_`gsegh asYZfd_Z^u ie_j€a asYZfd_Z^ daZa ` op b^jqa]Z`_eghr `_hb^e]Yc eg p YesY ef_Z k ^bsZaab^at s`__Zf  '  t oa]Z`_r ]Y^Z`fa \^bc mdan k ^bsZaab^at s`__Zf '   (  u ie_j€a asYZfd_Z^ hd`^`g]ZZa ]Y`] ]YZ sba] b\ a]Z`_q egh sbg]^emd]Za bg_n ]b s^e]es`_q k `]Y blZ^YZ`ft `gf gb] ]b p b^j blZ^YZ`fu ) ZlZ^]YZ_Zaat e] ea Y`^f ]b `lbef ]YZ cd]d`_q Zys_daebg sba]a egsd^^Zf mn ` k b]Zg]e`_ les]ect p YesY sbgq ]^emd]Z ]b p b^ju Xb cegecexZ p b^j blZ^YZ`ft ega]Z`f b\ daegh _bsjeght ie_j€a ^dg]ecZ ana]Zc daZa ` ‚eƒ ja]^`q_ejZ k ^b]bsb_t p YesY p Z s`__ ]YZ * + k ^b]bsb_t ]b c`g`hZ ]YZ ^dg]ecZ fZdZ b\ ^Z`fn ]Y^Z`fa eg ]YZ p b^jqa]Z`_egh `_hb^e]Ycu zg `ffZf `fl`g]`hZ b\ ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_ ea ]Y`] e] `__bp a `g ZysZ k ]ebg ]b mZ aehg`_Zf ]b ` p b^jegh k ^bsZaab^ p e]Y gb `fq fe]ebg`_ p b^j blZ^YZ`ft ` \Z`]d^Z daZf eg ie_j€a `mb^] cZsYq `geacu XYZ ^Zc`egfZ^ b\ ]Yea k ` k Z^ ea b^h`gexZf `a \b__bp au ûZsq ]ebg | blZ^leZ p a ]YZ m`aes \Z`]d^Za b\ ]YZ ie_j _`ghd`hZu ûZsq ]ebg ‘ ƒda]e[Za ]YZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Zu ûZs]ebg ’ fZas^emZa Ybp ]YZ ]p bqs_bgZ a]^`]Zhn ea ec k _ZcZg]Zft `gf ûZs]ebg { k ^ZaZg]a ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_u ûZs]ebg } helZa Zc k e^es`_ Zleq fZgsZ ]Y`] ]YZ ie_jq{ asYZfd_Z^ ea ZvseZg]u . eg`__nt ûZs]ebg / k ^ZaZg]a ^Z_`]Zf p b^j `gf b 0 Z^a abcZ sbgs_daebgau 1 2 3 … 4 Ž 56 5VŒ 7 V 7 … XYea aZs]ebg k ^ZaZg]a ` m^eZ\ blZ^leZ p b\ ]YZ ie_j Zy]Zgaebga ]b i `a ad kk b^]Zf mn ie_jq{u ú.b^ ` sbc k _Z]Z fZas^ek ]ebgt sbgad_] ]YZ ie_jq{ c`gd`_ “”uý XYZ jZn \Z`]d^Za b\ ]YZ _`gq hd`hZ `^Z ]YZ a k Zse[s`]ebg b\ k `^`__Z_eac `gf angsY^bgex`q ]ebgt ]Y^bdhY ]YZ 89:;< `gf 8=< jZn p b^fat `gf ]YZ a k Zseq [s`]ebg b\ gbgfZ]Z^cegeact daegh !B  t aegsZ e] ea `g eg]Z^g`_ \dgs]ebg b\ Š!@  u ) b _bsj ea ^Zde^Zf `^bdgf ]YZ `ssZaaZa ]b Ž mn 8Œ >B t mZs`daZ ie_j k ^blefZa `]bcese]n ec k _ese]_nu XYZ sbgsZ^g ea ]Y`] ]YZ ]p b d k f`]Za cehY] bssd^ eg k `^`__Z_t `gf e\ `]bcesq e]n ea gb] ec k baZft `g d k f`]Z cehY] mZ _ba]u ie_j k ^blefZa ec k _ese] `]bcese]n `cbgh ]YZ o]Y^Z`far b\ ` k ^bsZfd^Z egq a]`gsZt p YZ^Z `  ‹ ea ` c`yec`_ aZdZgsZ b\ ega]^dsq ]ebga Zgfegh p e]Y ` 89:;< t 8=< t b^ B>?ŒB< úZe]YZ^ Zy k _ese] b^ ec k _ese]ý a]`]ZcZg]u zg eg_Z] ea k ^Zs_dfZf \^bc sbg]`egegh 89:;< `gf 8=< a]`]ZcZg]at `gf ]Yda e] b k Z^`]Za `]bces`__n `a ` aegh_Z ]Y^Z`fu c k _ese] `]bcese]n aec k _e[Za ^Z`abgegh ºÀ ¤šœ›ž˜š •–šº º¢ š˜š¼—˜— £  §˜žŸŸ ™¡ › º—¼Á —£¡š™£›¼ Ÿ™ ­™›» º—¡–§ž£œ¡— £˜¹ —£¼š¡˜ —˜ º—¼Á £ ¡ ¨±Ã¾ ¨±Ã¾ £ ¡ —˜ ¤›˜š¢ º ¡šœ–£ ¼ ­¥À – š©š™À –—œ– ¢ š˜ Ÿ™ ©—¢š ¡–—˜ ˜žŸŸ ™¡¹  £ °£ž 





















cZg]`_ _bp Z^ mbdgfa `a ]b Ybp \`a] ` ie_j k ^bh^`c s`g ^dgu Z] da fZgb]Z mn   ]YZ ZyZsd]ebg ]ecZ b\ ` helZg sbc k d]`q ]ebg bg  k ^bsZaab^au XYZgt ]YZ p b^j b\ ]YZ sbc k d]`]ebg ea  `gf e]a s^e]es`_q k `]Y _Zgh]Y ea   u .b^ ` sbc k d]`]ebg p e]Y ‰  p b^jt ]YZ _b p Z^ mbdgf      cda] Yb_ft mZs`daZ `] ‰ ‰ cba]  dge]a b\ p b^j s`g mZ ZyZsd]Zf eg ` aegh_Z a]Z k u g `ffe]ebgt ]YZ _bp Z^ mbdgf      cda] Yb_ft aegsZ ` [ge]Z gdcmZ^ b\ k ^bsZaab^a s`ggb] ZyZsd]Z \`a]Z^ ]Y`g `g eg[ge]Z gdcmZ^u ie_j€a ^`gfbcexZf p b^jqa]Z`_egh asYZfd_Z^ ‘t {” ZyZsd]Za ` ie_j sbc k d]`]ebg bg  k ^bsZaab^a eg Zy k Zs]Zf ]ecZ      ú  ý úý ‰ `aadcegh `g efZ`_ k `^`__Z_ sbc k d]Z^u XYea Zd`]ebg ^ZaZcq m_Za o ^Zg]€a ]YZb^Zcr }t {” `gf ea b k ]ec`_ ]b p e]Yeg ` sbga]`g] \`s]b^t aegsZ   `gf   `^Z mb]Y _bp Z^ mbdgfau þZ s`__ ]YZ [^a] ]Z^c bg‰ ]YZ ^ehY]qY`gf aefZ b\ - d`]ebg úý ]YZ   ]Z^c `gf ]YZ aZsbgf ]Z^c ]YZ    ]Z^cu c k b^]`g]_nt `__ sbccdges`]ebg sba]a fdZ ]b ie_j€a asYZfd_Z^ `^Z mb^gZ mn ]YZ s^e]es`_q k `]Y ]Z^ct `a `^Z cba] b\ ]YZ b]YZ^ asYZfd_egh sba]au Xb c`jZ ]YZaZ blZ^YZ`fa Zy k _ese]t p Z fZq [gZ ]YZ     '   ‹ ]b mZ ]YZ ac`__Za] sbga]`g]

 adsY ]Y`]          ú|ý ‰ XYZ aZsbgf `aadc k ]ebg gZZfZf ]b ƒda]e\n ]YZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Z \bsdaZa bg ]YZ osbccbgqs`aZr ^ZhecZ eg p YesY ` k `^`__Z_ k ^bh^`c b k Z^`]Zau ‚Z[gZ ]YZ '      ( `a      t p YesY sb^^Za k bgfa ]b ]YZ c`yecdc k baq aem_Z a k ZZfd‰ k ]Y`] ]YZ ` kk _es`]ebg s`g bm]`egu ‚Z[gZ `_ab ]YZ       |“” ]b mZ ]YZ ^`]eb    u XYZ   (          ea ]Y`]      t p YesY cZ`ga ]Y`] ]YZ gdcmZ^  b\ k ^bsZaab^a ea cdsY ac`__Z^ ]Y`g ]YZ `lZ^`hZ k `^`__Z_eac  u  gfZ^ ]Yea `aadc k ]ebgt e] \b__bp a ]Y`]  ‰       t `gf YZgsZ \^bc gZd`_e]n ú|ý ]Y`]       t `gf p Z bm]`eg _egZ`^ a k ZZfd k u XYZ s^e]es`_q ‰ k `]Y blZ^YZ`f

 Y`a _e]]_Z Z 0 Zs] bg k Z^\b^c`gsZ p YZg advq seZg] a_`sjgZaa Zyea]at `_]YbdhY e] fbZa fZ]Z^cegZa Ybp cdsY a_`sjgZaa cda] Zyea] ]b Zgad^Z _egZ`^ a k ZZfd k u þYZ]YZ^ adma]`g]e`_ a_`sjgZaa Zyea]a eg sbccbg ` kk _es`q ]ebga ea ` c`]]Z^ b\ b k egebg `gf Zc k e^eseact md] p Z adhhZa] ]Y`] a_`sjgZaa ea ]YZ sbccbg s`aZu XYZ Zy k ^ZaaelZgZaa b\ ie_j c`jZa e] Z`an ]b sbfZ ` kk _es`]ebga p e]Y _`^hZ `cbdg]a b\ k `^`__Z_eacu .b^ cbfZa]qaexZf k ^bm_Zcat c`gn ` kk _es`q ]ebga ZyYeme] `g `lZ^`hZ k `^`__Z_eac b\ blZ^ | t neZ_fegh admq a]`g]e`_ a_`sjgZaa bg sbg]Zc k b^`^n û~ü€au - lZg bg û`gfe` ) `]ebg`_ `mb^`]b^n€a g]Z_ ü`^`hbgt p YesY sbg]`ega “|’ gbfZat ]YZ ÿûbs^`]Za sYZaa k ^bh^`c úsbfZf eg ie_jqý ^`g eg e]a _egZ`^qa k ZZfd k ^ZhecZ fd^egh ]YZ  { iiz þb^_f ibc k d]Z^ iYZaa iY`c k ebgaYek úp YZ^Z e] k _`sZf aZsbgf eg ` [Z_f b\ |’ýu ûZs]ebg } fZas^emZa ` fbxZg b]YZ^ felZ^aZ ` kk _es`]ebga p YesY p Z^Z ^dg bg `g “q k ^bsZaab^ û~ü p e]Y  ›¤˜¡™›œ¡ » ¢š¼  §š šœ¡˜À š“ šœž¡— £ —­£ ™š˜Âž—¡š ™š›¼µ¼—§š ¢š¡›—¼˜À ˜žœ–•–—˜ ›˜ »š» ™¥µ–—š™›™œ–¥ ¤ž¡ —˜ ¡—»š £ £š¡–š¼š˜˜ ›œœž™›¡š ”´ • ¹

sbgaefZ^`m_Z k `^`__Z_ a_`sjgZaau XYZ k `^`__Z_eaec b\ ]YZaZ ` k q k _es`]ebga egs^Z`aZa p e]Y k ^bm_Zc aexZt ]YZ^Zmn Zgad^egh ]YZn p e__ ^dg p Z__ bg _`^hZ c`sYegZau XYZ ]Ye^f `aadc k ]ebg mZYegf ]YZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Z ea ]Y`] ZlZ^n ie_j k ^bh^`c Y`a ` i Z_eaebg `h`ega] p YesY e]a bgZq k ^bsZaab^ k Z^\b^c`gsZ s`g mZ cZ`ad^Zfu Z] da fZgb]Z mn   ]YZ ^dggegh ]ecZ b\ ]YZ i Z_eaebgu XYZgt p Z fZ[gZ ]YZ    '   ‹ mn ‰   ‰    u gsb^ k b^`]egh s^e]es`_q k `]Y `gf p b^j blZ^YZ`fa eg]b gZd`_e]n ú|ý neZ_fa          ú‘ý ‰  

‰  

aegsZ p Z `aadcZ k `^`__Z_ a_`sjgZaau þZ s`g gbp ^Za]`]Z ]YZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Z k ^ZseaZ_nu      ‰              t mZs`daZ ‰ Y`a ` cb^Z fe^Zs] ec k `s] bg k Z^\b^c`gsZu zfb k ]egh ]YZ p b^jq[^a] ^egse _Z c`n `flZ^aZ_n ` 0 Zs] ]YZ `me_e]n b\ `g ` kk _es`]ebg k k ]b as`_Z d k t Ybp ZlZ^t e\ ]YZ s^e]es`_q k `]Y blZ^YZ`f  ea ]bb _`^hZu d]t `a p Z aY`__ aZZ eg ûZs]ebg }t s^e]es`_q k `]Y blZ^q YZ`f ea ^Z`abg`m_n ac`__ eg ie_jq{t `gf c`gn ` kk _es`]ebga s`g mZ sbfZf p e]Y _`^hZ `cbdg]a b\ k `^`__Z_eacu XYZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Z k Z^l`fZa ]YZ ie_jq{ ec k _ZcZg]`q ]ebgu XYZ p b^jqa]Z`_egh asYZfd_Z^ hd`^`g]ZZa ]Y`] p e]Y YehY k ^bm`me_e]nt bg_n ú   ý a]Z`_ úceh^`]ebgý `]]Zc k ]a bssd^ ú]Y`] eat ú  ý bg `lZ^`hZ k Z^ k ^bsZaab^ýt `__ sba]a \b^ p YesY `^Z mb^gZ bg ]YZ s^e]es`_ k `]Yu ibgaZdZg]_nt ]YZ asYZfd_Z^ \b^ ie_jq{ k ba] k bgZa `a cdsY b\ ]YZ asYZfd_egh sba] `a k baq aem_Z ]b p YZg p b^j ea mZegh a]b_Zgt ]YZ^Zmn ^Zcblegh e] `a ` sbg]^emd]b^ ]b p b^j blZ^YZ`fu XYea a]^`]Zhn b\ `cb^]exq egh sba]a `h`ega] a]Z`_ `]]Zc k ]a k Z^cZ`]Za le^]d`__n ZlZ^n fZseaebg c`fZ eg ]YZ fZaehg b\ ]YZ asYZfd_Z^u  4 Ž 56 S Wˆ  Ž 5VTŽˆŒ STUVT… 7 † XYea aZs]ebg fZas^emZa Ybp bd^ !"# $ sbc k e_Z^ hZgZ^`]Za i k ba]abd^sZ \^bc ` ie_j k ^bh^`cu za fes]`]Zf mn ]YZ p b^jq [^a] k ^egsek _Zt bd^ sbc k e_Z^ `gf asYZfd_Z^ `^Z fZaehgZf ]b ^ZfdsZ ]YZ p b^j blZ^YZ`f `a cdsY `a k baaem_Zu d^ a]^`]Zhn ea ]b hZgZ^`]Z ]p b s_bgZa b\ Z`sY k ^bsZfd^Z& `  s_bgZ `gf `   s_bgZu XYZ \`a] s_bgZ b k Z^`]Za cdsY `a fbZa ]YZ i Z_eaebg `gf Y`a _e]]_Z ad kk b^] \b^ k `^`__Z_eacu XYZ a_bp s_bgZ Y`a \d__ ad kk b^] \b^ k `^`__Z_eact `_bgh p e]Y e]a sbgsbce]`g] blZ^YZ`fu þZ [^a] fZas^emZ ]YZ ie_j asYZfd_egh `_hb^e]Ycu XYZgt p Z fZas^emZ Ybp ]YZ sbc k e_Z^ ]^`ga_`]Za ]YZ ie_j _`gq hd`hZ sbga]^ds]a eg]b sbfZ \b^ ]YZ \`a] `gf a_bp s_bgZa b\ Z`sY k ^bsZfd^Zu `a]_nt p Z fZas^emZ Ybp ]YZ ^dg]ecZ anaq ]Zc _egja ]bhZ]YZ^ ]YZ `s]ebga b\ ]YZ \`a] `gf a_bp s_bgZa ]b k ^bfdsZ ` sbc k _Z]Z ie_j ec k _ZcZg]`]ebgu za eg _`xn ]`aj s^Z`]ebg |’”t eg ie_jq{ Z`sY k ^bsZaq ab^t s`__Zf `   t c`eg]`ega `  ‹  ‹   úfbdm_nq ZgfZf dZdZý b\ ^Z`fn k ^bsZfd^Za ú]ZsYges`__nt k ^bsZfd^Z ega]`gsZaýu - `sY fZdZ Y`a ]p b Zgfat `  ‹ `gf `  t \^bc p YesY k ^bsZfd^Za s`g mZ `ffZf b^ ^ZcblZfu z p b^jZ^ b k Z^`]Za _bs`__n bg ]YZ ]`e_ b\ e]a bp g fZdZt ]^Z`]egh e] cdsY 







õ

DEM T DN UDEM E V W T DN  TY`f J hT Z T ^ `GGRF ULD JRT UhT VV Z TbQLDg ^ T DN  LDg Z DT UEKXV W TYJJ UT \ LD JRT UhT VV Z YJMHYE E Z e JGLJ W DEM [ \ ] Z TbQJEMY] ^ c Z TbQE ^ E Z h ^ T Z _HLP UV Z [ ^ T DN UEbcV Z DT U_R_ U[ V ^^  m  V YJMHYE q Z

    

÷ö õõõ õõ õõ õõ õ÷õö õ

    



Z TYJJ UT \ LD JRT UhT VV Z YJMHYE U[d] V Z



 

e

e

`c k _Z b\ ]YZ k ba]abd^sZ \b^ ]YZ \`a] s_bgZ b\ Š!@ ea helZg eg . ehd^Z ‘u XYZ hZgZ^`]Zf i sbfZ Y`a ]YZ a`cZ hZgZ^`_ a]^ds]d^Z `a ]YZ i Z_eaebgt p e]Y ` \Z p `ffe]ebg`_ a]`]ZcZg]au g _egZa ’ {t `g   '   (  ea `__bs`]Zf \b^ Š!@ `gf ege]e`_exZfu XYZ ie_j ^dg]ecZ ana]Zc daZa `s]el`]ebg \^`cZa ]b ^Z k ^ZaZg] k ^bsZfd^Z ega]`gsZau  aegh ]ZsYgedZa aece_`^ ]b }t /”t bd^ eg_egZf `__bs`]b^ ]n k es`__n ]`jZa bg_n ` \Z p sns_Zau XYZ \^`cZ ea ege]e`_exZf eg _egZ { mn a]b^egh ` k beg]Z^ ]b ` a]`]es a]^ds]d^Zt s`__Zf ` aehg`]d^Zt fZas^emegh Š!@ u XYZ [^a] a k `p g eg Š!@ ea ]^`ga_`]Zf eg]b _egZa | “u g _egZa | ‘t ]YZ a]`]Z b\ ]YZ Š!@ k ^bsZfd^Z ea a`lZf eg]b ]YZ `s]el`]ebg \^`cZu XYZ a`lZf a]`]Z egs_dfZa ]YZ k ^bh^`c sbdg]Z^t ZgsbfZf `a `g Zg]^n gdcmZ^t `gf `__ _elZt fe^]n l`^eq `m_Zau XYZgt ]YZ \^`cZ ea k daYZf bg ]YZ ^dg]ecZ fZdZ eg _egZa ’ {u ) Zy]t p Z s`__ ]YZ Š!@ ^bd]egZ `a p Z p bd_f eg iu Zs`daZ ]YZ 89:;< a]`]ZcZg] e]aZ_\ sbc k e_Za fe^Zs]_n ]b e]a i Z_eaebgt ]YZ k ba]abd^sZ s`g Zy k _be] ]YZ b k ]ecex`]ebg s` k `me_e]eZa b\ ]YZ i sbc k e_Z^t egs_dfegh e]a `me_e]n ]b k `aa `^hdcZg]a `gf ^ZsZelZ ^Z]d^g l`_dZa eg ^Zhea]Z^a ^`]YZ^ ]Y`g eg cZcb^nu z\]Z^ Š!@ ^Z]d^gat _egZa / “ sYZsj ]b aZZ p YZ]YZ^ ]YZ `^Zg] k k ^bsZfd^Z Y`a mZZg a]b_Zgu \ e] Y`at p Z ^Z]d^g ecq cZfe`]Z_n p e]Y ` fdccn l`_dZu ûegsZ `__ b\ ]YZ `gsZa]b^a Y`lZ mZZg a]b_Zg `a p Z__t ]YZ i a]`sj desj_n dgp egfa `gf sbg]^b_ ea ^Z]d^gZf ]b ]YZ ^dg]ecZ ana]Zcu XYZ k ^b]bsb_ ]b sYZsj p YZ]YZ^ ]YZ k `^Zg] k ^bsZfd^Z Y`a mZZg a]b_Zg ea de]Z adm]_Z& p Z k ba] k bgZ feasdaaebg b\ e]a ec k _ZcZg]`]ebg ]b ûZs]ebg {u \ ]YZ k `^Zg] k ^bsZfd^Z Y`a gb] mZZg a]b_Zgt e] sbg]egdZa ]b ZyZsd]Z `] _egZ  t k Z^\b^cegh ]YZ aZsbgf a k `p gt p YesY ea gb] aYbp gu g ]YZ \`a] s_bgZt `__ 8=< a]`]ZcZg]a sbc k e_Z ]b gbqb k au Zs`daZ ` \`a] s_bgZ gZlZ^ Y`a `gn sYe_f^Zg p YZg e] ea ZyZq sd]eght p Z jgbp `] sbc k e_Z ]ecZ ]Y`] `__ k ^Zlebda_n a k `p gZf k ^bsZfd^Za Y`lZ sbc k _Z]Zfu XYdat gb b k Z^`]ebga `^Z ^Zq de^Zf \b^ ` 8=< a]`]ZcZg]t `a e] `_p `na adssZZfau .b^ Zy`cq k _Zt _egZ | eg . ehd^Z ‘t ]YZ ]^`ga_`]ebg b\ ]YZ 8=< a]`]ZcZg] ea ƒda] ]YZ Zc k ]n a]`]ZcZg]u . eg`__nt eg _egZa | ||t Š!@ fZ`_q _bs`]Za ]YZ `s]el`]ebg \^`cZ `gf ^Z]d^ga ]YZ sbc k d]Zf ^Zad_] ]b e]a k `^Zg] k ^bsZfd^Zu XYZ a_bp s_bgZ ea aece_`^ ]b ]YZ \`a] s_bgZ ZysZ k ] ]Y`] e] k ^blefZa ad kk b^] \b^ k `^`__Z_ ZyZsd]ebgu þYZg ` k ^bsZq fd^Z ea a]b_Zgt sbg]^b_ Y`a mZZg ada k ZgfZf mZ]p ZZg ]p b b\ ]YZ k ^bsZfd^Z€a ]Y^Z`fat ]Y`] eat `] ` a k `p g b^ angs k beg]u þYZg ]YZ a_bp s_bgZ ea ^ZadcZft e] daZa ` % A?A a]`]ZcZg] ]b ^Za]b^Z ]YZ k ^bh^`c sbdg]Z^t `gf ]YZg e] ^Za]b^Za _bs`_ l`^e`m_Z a]`]Z \^bc ]YZ `s]el`]ebg \^`cZu z 89:;< a]`]ZcZg] ea ]^`ga_`]Zf eg ]YZ a_bp s_bgZ ƒda] `a eg ]YZ \`a] s_bgZu .b^ ` 8=< a]`]ZcZg]t !"# $ egaZ^]a ` s`__ ]b ]YZ ^dg]ecZ ana]Zct p YesY sYZsja ]b aZZ p YZ]YZ^ ]YZ k ^bsZfd^Z Y`a `gn a k `p gZf sYe_f^Zg ]Y`] Y`lZ gb] ^Z]d^gZfu z_]YbdhY ]YZ k `^`__Z_ mbbjq ¾§ »ž˜¡ ¡–š ˜–›™š¢ »š» ™¥¤š¡šš£ —˜ £ ¡ ¼—£š˜ ˜šÂžš£¡—›¼¼¥ œ £˜—˜¡š£¡À › ¡–›¡ »š» ™¥ §š£œš ¤š —£˜š™¡š¢ ³´ ›£¢ ³¸ ¡  š£˜ž™š ¡–š ˜ž™™ ž£¢—£­ ™—¡š˜ ›™š š “ šœž¡š¢ —£ ¡–š Ÿ™ Ÿš™  ™¢š™¹ •–š ˜¡™›¡š­¥ —˜§›œ—¼—¡¥  ž™ ž£—£¢—£­ ˜—»Ÿ¼š™¹ § º œ ž¼¢ –›©š ¤šš£ ž˜š¢ ›˜ š¼¼À ¤ž¡

ÖÍäåÐ ÎÒÓ×ÐÍ äÒÓÒ×Òä êêÎÏä×ÐêÒé ÐÖÍäåÐ ÖÍäåÐ ÖÍÐÐ ÖÍäåÐ 



ÕäÕä ÐÐ ÌÒ ÝÐ äÍÕ êÖÍäåÐ é ÎÒÓ×ÐÍ Õ×ÎÍÐ éÑÎæÕØÝ ÖÍäåÐ Ïä êê Îé ÖÍäåÐ éÖÍäåÐ Õ×ÎÕ äêÐÓÓ ÕÐÏÎÓÑ é ÕÖÍÐÐÓÏÖÍäåÐ ÒÕ ÖÍÐÐ











 





rstuvw y Ä € È Æ { ï  ðÅËÈ ~ ÈËÈÉÆïÈò ƒ† FDGSXF ÅÉ ï € È T DN ÇÉÅ  È òôÉÈ ‚ Ê ~ ôÉÈ õø Ä € È  ÅòÈ ÅÉ ï € È { È  ÅËò { ÇÆ Ë Ê { Å | ÊïïÈòø { `GGRF ÆËò TYJJ ÆÉÈ ÊËðÊËÈò  Æðð { ïÅ ï € È ÉôËïÊ | È Ä{†{€ ÈïÈ |ôËÉÅ{|ïÊÅË { ï | È | ÅÉ † ÆððÅ  ÆïÅÉø Ä € È { Ê ~ ËÆïôÉÈ T DN LDg  ÅËïÆÊË { Æ Æ òÈ { ÉÊÇïÊÅË Å ï € È T DN ÇÉÅ  ÈòôÉÈí ÊË  ðôòÊË ~ Æ ÇÅÊËïÈÉ ïÅ ï € È {ðÅ  ðÅËÈø Ä € È _HLP ÆËò _R_  Æðð { ÆÉÈ ÅÇÈÉÆïÊÅË { ÅË ï € È {€ ÈòôðÊË ~ òÈ ôÈ ÆËò ÆÉÈ òÈ { Éʃ Èò ÊË òÈïÆÊð ÊË È ïÊÅË ø `a i ]^Z`]a e]a s`__ a]`sjt k daYegh `gf k b kk egh a k `p gZf `s]eq l`]ebg \^`cZau þYZg ` p b^jZ^ ^dga bd] b\ p b^jt e] mZsbcZa `  `gf `]]Zc k ]a ]b a]Z`_ ` k ^bsZfd^Z `gb]YZ^ p b^jZ^t s`__Zf e]a '   ( u XYZ ]YeZ\ a]Z`_a ]YZ k ^bsZfd^Z \^bc ]YZ YZ`f b\ ]YZ les]ec€a fZdZt ]YZ b kk bae]Z Zgf \^bc p YesY ]YZ les]ec ea p b^jeghu þYZg ` k ^bsZfd^Z ea a k `p gZft ]YZ \`a] s_bgZ ^dgau þYZgq ZlZ^ ` ]YeZ\ a]Z`_a ` k ^bsZfd^Zt Ybp ZlZ^t ]YZ k ^bsZfd^Z ea sbglZ^]Zf ]b ` a_bp s_bgZu XYZ ie_j asYZfd_Z^ hd`^`g]ZZa ]Y`] ]YZ gdcmZ^ b\ a]Z`_a ea ac`__ p YZg advseZg] a_`sjgZaa Zyea]at `gf ab p Z Zy k Zs] ]YZ \`a] s_bgZa ]b mZ ZyZsd]Zf cba] b\ ]YZ ]ecZu XYdat ]YZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Z ^ZfdsZa ]b cegeq cexegh sba]a eg ]YZ \`a] s_bgZt p YesY sbg]^emd]Z cb^Z YZ`le_n ]b p b^j blZ^YZ`fu ~egecexegh sba]a eg ]YZ a_bp s_bgZt `_q ]YbdhY ` fZae^`m_Z hb`_t ea _Zaa ec k b^]`g]t aegsZ ]YZaZ sba]a sbg]^emd]Z _Zaa YZ`le_n ]b p b^j blZ^YZ`f `gf cb^Z ]b s^e]es`_q k `]Y blZ^YZ`fu þZ cegecexZ ]YZ sba]a b\ ]YZ \`a] s_bgZ mn Zy k _be]egh ]YZ a]^ds]d^Z b\ ]YZ ie_j asYZfd_Z^u Zs`daZ p Z sbglZ^] ` k ^bq sZfd^Z ]b e]a a_bp s_bgZ p YZg e] ea a]b_Zgt p Z c`eg]`eg ]YZ egl`^e`g] ]Y`] ` \`a] s_bgZ Y`a gZlZ^ mZZg a]b_Zgu .d^]YZ^q cb^Zt gbgZ b\ ]YZ fZasZgf`g]a b\ ` \`a] s_bgZ Y`lZ mZZg a]b_Zg Ze]YZ^t aegsZ ]YZ a]^`]Zhn b\ a]Z`_egh \^bc ]YZ YZ`fa b\ ^Z`fn fZdZa hd`^`g]ZZa ]Y`] k `^Zg]a `^Z a]b_Zg mZ\b^Z ]YZe^ sYe_f^Zgu za p Z aY`__ aZZt ]Yea aec k _Z \`s] `__bp a c`gn b k ]ecex`]ebga ]b mZ k Z^\b^cZf eg ]YZ \`a] s_bgZu þZ gbp fZas^emZ Ybp bd^ !"# $ sbc k e_Z^ hZgZ^`]Za k ba]q abd^sZ i sbfZ \b^ ]YZ Š!@ k ^bsZfd^Z \^bc . ehd^Z u zg Zyq  





 































!

-

"#$ %&' ()*+ ,%&'

]ebga _Zf ]b sbc k _es`]Zf k ^b]bsb_au - lZg ]YbdhY ]YZaZ blZ^q YZ`fa sbd_f mZ sY`^hZf ]b ]YZ s^e]es`_q k `]Y ]Z^ct eg k ^`s]esZt ]YZn mZs`cZ ab _`^hZ ]Y`] ]YZ s^e]es`_q k `]Y ]Z^c sbg]^emd]Zf aehge[s`g]_n ]b ]YZ ^dggegh ]ecZt ]YZ^Zmn leb_`]egh ]YZ `aq adc k ]ebg b\ k `^`__Z_ a_`sjgZaau z bgZq k ^bsZaab^ ZyZsd]ebg b\ ` k ^bh^`c p `a egfZZf \`a]t md] egadvseZg] a_`sjgZaa abcZq ]ecZa ^Zad_]Zf eg k bb^ k `^`__Z_ k Z^\b^c`gsZu g ie_jq{t p Z aec k _e[Zf ]YZ `__bs`]ebg b\ `s]el`]ebg \^`cZa mn aec k _n daegh ` YZ` k u g ]YZ sbccbg s`aZt ` \^`cZ ea `__bs`]Zf mn ^Zcblegh e] \^bc ` \^ZZ _ea]u ‚Z`__bs`]ebg ea k Z^\b^cZf mn egaZ^]egh ]YZ \^`cZ eg]b ]YZ \^ZZ _ea]u ) b daZ^q _ZlZ_ c`g`hZcZg] b\ le^]d`_ cZcb^n ea ^Zde^Zft ZysZ k ] \b^ ]YZ ege]e`_ aZ]d k b\ aY`^Zf cZcb^nu , Z` k `__bs`]ebg sbgq ]^emd]Za bg_n a_ehY]_n cb^Z ]Y`g a]`sj `__bs`]ebg ]b ]YZ p b^j blZ^YZ`ft md] e] a`lZa adma]`g]e`__n bg ]YZ s^e]es`_ k `]Y ]Z^cu g ]YZ fbp gaefZt YZ` k `__bs`]ebg s`g k b]Zg]e`__n p `a]Z cb^Z cZcb^n ]Y`g a]`sj `__bs`]ebg fdZ ]b \^`hcZg]`]ebgu .b^ ` s`^Z\d_ `g`_naea b\ ]YZ ^Z_`]elZ cZ^e]a b\ a]`sj `gf YZ` k m`aZf `__bs`]ebg ]Y`] ad kk b^]a YZ` k `__bs`]ebgt aZZ ]YZ k ` k Z^ mn z kk Z_ `gf ûY`b ”u .b^ `g Zd`__n s`^Z\d_ `g`_naea ]Y`] ad kk b^]a a]`sj `__bs`]ebgt aZZ ||”u XYdat `_]YbdhY ]YZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Z helZa ` hZgZ^`_ dgq fZ^a]`gfegh b\ p YZ^Z blZ^YZ`fa aYbd_f mZ mb^gZt bd^ Zy k Zq ^eZgsZ p e]Y ie_jq’ aYbp Zf ]Y`] _`^hZ ZgbdhY s^e]es`_q k `]Y blZ^YZ`fa s`g ]ek ]YZ as`_Za ]b ]YZ k beg] p YZ^Z ]YZ `aadc k q ]ebga dgfZ^_negh ]YZ k ^egsek _Z gb _bghZ^ Yb_fu þZ mZ_eZlZ ]Y`] ie_jq{ p b^j blZ^YZ`f ea gZ`^_n `a _bp `a k baaem_Zt helZg bd^ hb`_ b\ hZgZ^`]egh k b^]`m_Z i bd] k d] \^bc bd^ sbc k e_Z^u ]YZ^ ^ZaZ`^sYZ^a Y`lZ mZZg `m_Z ]b ^ZfdsZ blZ^YZ`fa ZlZg cb^Zt Ybp ZlZ^t `] ]YZ Zy k ZgaZ b\ k b^]`me_e]nu .b^ Zy`c k _Zt _`xn ]Y^Z`fa ’” bm]`ega ZvseZgsn `] ]YZ Zy k ZgaZ b\ ecq k _ZcZg]egh e]a bp g s`__egh sbglZg]ebgat a]`sj _`nbd]at Z]su z_]YbdhY p Z sbd_f eg k ^egsek _Z egsb^ k b^`]Z adsY c`sYegZq fZ k ZgfZg] ]ZsYgedZa eg]b bd^ sbc k e_Z^t p Z \ZZ_ ]Y`] ie_jq{ a]^ejZa ` hbbf m`_`gsZ mZ]p ZZg k Z^\b^c`gsZ `gf k b^]`me_e]nu þZ `_ab \ZZ_ ]Y`] ]YZ sd^^Zg] blZ^YZ`fa `^Z advseZg]_n _bp ]Y`] b]YZ^ k ^bm_Zcat gb]`m_n cegecexegh blZ^YZ`fa \b^ f`]` angsY^bgex`]ebgt fZaZ^lZ cb^Z `]]Zg]ebgu ‹ 5…  …ŒTŽˆŒ ˆ ‡ˆU 6 ST…V 5ŽŒ 7 g ]Yea aZs]ebgt p Z fZas^emZ ie_jq{€a p b^jqa]Z`_egh cZsY`q geact p YesY ea m`aZf bg ` ‚eƒ ja]^`q_ejZ ”t aY`^ZfqcZcb^nt cd]d`_qZys_daebg k ^b]bsb_ s`__Zf ]YZ oX , - r k ^b]bsb_u g `ssb^f`gsZ p e]Y ]YZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Zt ]Yea k ^b]bsb_ Y`a mZZg fZaehgZf ]b cegecexZ p b^j blZ^YZ`fu .b^ Zy`c k _Zt bg ` } /qcZh`YZ^]x  _]^`ûüz i t ]YZ Š!@ k ^bh^`c p e]Y ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_ ^dga `mbd] |{ \`a]Z^ ]Y`g p e]Y Y`^f p `^Z _bsjegh k ^ece]elZau þZ [^a] k ^ZaZg] ` aec k _e[Zf lZ^aebg b\ ]YZ k ^b]bsb_u XYZgt p Z feasdaa ]YZ `s]d`_ ec k _ZcZg]`]ebgt p YesY `__bp a ZysZ k ]ebga ]b mZ aehg`_Zf p e]Y gb `ffe]ebg`_ blZ^YZ`fu ¨¼¡– ž­– ¡–š ™ž£¡—»š ˜¥˜¡š» ™šÂž—™š˜ ˜ »š š–›¡˜ š©š™   ™¡ ¡  Ÿ ™¡ ¤š¡šš£ ›™œ–—¡šœ¡ž™š˜À ¡–š œ »Ÿ—¼š™ ™šÂž—™š˜ £  œ–›£­š˜ § ™ ¢— š™µ š£¡ Ÿ¼›¡§ ™»˜¹

jZZ k egh eg ` a_bp s_bgZ ea adma]`g]e`_t e] sbg]^emd]Za _e]]_Z ]b p b^j blZ^YZ`ft aegsZ a_bp s_bgZa `^Z ^`^Z_n ZyZsd]Zfu XYZ aZ k `^`]ebg mZ]p ZZg \`a] s_bgZa `gf a_bp s_bgZa `_ab `__bp a da ]b sbc k e_Z eg_Z]a `gf `mb^] a]`]ZcZg]a ZvseZg]_n eg ]YZ \`a] s_bgZu zg eg_Z] s`__ sbc k e_Za `a ZvseZg]_n `a `g b^feg`^n a k `p gu .b^ Zy`c k _Zt ]YZ sbfZ \b^ ]YZ eg_Z] s`__ \^bc . ehd^Z | sbc k e_Za aece_`^_n ]b ]YZ \b__b p egh ie_j sbfZw Mf_ ^ L_`aE T DN UEbcV Z LHff JY UMf_ V Z

c k _ese] eg_Z] s`__at adsY `a Ž  89:;< Š!@ <  t sbc k e_Z fe^Zs]_n ]b ]YZe^ i Z_eaebgau zg :@AB? a]`]ZcZg] sbc k e_Za ]b ` gbqb k ƒda] `a ` 8=< a]`]ZcZg] fbZat mZs`daZ p Ye_Z e] ea ZyZsd]eght ` \`a] s_bgZ Y`a gb sYe_f^Zg ]b `mb^]u XYZ ^dg]ecZ ana]Zc k ^blefZa ]YZ h_dZ mZ]p ZZg ]YZ \`a] `gf a_bp s_bgZa ]Y`] c`jZa ]YZ p Yb_Z ana]Zc p b^ju ] egs_dfZa k ^b]bsb_a \b^ a]Z`_egh k ^bsZfd^Zat ^Z]d^gegh l`_dZa mZ]p ZZg k ^bsZaab^at ZyZsd]egh eg_Z]at `mb^]egh sbc k d]`]ebg adm]^ZZat `gf ]YZ _ejZu z__ b\ ]YZ sba]a b\ ]YZaZ k ^b]bsb_a s`g mZ `cb^q ]exZf `h`ega] ]YZ s^e]es`_ k `]Yt ab ]YZe^ blZ^YZ`f fbZa gb] aehge[s`g]_n ` 0 Zs] ]YZ ^dggegh ]ecZ p YZg advseZg] k `^`__Z_ a_`sjgZaa Zyea]au XYZ k b^]ebg b\ ]YZ a]Z`_egh k ^b]bsb_ ZyZq sd]Zf mn ]YZ p b^jZ^ sbg]^emd]Za ]b p b^j blZ^YZ`ft Ybp ZlZ^t ]YZ^Zmn p `^^`g]egh ` s`^Z\d_ ec k _ZcZg]`]ebgu þZ feasdaa ]Yea k ^b]bsb_ eg fZ]`e_ eg ûZs]ebg {u XYZ p b^j blZ^YZ`f b\ ` 89:;< eg ie_jq{ ea bg_n ` \Z p ^Z`fa `gf p ^e]Za eg ]YZ \`a] s_bgZ& ‘ ^Z`fa `gf { p ^e]Za \b^ ]YZ Š!@ Zy`c k _Zu þZ p e__ Zy k Z^ecZg]`__n d`g]e\n ]YZ p b^j blZ^YZ`f eg ûZs]ebg }u ûbcZ p b^j blZ^YZ`fa a]e__ ^Zc`eg eg bd^ ecq k _ZcZg]`]ebgt Ybp ZlZ^t egs_dfegh ]YZ `__bs`]ebg `gf \^ZZegh b\ `s]el`]ebg \^`cZat a`legh a]`]Z mZ\b^Z ` a k `p gt k daYegh `gf k b kk egh b\ ]YZ \^`cZ bg ]YZ fZdZt `gf sYZsjegh e\ ` k ^bsZfd^Z Y`a mZZg a]b_Zgu z k b^]ebg b\ ]Yea p b^j blZ^YZ`f ea fdZ ]b ]YZ \`s] ]Y`] ie_jq{ ea fd k _es`]egh ]YZ p b^j ]YZ i sbc k e_Z^ k Z^\b^cat md] `a ûZs]ebg } aYbp at ]Yea blZ^YZ`f ea ac`__u z_]YbdhY ` k ^bfds]ebg ie_j sbc k e_Z^ cehY] mZ `m_Z Z_eceg`]Z ]Yea dggZsZaa`^n p b^jt e] p bd_f _ejZ_n sbc k ^bceaZ k b^]`me_e]nu g ie_jq’t ]YZ k ^Zsd^ab^ ]b ie_jq{t p Z ]bbj ]YZ p b^jq[^a] ^egse k k _Z ]b ]YZ Zy]^ZcZu ie_jq’ k Z^\b^cZf a]`sjqm`aZf `_q _bs`]ebg b\ `s]el`]ebg \^`cZat aegsZ ]YZ p b^j blZ^YZ`f b\ a]`sj `__bs`]ebg ea ac`__Z^ ]Y`g ]YZ blZ^YZ`f b\ YZ` k `__bs`q ]ebgu Zs`daZ b\ ]YZ os`s]da a]`sjr |{” aZc`g]esa b\ ]YZ ie_j a]`sjt Ybp ZlZ^t ie_jq’ Y`f ]b c`g`hZ ]YZ le^]d`_qcZcb^n c` k bg Z`sY k ^bsZaab^ Zy k _ese]_nt `a p `a fbgZ eg | / ”u XYZ p b^j blZ^YZ`f eg ie_jq’ \b^ \^`cZ `__bs`]ebg p `a _e]]_Z cb^Z ]Y`g ]Y`] b\ egs^ZcZg]egh ]YZ a]`sj k beg]Z^t md] p YZgZlZ^ ]YZ a]`sj k beg]Z^ blZ^ bp Zf ` k `hZt `g Zy k ZgaelZ daZ^q_ZlZ_ eg]Z^^d k ] ZgadZft fd^egh p YesY ie_jq’ p bd_f cbfe\n ]YZ cZcb^n c` k u  g\b^]dg`]Z_nt ]YZ b k Z^`]eghqana]Zc cZsYq `geaca ad kk b^]egh ]YZaZ b k Z^`]ebga p Z^Z ]bb a_bp `gf dgq k ^Zfes]`m_Zt `gf ]YZ k baaeme_e]n b\ ` k `hZ \`d_] eg s^e]es`_ aZsq ޟŸ ˜š ›™š§š™š£œš Ÿ™ œš¢ž™š ¤¬šœ¡˜ ¨ ˜Ÿ›£˜ ¡ ›œ¡—©›¡— £ œ–—¼¢™š£§™›»šÀ›£¢¤ž¡º¹ •–š›£¢¡ º œ–—¼¢™š£ œ›£ —£ ¨ ˜ ¢  £ ¡ ˜šš š›œ–  ¡–š™ ˜ §™›»š¹ 

























-







ûZlZ^`_ a]^`ehY]\b^ p `^f cZsY`geaca cehY] mZ sbgaefZ^Zf ]b ec k _ZcZg] ` p b^jqa]Z`_egh k ^b]bsb_u .b^ Zy`c k _Zt ` ]YeZ\ cehY] eg]Z^^d k ] ` p b^jZ^ `gf fZc`gf `]]Zg]ebg \^bc ]Yea les]ecu XYea a]^`]Zhn k ^ZaZg]a k ^bm_Zca \b^ ]p b ^Z`abgau . e^a]t ]YZ cZsY`geaca \b^ aehg`_egh eg]Z^^d k ]a `^Z a_b p t `gf `_]YbdhY `g eg]Z^^d k ] p bd_f mZ mb^gZ bg ]YZ s^e]es`_ k `]Yt e]a _`^hZ sba] sbd_f ]Y^Z`]Zg ]YZ `aadc k ]ebg b\ k `^`__Z_ a_`sjq gZaau ûZsbgft ]YZ p b^jZ^ p bd_f gZsZaa`^e_n egsd^ abcZ blZ^q YZ`f bg ]YZ p b^j ]Z^c ]b Zgad^Z ]Y`] e] sbd_f mZ a`\Z_n eg]Z^^d k ]Zf eg ` s^e]es`_ aZs]ebgu za `g `_]Z^g`]elZ ]b aZgfq egh eg]Z^^d k ]at ]YeZlZa sbd_f k ba] a]Z`_ ^ZdZa]at `gf p b^jZ^a sbd_f k Z^ebfes`__n k b__ \b^ ]YZcu gsZ `h`egt Ybp ZlZ^t ` sba] `ss^dZa ]b ]YZ p b^j blZ^YZ`ft ]Yea ]ecZ \b^ k b__eghu XZsYq gedZa `^Z jgbp g ]Y`] s`g _ece] ]YZ blZ^YZ`f b\ k b__egh |”t md] ]YZn ^Zde^Z ]YZ ad kk b^] b\ ` ab k Yea]es`]Zf sbc k e_Z^u XYZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Z adhhZa]a ]Y`] e] ea ^Z`abg`m_Z ]b d] k adma]`g]e`_ Z 0 b^] eg]b cegecexegh p b^j blZ^YZ`f eg ]YZ p b^jqa]Z`_egh k ^b]bsb_u ûegsZ ie_jq{ ea fZaehgZf \b^ aY`^Zfq cZcb^n c`sYegZat p Z sYbaZ ]b ec k _ZcZg] p b^jqa]Z`_egh ]Y^bdhY aY`^ZfqcZcb^nt ^`]YZ^ ]Y`g p e]Y cZaa`hZq k `aaeght `a cehY] b]YZ^ p eaZ mZ ` kk ^b k ^e`]Z \b^ ` fea]^emd]ZfqcZcb^n ec k _ZcZg]`]ebgu g bd^ ec k _ZcZg]`]ebgt mb]Y les]ec `gf ]YeZ\ b k Z^`]Z fe^Zs]_n ]Y^bdhY aY`^Zf cZcb^n bg ]YZ les]ec€a ^Z`fn fZdZu XYZ s^dse`_ eaadZ ea Ybp ]b ^Zab_lZ ]YZ ^`sZ sbgq fe]ebg ]Y`] `^eaZa p YZg ` ]YeZ\ ]^eZa ]b a]Z`_ ]YZ a`cZ \^`cZ ]Y`] e]a les]ec ea `]]Zc k ]egh ]b k b k u gZ aec k _Z ab_d]ebg ea ]b `ff ` _bsj ]b ]YZ fZdZ daegh ^Z_`]elZ_n YZ`ln p ZehY] Y`^f p `^Z k ^ece]elZa _ejZ ibc k `^Zqzgfqû p ` k b^ XZa]qzgfq ûZ]u þYZgZlZ^ ` ]YeZ\ b^ p b^jZ^ p eaYZa ]b ^ZcblZ ` \^`cZ \^bc ]YZ fZdZt e] [^a] h^`ma ]YZ _bsju XYea ab_d]ebg Y`a ]YZ a`cZ \dgf`cZg]`_ k ^bm_Zc `a ]YZ eg]Z^^d k ] `gf k b__egh cZsY`geaca ƒda] fZas^emZft Ybp ZlZ^u þYZgZlZ^ ` p b^jZ^ k b k a ` \^`cZt e] k `na ]YZ YZ`ln k ^esZ ]b h^`m ` _bsjt p YesY sbg]^emd]Za ]b p b^j blZ^YZ`fu ibgaZdZg]_nt p Z `fb k ]Zf ` ab_d]ebg ]Y`] Zc k _bna ‚eq ƒja]^`€a k ^b]bsb_ \b^ cd]d`_ Zys_daebg ”t p YesY `aadcZa bg_n ]Y`] ^Z`fa `gf p ^e]Za `^Z `]bcesu Zs`daZ bd^ k ^b]bq sb_ daZa ]Y^ZZ `]bces aY`^Zf l`^e`m_Za t  t `gf  t p Z s`__ e] ]YZ * + k ^b]bsb_u XYZ jZn efZ` ea ]Y`] `s]ebga mn ]YZ p b^jZ^ bg ]YZ ]`e_ b\ ]YZ dZdZ sbg]^emd]Z ]b p b^j blZ^YZ`ft p Ye_Z `s]ebga mn ]YeZlZa bg ]YZ YZ`f b\ ]YZ dZdZ sbg]^emd]Z bg_n ]b s^e]es`_q k `]Y blZ^YZ`fu XYZ^Z\b^Zt eg `ssb^f`gsZ p e]Y ]YZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Zt p Z `]]Zc k ] ]b cblZ sba]a \^bc ]YZ p b^jZ^ ]b ]YZ ]YeZ\u Xb `^me]^`]Z `cbgh fe0 Z^Zg] ]YeZlZa `]]Zc k ]egh ]b a]Z`_ \^bc ]YZ a`cZ les]ect p Z daZ ` Y`^fq p `^Z _bsjt aegsZ ]Yea blZ^YZ`f s`g mZ `cb^]exZf `h`ega] ]YZ s^e]es`_ k `]Yu Xb ^Zab_lZ sbg es]a mZ]p ZZg ` p b^jZ^ `gf ]YZ ab_Z ]YeZ\ Yb_fegh ]YZ _bsjt Ybp ZlZ^t p Z daZ ` _ehY]p ZehY] ‚eƒ ja]^`q_ejZ k ^b]bsb_ p YesY sbg]^emd]Za cegec`__n ]b p b^j blZ^YZ`fu z p b^jZ^ ^Zab^]a ]b ` YZ`ln p ZehY] Y`^f p `^Z _bsj bg_n p YZg e] Zgsbdg]Z^a `g `s]d`_ sbg es] p e]Y ` ]YeZ\t eg p YesY s`aZ p Z s`g sY`^hZ ]YZ blZ^YZ`f ]Y`] ]YZ les]ec egsd^a ]b ]YZ s^e]es`_ k `]Yu g ]YZ ^Za] b\ ]Yea aZs]ebgt p Z fZas^emZ ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_

õ     

÷ö õõõ õõ õõ õõ õ÷

    

     _HLP UV W dd Z e

õ

_R_ UV W bb Z DT U Q V W dd Z GRFS U V Z bb Z DT U Q V W dd Z HEGRFS U V Z YJMHYE  m  Z e HEGRFS U V Z e YJMHYE      Z e

    

÷ö õõõ

 LMJ`G UV W GRFS U V Z  dd Z DT U Q V W  bb Z HEGRFS U V Z YJMHYE  m  Z e HEGRFS U V Z YJMHYE      Z e

y { ÈôòÅ  ÅòÈ Å Æ { Ê | ÇðÊ Èò … ÈÉ { ÊÅË Å ï € È Ä  ÇÉÅïÅ  Åðø ąrstuvw € È ðÈ ï ÇÆÉï Å ï € È ~ ôÉÈ {€ Å { ï € È Æ  ïÊÅË { ÇÈÉ ÅÉ | Èò ƒ† ï € È ï{€ƒÈÈ {ÉÊÊòÈ~€{ï ÉÈÆò ÇÆÉï{ {€ÆËòÅ { ÉÊïÈ ï € È{ ÆÆÉÈïÊÅËÆ {{{ ôÅ| Èòï € ÈïÅï €ƒÊÈÈ ÆïÅ ø |ÅËÈÊ ø łÊÅÉïïʀÈ|È ÆÆí |ÆËò ïÊÅË ÇðÈíø bb Z  ÆË ƒ È Ê| ÇðÈ | ÈËïÈò Æ { Mf_ ^ Z Mf_ ^ Mf_ b 





cZ



^ Mf_ Z





  











eg fZ]`e_u þZ [^a] k ^ZaZg] ` aec k _e[Zf k ^b]bsb_ ]Y`] daZa bg_n ]p b aY`^Zf l`^e`m_Za `gf  fZaehg`]egh ]YZ ]`e_ `gf ]YZ YZ`f b\ ]YZ fZdZt ^Za k Zs]elZ_nu `]Z^t p Z Zy]Zgf ]YZ k ^b]bsb_ p e]Y ` ]Ye^f l`^e`m_Z  ]Y`] `__bp a ZysZ k ]ebga ]b mZ aehg`_Zf ]b ` p b^jZ^u XYZ ZysZ k ]ebg cZsY`geac ea daZf ]b ec k _ZcZg] ie_j€a :@AB? a]`]ZcZg]u g]Z^Za]egh_nt ]Yea Zy]Zgq aebg fbZa gb] eg]^bfdsZ `gn `ffe]ebg`_ p b^j blZ^YZ`fu XYZ k aZdfbsbfZ b\ ]YZ aec k _e[Zf X , - k ^b]bsb_ ea aYbp g eg . ehd^Z ’u zaadcZ ]Y`] aY`^Zf cZcb^n ea aZdZg]e`__n sbgaea]Zg] | ”u XYZ sbfZ `aadcZa ]Y`] ]YZ ^Z`fn fZdZ ea ec k _ZcZg]Zf `a `g `^^`n b\ \^`cZau XYZ YZ`f `gf ]`e_ b\ ]YZ fZdZ `^Z fZ]Z^cegZf mn ]p b egfesZa `gf  t p YesY `^Z a]b^Zf eg aY`^Zf cZcb^n `gf `^Z leaem_Z ]b `__ k ^bsZaab^au XYZ egfZy k beg]a ]b ]YZ [^a] dgdaZf Z_ZcZg] eg ]YZ `^^`nt `gf  k beg]a ]b ]YZ [^a] \^`cZ bg ]YZ fZdZu gfesZa h^bp \^bc ]YZ YZ`f ]bp `^fa ]YZ ]`e_ ab ]Y`] dgfZ^ gb^c`_ sbgq fe]ebgat p Z Y`lZ   u ~b^ZblZ^t Z`sY fZdZ Y`a ` _bsj  ec k _ZcZg]Zf p e]Y `]bces Y`^f p `^Z k ^ece]elZa b^ p e]Y û s`__au XYZ p b^jZ^ daZa ]YZ fZdZ `a ` a]`sju úûZZ ûZs]ebg ’uý Z\b^Z ` 89:;< t e] k daYZa ` \^`cZ bg]b ]YZ ]`e_ b\ ]YZ fZdZu z\]Z^ ` 89:;< t e] k b k a ]YZ \^`cZt dg_Zaa ]YZ \^`cZ Y`a mZZg a]b_Zgu z ]YeZ\ `]]Zc k ]a ]b a]Z`_ ]YZ \^`cZ `] ]YZ YZ`f b\ ]YZ fZdZu g_n bgZ ]YeZ\ `] ]YZ ]ecZ c`n a]Z`_ \^bc ]YZ fZdZt aegsZ ` ]YeZ\ h^`ma  `a e]a [^a] `s]ebgu za s`g mZ aZZg \^bc ]YZ sbfZt ]YZ p b^jZ^ `_]Z^a md] gb]  t p YZ^Z`a ]YZ ]YeZ\ bg_n egs^ZcZg]a  `gf fbZa gb] `_]Z^ u XYZ bg_n k baaem_Z eg]Z^`s]ebg mZ]p ZZg ` ]YeZ\ `gf e]a lesq  ¾§ ¡–š ˜–›™š¢ »š» ™¥ —˜ £ ¡ ˜šÂžš£¡—›¼¼¥ œ £˜—˜¡š£¡À › »š» ™¥ §š£œš »ž˜¡ ¤š —£˜š™¡š¢ ¤š¡šš£ ¼—£š˜ ¸ ›£¢   § ¡–š  ™Áš™ ©—œ¡—» œ ¢š ›£¢ ¤š¡šš£ ¼—£š˜  ›£¢ ´  § ¡–š ¡–—š§ œ ¢š ¡  š£˜ž™š ¡–›¡ ¡–š˜š —£˜¡™žœ¡— £˜ ›™š š“ šœž¡š¢ —£ ¡–š Ÿ™ Ÿš™  ™¢š™¹ 





(



]YZ fZdZt mb]Y  `gf s`g mZ s`sYZf Zys_daelZ_n mn ]YZ p b^jZ^u XYZ Zy k ZgaelZ b k Z^`]ebg b\ ` p b^jZ^ h^`mmegh ]YZ _bsj  bssd^a bg_n p YZg ` ]YeZ\ ea aecd_]`gZbda_n ]^negh ]b a]Z`_ ]YZ \^`cZ mZegh k b kk Zfu ûegsZ ]YZ gdcmZ^ b\ a]Z`_ `]]Zc k ]a fZ k Zgfa bg   t gb] bg  ‰ t ]YZ ^Z_`]elZ_n YZ`ln sba] b\ ` les]ec h^`mmegh  s`g mZ sbgaefZ^Zf `a k `^] b\ ]YZ s^e]es`_q k `]Y blZ^YZ`f  `gf fbZa gb] eg dZgsZ ]YZ p b^j blZ^YZ`f ‰ u þZ ^`g abcZ Zy k Z^ecZg]a ]b fZ]Z^cegZ ]YZ ^Z_`]elZ k Z^q \b^c`gsZ b\ ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_ lZ^ada ]YZ a]^`ehY]\b^ p `^f k ^b]bsb_ eg p YesY 9A9 ƒda] _bsja ]YZ fZdZ mZ\b^Z `ssZaaegh e]u g ` } /qcZh`YZ^]x  _]^`ûüz i t ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_ ea `mbd] |{ \`a]Z^ ]Y`g ]YZ aec k _Z _bsjegh k ^b]bsb_u XYea c`sYegZ€a cZcb^n cbfZ_ ^Zde^Za ]Y`] ` cZcb^n \ZgsZ egq a]^ds]ebg ú > @:B ý mZ egaZ^]Zf mZ]p ZZg _egZa { `gf } b\ ]YZ 9A9 k aZdfbsbfZu þZ ]^eZf ]b d`g]e\n ]YZ k Z^\b^c`gsZ ecq k `s] b\ ]YZ > @:B ega]^ds]ebgt md] eg `__ bd^ Zy k Z^ecZg]a ]YZ ZyZsd]ebg ]ecZa b\ ]YZ sbfZ p e]Y `gf p e]Ybd] > @:B `^Z `mbd] ]YZ a`cZu g ` | qcZh`YZ^]x üZg]edc ü^b ^dgq gegh egdy `gf % |u/ ut ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_ ea bg_n `mbd] { \`a]Z^ ]Y`g ]YZ _bsjegh k ^b]bsb_u g ]Yea k ^bsZaab^t ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_ a k Zgfa `mbd] Y`_\ b\ e]a ]ecZ eg ]YZ cZcb^n \ZgsZu Zs`daZ e] ^Z k _`sZa _bsja p e]Y cZcb^n angsY^bgex`]ebgt ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_ ea cb^Z ogbgm_bsjeghr ]Y`g ` a]^`ehY]\b^q p `^f _bsjegh k ^b]bsb_u ibgaZdZg]_nt ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_ ea _Zaa k ^bgZ ]b k ^bm_Zca ]Y`] `^eaZ p YZg a k eg _bsja `^Z daZf Zy]ZgaelZ_nu .b^ Zy`c k _Zt ZlZg e\ ` p b^jZ^ ea ada k ZgfZf mn ]YZ b k Z^`]egh ana]Zc fd^egh ]YZ ZyZsd]ebg b\ 9A9 t ]YZ eg\^ZdZgsn b\ _bsjegh eg ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_ cZ`ga ]Y`] ` ]YeZ\ s`g dad`__n sbc k _Z]Z ` a]Z`_ b k Z^`]ebg bg ]YZ p b^jZ^€a fZdZu ZsZg] p b^j mn z^b^` Z] `_u |” Y`a aYbp g ]Y`] ` sbc k _Z]Z_n gbgm_bsjegh p b^jqa]Z`_egh asYZfd_Z^ s`g mZ ecq k _ZcZg]Zfu  aegh ]YZaZ efZ`at eaeZsje `gf ~Zfeg` |” Y`lZ cbfe[Zf ]YZ ie_jq{ asYZfd_Z^ ]b c`jZ e] sbc k _Z]Z_n gbgq m_bsjeghu XYZe^ Zy k Z^eZgsZ ea ]Y`] ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_ h^Z`]_n aec k _e[Za ` gbgm_bsjegh ec k _ZcZg]`]ebgu XYZ aec k _e[Zf X , - k ^b]bsb_ s`g mZ Zy]ZgfZf ]b ad kk b^] ]YZ aehg`_egh b\ ZysZ k ]ebga ]b ` p b^jZ^u g . ehd^Z ’t ]YZ egfZy  k _`na ]p b ^b_Zaw e] c`^ja ]YZ YZ`f b\ ]YZ fZdZt `gf e] c`^ja ]YZ k beg] ]Y`] ]YZ p b^jZ^ s`ggb] s^baa p YZg e] k b k au XYZaZ k _`sZa eg ]YZ fZdZ gZZf gb] mZ ]YZ a`cZu g ]YZ \d__ X , - k ^b]bsb_t p Z aZ k `^`]Z ]YZ ]p b \dgs]ebga b\  eg]b ]p b l`^e`m_Zaw  t p YesY gbp bg_n c`^ja ]YZ YZ`f b\ ]YZ fZdZt `gf  t p YesY c`^ja ]YZ k beg] ]Y`] ]YZ les]ec s`ggb] s^baau þYZgZlZ^  t abcZ ZysZ k ]ebg`_ sbgfe]ebg Y`a bssd^^Zft p YesY egs_dfZa ]YZ \^`cZ mZegh a]b_Zgt md] e] s`g `_ab mZ daZf \b^ b]YZ^ ZysZ k ]ebgau .b^ Zy`c k _Zt aZ]]egh   s`daZa ]YZ p b^jZ^ ]b feasblZ^ ]YZ ZysZ k ]ebg `] e]a gZy] k b k u g ]YZ gZ p k ^b]bsb_t  ^Z k _`sZa  eg _egZ } b\ ]YZ p b^jZ^ùles]ecu ~b^ZblZ^t _egZa / { b\ ]YZ p b^jZ^ùles]ec `^Z ^Z k _`sZf mn ` s`__ ]b `g     ‹  ]b fZ]Z^cegZ ]YZ ]n k Z b\ ZysZ k ]ebg úa]b_Zg \^`cZ b^ b]YZ^ p eaZý `gf ]YZ k ^b k Z^ `s]ebg ]b k Z^\b^cu XYZ ]YeZ\ sbfZ ea `_ab cbfe[Zfu Z\b^Z ]^negh ]b

Thief 1 2 3 4 5

















































 

 

 







 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

H



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 







 

 

 

















































H=T

H





T

 

6

Victim

T

 

 

(a)

(b)

(c)



rstuvw y Ä € È ï € ÉÈÈ  Æ { È { Å ï € È ÉÈÆò † òÈ ôÈ ÊË ï € È { Ê | ÇðÊ Èò Ä  ÇÉÅïÅ  Åðø z {€ ÆòÈò ÈËïÉ † ÊËòÊ  ÆïÈ { ï € È ÇÉÈ { ÈË  È Å Æ ÉÆ | È Æï Æ  ÈÉïÆÊË ÇÅ { ÊïÊÅË ÊË ï € È òÈ ôÈø Ä € È € ÈÆò ÆËò ï € È ïÆÊð ÆÉÈ | ÆÉ } Èò ƒ† ÆËò  ø ]ec bssd^a p YZg ]YZ ]YeZ\ ea egs^ZcZg]egh  p Ye_Z ]YZ lesq ]ec ea fZs^ZcZg]egh u ibgaZdZg]_nt e] ea `_p `na a`\Z \b^ ` p b^jZ^ ]b ` kk Zgf ` gZ p \^`cZ `] ]YZ Zgf b\ ]YZ fZdZ ú9Œ 8 ý p e]Ybd] p b^^negh `mbd] ]YZ `s]ebga b\ ]YZ ]YeZ\u .b^ ` 9A9 b k Z^`]ebgat ]YZ^Z `^Z ]Y^ZZ s`aZat p YesY `^Z aYbp g eg . ehd^Z {u g s`aZ ú`ýt ]YZ ]YeZ\ `gf ]YZ les]ec s`g mb]Y hZ] ` \^`cZ \^bc ]YZ fZdZu g s`aZ úmýt ]YZ fZdZ sbg]`ega bg_n bgZ \^`cZu \ ]YZ les]ec fZs^ZcZg]a p e]Ybd] eg]Z^\Z^ZgsZ \^bc ]YeZlZat e] hZ]a ]YZ \^`cZu ûece_`^_nt ` ]YeZ\ s`g a]Z`_ ]YZ \^`cZ `a _bgh `a e]a les]ec ea gb] ]^negh ]b bm]`eg e]u \ mb]Y ]YZ ]YeZ\ `gf ]YZ les]ec ]^n ]b h^`m ]YZ \^`cZt Ybp ZlZ^t ]YZ k ^b]bsb_ hd`^`g]ZZa ]Y`] `] _Z`a] bgZ b\ ]YZc feasblZ^a ]Y`]  u \ ]YZ ]YeZ\ feasblZ^a ]Y`]  t e] ^Za]b^Za  ]b e]a b^eheg`_ l`_dZ `gf ^Z]^Z`]au \ ]YZ les]ec feasblZ^a ]Y`]  t e] ^Za]b^Za ]b e]a b^eheg`_ l`_dZ `gf ^Za]`^]a ]YZ k ^b]bsb_ `\]Z^ Y`legh `sde^Zf  u þe]Y  `sde^Zft gb ]YeZ\ s`g a]Z`_ \^bc ]Yea fZdZ ab ]YZ les]ec s`g k b k ]YZ \^`cZ p e]Ybd] eg]Z^\Z^ZgsZ úe\ ]YZ \^`cZ ea a]e__ ]YZ^Zýu . eg`__nt eg s`aZ úsý ]YZ fZdZ ea Zc k ]nu \ ` ]YeZ\ ]^eZa ]b a]Z`_t e] p e__ `_p `na \`e_u \ ]YZ les]ec ]^eZa ]b k b k t ]YZ `]]Zc k ] \`e_a `gf sbg]^b_ ^Z]d^ga ]b ]YZ ie_j ^dg]ecZ ana]Zcu XYZ k ^b]bsb_ s`ggb] fZ`f_bsjt mZs`daZ Z`sY k ^bsZaa Yb_fa bg_n bgZ _bsj `] ` ]ecZu þZ gbp `^hdZ ]Y`] ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_ sbg]^emd]Za _e]]_Z ]b ]YZ p b^j blZ^YZ`fu üdaYegh ` \^`cZ eglb_lZa gb blZ^YZ`f mZnbgf d k f`]egh u g ]YZ sbccbg s`aZ p YZ^Z ` p b^jZ^ s`g adssZa\d__n k b k ` \^`cZt ]YZ k b k k ^b]bsb_ k Z^\b^ca bg_n } b k Z^`]ebga& | cZcb^n _b`fat  cZcb^n a]b^Zt  fZs^Zq cZg]t  sbc k `^eabgt `gf  úk ^Zfes]`m_Zý sbgfe]ebg`_ m^`gsYu ~b^ZblZ^t eg ]YZ sbccbg s`aZ p YZ^Z gb ]YeZ\ b k Z^`]Za bg 

































‘



‘



‘      ¸ ³  ¹ ²¹²²²¸  ¸¸´²  ¹ ³¹ ² ·¹²  ¹ ³²³² ´´  ¶¹¶ ²¹²²´´  ² ³¹²¸ ´¹   ¹²  ¹  ¶¹ ²¹²³¸ ³¶ ²¸ ³¹²¸  ¹¶  ¹  ¹ ³² ´  ²¹ ²¹¸· ³¹²³  ¹¸´ ¸¹  ¸¹¸¹² ´  ³²² ²²² ³¸²¹¸¹´ ²¹²²´¶ ³³²· ³¹ ³ ²¹¶²  ¹² ²¹²²³¸ ¶¸´³´  ·¶· ²¹¶¶ ³·¹· ·¹² ·¹² ²  ¸¹· ²¹²²³´  ³¹²  ¶¹¸ ·¹²  ¹  ²´· ³¸¸¹· ²¹´   ² ³¹²   ²¹  ¹¹¶ ¸¹¸¹¸ ºÃÕ !   ³´  ¹  ¹´ ´  ² ³¹ ¸  ²·¹ ´²¶  "# ¸³  ´¹ ¹ ²¹³   ·´ ³¹²· ²¹¶¹´ ¸¹¹  ¹³¹² ²¹²² ²  ³´¸ ²¹¶  ‘ ³ ´¹ ²¹³¸ ·¸  ³¹²  ³ ¹¸  ¹¸  ¹´ rstuvw ' y Ä € È ÇÈÉ ÅÉ | ÆË  È Å È  Æ | ÇðÈ ñÊð } ÇÉÅ ~ ÉÆ | { ø ÄÊ | È { ÆÉÈ ÊË { È  ÅËò { ÆËò ÆÉÈ Æ  ôÉÆïÈ ïÅ Êï € ÊË Æ ƒ Åôï õ ( ø Ä € È { ÈÉÊÆð ÇÉÅ ~ ÉÆ | { ÆÉÈ ñÊð} ÇÉÅ ÇÉÅ~~ÉÆÉÆ||ø{ í ÈÉÅ ~ÈÇï ÅÉ ï € Å {È ÇÉÅ ~ ÉÆ | { ï € Æï ÆÉÈ {ïÆÉÉÈò „) ‡ í € ÈÉÈ ï € È ÇÆÉÆððÈð ÇÉÅ ~ ÉÆ | Ê| ÇðÈ | ÈËï { Æ òÊ* ÈÉÈËï ÆðÊ{ ~ËÅï ÅÉÊïñ Èðʀ|ï €{ÈÊÅËï{€ÆÆË{|ÅÈï €ÆïȀ{ È{ïÈÉÊÆð ÉÆ | { ðÆ ƒ ÈðÈò ƒ† Æ òÆ ~~ ÈÉ „+ ‡ ÆÉÈ ËÅËòÈïÈÉ | ÊËÊ { ïÊ  í ÆËò ï € ô { í ï € È ÉôËËÊË ~ ïÊ | È ÅË ÅËÈ ÇÉÅ  È {{ ÅÉ € È ÅÉ } ÇÈÉ ÅÉ | Èò ƒ† ï € È  Å | ÇôïÆïÊÅËø ‚ÅÉ ï € È { È ÇÉÅ ~ ÉÆ | { í ï € È … ÆðôÈ ÅÉ , ‰ ÊËòÊ  ÆïÈ { ï € È Æ  ïôÆð ÅÉ } Å ï € È  Å | ÇôïÆïÊÅË ÅË ÷ ÇÉÅ  È {{ ÅÉ { í ÆËò ËÅï ï € È ÉôËËÊË ~ ïÊ | È ÅË ÅËÈ ÇÉÅ  È {{ ÅÉø     )*  #  &  ) + *$ #&'&  ) "$  ""#+   )  "*  $  ##+ "  +  ' "  )  *)#"   #$  $ $ + #" %& $





 



























m_Z `_ab _ea]a ]YZ ^dggegh ]ecZ   bg “ k ^bsZaab^at `gf ]YZ a k ZZfd k  ‰   ^Z_`]elZ ]b ]YZ bgZq k ^bsZaab^ ZyZsd]ebg ]ecZt `gf a k ZZfd k     ^Z_`]elZ ]b ]YZ aZ^e`_ ZyZsd]ebg ]ecZu .b^ ]YZ | k ^bh^`cat ]YZ `lZ^`hZ k `^`__Z_eac  ea eg cba] s`aZa de]Z _`^hZ ^Z_`]elZ ]b ]YZ gdcmZ^ b\ k ^bsZaab^a bg ` ]n k es`_ û~üu XYZaZ cZ`ad^ZcZg]a l`_ef`]Z bd^ `aadc k ]ebg b\ k `^`__Z_ a_`sjgZaat p YesY ec k _eZa ]Y`] ]YZ p b^j ]Z^c fbcq eg`]Za eg gZd`_e]n ú’ýu .b^ ega]`gsZt bg  |’ 0  |’ c`]^eq sZat 9 Œ" ^dga p e]Y `g `lZ^`hZ k `^`__Z_eac b\  / & neZ_fegh `fZd`]Z k `^`__Z_ a_`sjgZaa \b^ d k ]b aZlZ^`_ Ydgq f^Zf k ^bsZaab^au .b^ ZlZg _`^hZ^ c`sYegZat bgZ gb^c`__n p bd_f gb] ^dg adsY ` ac`__ k ^bm_Zcu .b^ 9 Œ" t `a p Z__ `a ]YZ b]YZ^  ` kk _es`]ebgat ]YZ `lZ^`hZ k `^`__Z_eac h^bp a p e]Y k ^bm_Zc aexZt `gf ]Yda advseZg] k `^`__Z_ a_`sjgZaa ea _ejZ_n ]b Zyea] ZlZg \b^ cdsY _`^hZ^ c`sYegZat `a _bgh `a ]YZ k ^bm_Zc aexZa `^Z as`_Zf ` kk ^b k ^e`]Z_nu XYZ p b^j blZ^YZ`f ‰ ea bg_n ` \Z p k Z^sZg] _`^hZ^ ]Y`g  \b^ cba] k ^bh^`cat p YesY aYbp a ]Y`] bd^ fZaehg b\ ie_jq{ \`e]Y\d__n ec k _ZcZg]a ]YZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Zu XYZ ]p b s`aZa p YZ^Z ]YZ p b^j blZ^YZ`f ea _`^hZ^ ú !"# 8AB? `gf A">8#= ý `^Z fdZ ]b ]YZ \`s] ]Y`] p Z Y`f ]b sY`ghZ ]YZ aZ^e`_ `_hbq ^e]Yc ]b bm]`eg ` k `^`__Z_ `_hb^e]Yct `gf ]Yda ]YZ sbc k `^q eabg ea gb] `h`ega] ]YZ i Z_eaebgu .b^ Zy`c k _Zt ]YZ aZ^e`_ i `_hb^e]Yc \b^ ab^]egh ea `g egq k _`sZ desjab^]t md] ]YZ k `^q `__Z_ `_hb^e]Yc !"# 8AB? ^Zde^Za `g `ffe]ebg`_ ]Zc k b^`^n `^^`n p YesY `ffa blZ^YZ`f mZnbgf ]YZ blZ^YZ`f b\ ie_j e]q aZ_\u ûece_`^_nt bd^ k `^`__Z_ iYb_Zajn \`s]b^ex`]ebg daZa ` d`f]^ZZ ^Z k ^ZaZg]`]ebg b\ ]YZ a k `^aZ c`]^eyt p YesY egfdsZa cb^Z p b^j ]Y`g ]YZ _egjZfq_ea] ^Z k ^ZaZg]`]ebg daZf eg ]YZ aZ^e`_ i `_hb^e]Ycu . eg`__nt ]YZ p b^j blZ^YZ`f \b^ Š!@ ea _`^hZt mZs`daZ Š!@ fbZa ZaaZg]e`__n gb p b^j mZaefZa a k `p gq egh k ^bsZfd^Zau XYdat ]YZ blZ^YZ`f ‰  ‘ }‘ \b^ Š!@ helZa ` hbbf Za]ec`]Z b\ ]YZ sba] b\ ` ie_j 89:;< lZ^ada ` ]^`fe]ebg`_ i \dgs]ebg s`__u þe]Y adsY ` ac`__ blZ^YZ`f \b^ a k `p geght bgZ s`g dgfZ^a]`gf p Yn \b^ cba] b\ ]YZ b]YZ^ ` kk _es`]ebgat p YesY k Z^\b^c aehge[s`g] p b^j \b^ Z`sY a k `p gt ]YZ blZ^YZ`f b\ ie_jq{€a asYZfd_egh ea m`^Z_n gb]esZ`m_Z sbc k `^Zf ]b ]YZ  ogbeaZr eg bd^ cZ`ad^ZcZg]au

a]Z`_t ]YZ ]YeZ\ egs^ZcZg]a  u \ ]YZ^Z ea gb]Yegh ]b a]Z`_t ]YZ ]YeZ\ ^Za]b^Za  ]b ]YZ b^eheg`_ l`_dZu ]YZ^ p eaZt ]YZ ]YeZ\ a]Z`_a \^`cZ  `gf egs^ZcZg]a  u .^bc ]YZ k beg] b\ leZp b\ ` p b^jZ^t ]YZ sbccbg s`aZ ea ]YZ a`cZ `a eg ]YZ aec k _e[Zf k ^b]bsb_w e] sbc k `^Za ]p b k beg]Z^a ú `gf ^`]YZ^ ]Y`g  `gf ýu XYZ ZysZ k ]ebg cZsY`geac ea daZf ]b ec k _ZcZg] :@AB? u þYZg ` ie_j k ^bsZfd^Z ZyZsd]Za `g :@AB? ega]^ds]ebgt ]YZ ^dg]ecZ ana]Zc aZ^e`__n p `_ja ]YZ ]^ZZ b\ bd]a]`gfegh fZasZgq f`g]a b\ ]Y`] k ^bsZfd^Zu ] c`^ja ]YZ fZasZgf`g]a `a `mb^]Zf `gf aehg`_a `g `mb^] ZysZ k ]ebg bg `gn k ^bsZaab^ p b^jegh bg ` fZasZgf`g]u z] e]a gZy] 9A9 t `g `mb^]Zf k ^bsZfd^Z p e__ feasblZ^ ]YZ ZysZ k ]ebgt gb]esZ ]Y`] e] Y`a mZZg `mb^]Zft `gf ^Z]d^g eccZfe`]Z_nu ] ea sbgsZel`m_Z ]Y`] ` k ^bsZfd^Z sbd_f ^dg \b^ ` _bgh ]ecZ p e]Ybd] ZyZsd]egh ` 9A9 `gf feasblZ^egh ]Y`] e] Y`a mZZg `mb^]Zfu þZ c`fZ ]YZ fZaehg fZseaebg ]b `ssZ k ] ]YZ k baaeme_e]n b\ ]Yea dg_ejZ_n asZg`^ebt [hd^egh ]Y`] cb^Z sns_Za p Z^Z _ejZ_n ]b mZ _ba] eg p b^j blZ^YZ`f e\ p Z `m`gfbgZf ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_ \b^ ` cZsY`geac ]Y`] ab_lZa ]Yea cegb^ k ^bm_Zcu - …ŒW 3  VU 6 S g ]Yea aZs]ebgt p Z Zl`_d`]Z ]YZ k Z^\b^c`gsZ b\ ie_jq{u þZ aYbp ]Y`] bg | ` kk _es`]ebgat ]YZ p b^j blZ^YZ`f ea s_baZ ]b t p YesY egfes`]Za ]Y`] ]YZ ie_jq{ ec k _ZcZg]`]ebg‰ Zy k _be]a ]YZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Z Z 0 Zs]elZ_nu þZ ]YZg k ^ZaZg] ` m^Z`jq fbp g b\ ie_j€a p b^j blZ^YZ`f ‰ bg \bd^ c`sYegZau . eg`__nt p Z k ^ZaZg] Zy k Z^ecZg]a aYbp egh ]Y`] ]YZ s^e]es`_q k `]Y blZ^q YZ`f  ea ^Z`abg`m_n ac`__ `a p Z__u . ehd^Z } aYb p a ` ]`m_Z b\ k Z^\b^c`gsZ cZ`ad^ZcZg]a ]`jZg \b^ | ie_j k ^bh^`ca bg ` ûdg - g]Z^ k ^eaZ { û~ü p e]Y “ } /qcZh`YZ^]x  _]^`ûüz i k ^bsZaab^at Z`sY p e]Y {| je_bq mn]Za b\ | s`sYZt } je_bmn]Za Z`sY b\  f`]` `gf ega]^dsq ]ebg s`sYZat ^dggegh ûb_`^ea |u{u þZ sbc k e_Zf bd^ k ^bh^`ca p e]Y % |u/ u| `] b k ]ecex`]ebg _ZlZ_ ./ u .b^ ` \d__ fZas^ek q ]ebg b\ ]YZaZ k ^bh^`cat aZZ ]YZ ie_j {u c`gd`_ “”u XYZ ]`m_Z aYbp a ]YZ p b^j b\ Z`sY ie_j k ^bh^`c  ‰ t ]YZ s^e]es`_ k `]Y   t `gf ]YZ ]p b fZ^elZf d`g]e]eZa  `gf ‰ u XYZ ]`q





 



 





 







1

27ns

200 MHz Pentium Pro

78ns

167 MHz Ultra SPARC I

113ns

1 Normalized Speedup

466 MHz Alpha 21164

THE protocol frame allocation state saving C

195 MHz MIPS R10000 115ns 0

1

2

3 4 overheads

5

6

0.1 Experimental data Model T_1/P + T_inf Work bound Critical path bound

7

0.01 0.01

rstuvw y  ÉÈÆ } òÅ  Ë Å  Ņ ÈÉ € ÈÆò {  ÅÉ T DN ÉôËËÊË ~ ÅË ÅËÈ ÇÉÅ   È {{ ÅÉ ÅË … ÆÉÊÅô { ÆÉ € ÊïÈ  ïôÉÈ { ø Ä € È Å … ÈÉ € ÈÆò { ÆÉÈ ËÅÉ | ÆðÊ  Èò ïÅ ïÅɀ È {ÉôËËÊË ~ ïÊ | È Å  ï € È { ÈÉÊÆð ñ ÈðÊ { ÊÅËø Ä € È ï € ÉÈÈ Å … ÈÉ € ÈÆò { ÆÉÈ Æ … ÊË ~ ï € È { ïÆïÈ Å  Æ ÇÉÅ  ÈòôÉÈ ƒ È  ÅÉÈ Æ { ÇÆ Ëí ï € È ÆððÅ  ÆïÊÅË Å{ ÅðôïÈ  Æ  ïÊ … ÆïÊÅË  ÉÆ | È {  ÅÉ ÇÉÅ  ÈòôÉÈ { í ÆËò ï € È Ä  ÇÉÅïÅ  Åðø zƒ  ÈðÊ{ ÊÅËøïÊ| È { ÆÉÈ ~ ʅ ÈË ÅÉ ï € È ÇÈÉ{ ÇÆ Ë ÉôËËÊË ~ ïÊ| È Å  ï € È ñ

0.1 1 Normalized Machine Size

10

y  ÅÉ | ÆðÊ Èò { ÇÈÈòôÇ  ôÉ … È ÅÉ ñÊð } ø Ä € È € ÅÉÊ ÅËïÆð Æ{rstuvw  Ê { Ê { ï € È Ëô |ƒ ÈÉ Å ÇÉÅ  È {{ ÅÉ{ ÆËò ï € È … ÈÉïÊ Æð Æ Ê{ Ê{ ï € È ÇÈÈòôÇ , ‰ ,  í ƒ ôï ÈÆ € òÆïÆ ÇÅÊËï € Æ { ƒ ÈÈË ËÅÉ | ÆðÊ Èò ƒ† òÊ … ÊòÊË ~ ƒ† , ‰ ,  ø Ä € È ~ ÉÆÇ € Æð { Å {€ Å { ï € È { ÇÈÈòôÇ ÇÉÈòÊ  ïÈò ƒ† ï € È ÅÉ | ôðÆ ,  , ‰ , ø a k ZZfd k    \b^ Z`sY ^dg `h`ega] ]YZ c`sYegZ aexZ  \b^ ]Y`] ^dgu g‰ b^fZ^ ]b k _b] fe0 Z^Zg] sbc k d]`]ebga bg ]YZ a`cZ h^` k Yt p Z gb^c`_exZf ]YZ c`sYegZ aexZ `gf ]YZ a k ZZfd k mn felefegh ]YZaZ l`_dZa mn ]YZ `lZ^`hZ k `^`__Z_eac    ‰   t `a p `a fbgZ eg ’”u .b^ Z`sY ^dgt ]YZ Yb^exbg]`_ k bae]ebg b\ ]YZ k _b]]Zf f`]dc ea ]YZ eglZ^aZ b\ ]YZ a_`sjgZaa    t `gf ]Ydat ]YZ gb^c`_exZf c`sYegZ aexZ ea   p YZg ]YZ gdcmZ^ b\ k ^bsZaab^a ea Zd`_ ]b ]YZ `lZ^`hZ k `^`__Z_eacu XYZ lZ^]es`_ k bae]ebg b\ ]YZ k _b]]Zf f`]dc ea ú   ý        t p YesY cZ`ad^Za ]YZ \^`s]ebg b\ c`yecdc‰  bm]`eg`m_Z a k ZZfd k u za s`g mZ aZZg eg ]YZ sY`^]t \b^ `_cba] `__ ^dga b\ ]Yea mZgsYq c`^jt p Z bmaZ^lZf     ‰       u ú gZ ZysZ k ]ebg`_ f`]` k beg] a`]ea[Za     ‰     {  uý XYdat `_]YbdhY ]YZ p b^jq[^a] k ^egsek _Z s`daZf da ]b cblZ blZ^YZ`fa ]b ]YZ s^e]es`_ k `]Yt ]YZ `me_e]n b\ ie_j ` kk _es`]ebga ]b as`_Z d k p `a gb] aehge[s`g]_n sbc k ^bceaZfu  4 ˆŒW 5 SŽˆŒ þZ sbgs_dfZ ]Yea k ` k Z^ mn Zy`cegegh abcZ ^Z_`]Zf p b^ju ~bY^   |’” eg]^bfdsZf _`xn ]`aj s^Z`]ebg eg ]YZe^ ecq k _ZcZg]`]ebg b\ ]YZ ~d_qX _`ghd`hZu `xn ]`aj s^Z`]ebg ea aece_`^ eg c`gn p `na ]b bd^ _`xn asYZfd_egh ]ZsYgedZau ~bY^   ^Z k b^] ` p b^j blZ^YZ`f b\ `^bdgf | p YZg sbcq k `^egh p e]Y aZ^e`_ Xt ]YZ ûsYZcZ fe`_Zs] bg p YesY ~d_qX ea m`aZfu d^ ^ZaZ`^sY sbg[^ca ]YZ eg]de]ebg mZYegf ]YZe^ cZ]Ybfa `gf aYbp a ]Y`] p b^j blZ^YZ`fa b\ s_baZ ]b  `^Z `sYeZl`m_Zu XYZ ief _`ghd`hZ |}” ea _ejZ ie_j eg ]Y`] e] daZa i `a ` m`aZ _`ghd`hZ `gf Y`a ` aec k _Z k ^Z k ^bsZaaegh sbc k e_Z^ ]b sbglZ^] k `^`__Z_ ief sbga]^ds]a ]b iu ief ea fZaehgZf ]b p b^j eg ` fea]^emd]Zf cZcb^n Zgle^bgcZg]t `gf ab e] Zc k _bna _`]ZgsnqYefegh cZsY`geaca p YesY ie_jq{ sbd_f `lbefu úþZ 







þZ gbp k ^ZaZg] ` m^Z`jfbp g b\ ie_j€a aZ^e`_ blZ^YZ`f eg]b e]a sbc k bgZg]au Zs`daZ asYZfd_egh blZ^YZ`fa `^Z ac`__‰ \b^ cba] k ^bh^`cat p Z k Z^\b^c bd^ `g`_naea p e]Y ]YZ Š!@ k ^bh^`c \^bc . ehd^Z u XYea k ^bh^`c ea dgdad`__n aZgaeq ]elZ ]b asYZfd_egh blZ^YZ`fat mZs`daZ e] sbg]`ega _e]]_Z `s]d`_ sbc k d]`]ebgu þZ helZ ` m^Z`jfbp g b\ ]YZ aZ^e`_ blZ^YZ`f eg]b ]Y^ZZ sbc k bgZg]aw ]YZ blZ^YZ`f b\ a`legh a]`]Z mZ\b^Z a k `p geght ]YZ blZ^YZ`f b\ `__bs`]egh `s]el`]ebg \^`cZat `gf ]YZ blZ^YZ`f b\ ]YZ X , - k ^b]bsb_u . ehd^Z / aYb p a ]YZ m^Z`jfb p g b\ ie_j€a aZ^e`_ blZ^YZ`f \b^ Š!@ bg \bd^ c`sYegZau d^ cZ]Ybfb_bhn \b^ bm]`egegh ]YZaZ gdcmZ^a ea `a \b__bp au . e^a]t p Z ]`jZ ]YZ aZ^e`_ i Š!@ k ^bh^`c `gf ]ecZ e]a ZyZsd]ebgu XYZgt p Z egfelefd`__n `ff eg ]YZ sbfZ ]Y`] hZgZ^`]Za Z`sY b\ ]YZ blZ^YZ`fa `gf ]ecZ ]YZ ZyZsd]ebg b\ ]YZ ^Zad_]egh k ^bh^`cu þZ `]]^emd]Z ]YZ `ffe]ebg`_ ]ecZ ^Zde^Zf mn ]YZ cbfe[Zf k ^bh^`c ]b ]YZ asYZfd_egh sbfZ p Z `ffZfu g b^fZ^ ]b lZ^e\n bd^ gdcmZ^at p Z ]ecZf ]YZ Š!@ sbfZ p e]Y `__ b\ ]YZ ie_j blZ^YZ`fa `ffZf ú]YZ sbfZ aYbp g eg . ehd^Z ‘ýt `gf sbc k `^Zf ]YZ ^Zad_]egh ]ecZ ]b ]YZ adc b\ ]YZ egfelefd`_ blZ^YZ`fau g `__ s`aZat ]YZ ]p b ]ecZa fe0 Z^Zf mn _Zaa ]Y`g  u lZ^YZ`fa l`^n `s^baa `^sYe]Zs]d^Zat md] ]YZ blZ^YZ`f b\ ie_j ea ]n k es`__n bg_n ` \Z p ]ecZa ]YZ i ^dggegh ]ecZ bg ]Yea a k `p gqeg]ZgaelZ k ^bh^`cu lZ^YZ`fa bg ]YZ z_k Y` c`sYegZ `^Z k `^]esd_`^_n _`^hZt mZs`daZ e]a g`]elZ i \dgs]ebg s`__a `^Z \`a] sbc k `^Zf ]b ]YZ b]YZ^ `^sYe]Zs]d^Zau XYZ a]`]Zqa`legh sba]a `^Z ac`__ \b^ Š!@ t mZs`daZ `__ \bd^ `^sYe]Zs]d^Za Y`lZ p ^e]Z md 0 Z^a ]Y`] s`g YefZ ]YZ _`]Zgsn b\ ]YZ p ^e]Za ^Zde^Zfu þZ `_ab `]]Zc k ]Zf ]b cZ`ad^Z ]YZ s^e]es`_q k `]Y blZ^q YZ`f  u þZ daZf ]YZ ang]YZ]es #