Page 1 Hervé Cochard INRA-Clermont (Editor at Plant Physiology

Articles are archived by HAL. And indexed by. Google Scholar. Page 6. BUT,. JPH is not just another journal ! JPH is an « Experimental » Journal to explore and ...
1MB taille 0 téléchargements 42 vues
Hervé&Cochard&

INRA1Clermont& (Editor&at&Plant&Physiology)& & &

Chief&Editor&of&the&& Journal(of(Plant(Hydraulics( &

JPH:&A&new&peer4reviewed&Journal&for&Plant(Hydraulics( &Launched&in&2014& &Hosted&by&INRA&(www.inra.fr/jph)&

JPH&Editorial&Board&

23&

Currently:&& a&basic&front&office& No&back&office…&

•  ArNcles&are&archived& by&HAL& •  And&indexed&by& Google&Scholar&

BUT,&& JPH&is¬&just&another&journal&!& & & JPH&is&&an&«&Experimental&»&Journal& to&explore&and&promote& alterna@ve&economical&&&editorial& models&

14&An&alterna@ve&economical&model&

•  Scholarly&Journals&used&to&be&published&by&non1profit&organisaNons& (UniversiNes,&Research&InsNtuNons,&ScienNfic&SocieNes…)&& •  Scholarly&Journals&are&now&in&the&hands&of&a&few&for1profit&majors&(Elsevier,& Springer,&Wiley)&&& •  The&fees&paid&by&academics&to&access&these&publicaNons&are&excessive& &(several&M€/year&for&INRA&=&Annual&Budget&of&INRA1EFPA&department)&& •  Dilemma&:&pay&to&access&knowledge&or&pay&to&produce&knowledge&?&&

Thanks&to&the&emergence&of&e.publishing&it&is&now&cost1effecNve&for&Academic& research&insNtuNons&to&re1appropirate&its&scienNfic&ediNon& & •  As&authors,&editors,&referees…&academics&already&cover&most&the&editorial& costs&& •  InsNtuNons&could&afford&to&pay&for&the&extra&on1line&publicaNon&cost& JPH&is&hosted&and&published&by&INRA&& JPH&is&open4access&for&readers&and&free&of&charge&for&authors&

24&An&alterna@ve&editorial&model& The¤t&editorial&model&is&too&corrupted& by&the&«&Impact&Factor&»& & •  Impact&Factor&is&a&big&business&issue&for& for1profit&publishers& Higher&IF&=&more&money& •  Impact&Factor&should¬&be&a&scienNfic& issue&for&researchers& Higher&IF&≠&higher&impact& & H&Cochard&

Another&pernicous&effects&of&Impact&factor&for&scien@fic&edi@on& (Cochard&&&Delzon&PLAS&2015)&

IF=&N&citaNons/N&published&papers& Maximising&IF&inevitably&encourage&journals&to& publish&a&small&number&of&arbitrarily&selected& ‘good’&papers.& &Higher&IF&=&Higher&rejec=on&rate&&

Aarssen&et&al&2008&

Satura@on&of&the& peer4review&system&

JPH&Editorial&policy&(cf&PlosOne)&

&

•  We&reject&the&Impact&Factor& •  We&publish&all&the&papers&that&are&judged& technically&sound&and&scienNfically&correct.&& •  We&have&no&a&priori&on&a&presumed& importance&or&significance&of&the&science& (measured&a&posteriori&by&the&readership&on&the& own&arNcles&merit&=&eg,&N&citaNons)& •  We&are&more&H51friendly,&a&more&defendable&and& less&pernicious&metric&of&a&journal&audience&

TradiNonal&editorial&model& maximising&Impact&Factors&

Emerging&model& favouring&H5&

Journal&1&

Revue&1&

Peer1review&

Peer1review&

Index:&

&

Second&

&

&

67&

&

&

45&

&

30&

&

20&

30&

& Peer1review& &

20&

&

20&

&

14&

&

14&

& &

Journal&3& Third&

&

9&

&

9&

6&

&

6&

& Peer1review& &

4&

&

4&

&

4&

&

3&

&

3&

&

3&

&

CitaNons& per&arNcle&

&

14& 9& 6& 4&

Journal&4& Fourth&

3&

2&

&

2&

&

2&

&

1&

&

1&

&

1&

&

Peer1review&

1&

&

1&

&

1&

&

1&

1&

1&

&

1&

&

1&

&

1&

1&

0&

&

0&

&

0&

&

0&

0&

0&

&

0&

&

0&

&

0&

0&

0&

&

0&

&

0&

&

0&

0&

0&

&

0&

&

0&

&

0&

0&

0&

&

0&

&

0&

&

0&

0&

0&

&

0&

&

0&

&

0&

0&

66%&

50%&

20%&

IF=2.2&

IF=0.5&

H5=7&

80%& 75%& IF=53& IF=10.7&

PUBLISHED&&

45&

Journal&2&

100&

2& 1&

PUBLISHED&

&

&

Not&contribuNng&to&H5&

67&

&

&

&

REJECTED&

PUBLISHED& REJECTED& %Reject:&

100&

ContribuNng&to&H5&

Only&one&

First&&

What&is&next&for&JPH&?& &

•  Financial&support&from&Bordeaux& University&(60k€)& •  Improve&our&back&and&front&offices&& •  Propose&an&open&plateform&for& Scholarly&Journals&