Overlay Optimizations for End-host Multicast Wenjie Wang
David A. Helder
Sugih Jamin
Department of EECS University of Michigan 48109 Ann
Arbor, MI
!" ##$ % &(') $& *'
ABSTRACT
./10)2 346587 9;:,(? @587 @A BA0 OFg@00,>/,Rj/_)5;7#4d@C/qA r >587#>/Rs4CB6A J#46/D]">=7#3Q@/FD4CKU7#3APA r >587#>(/,R 7*J#A A2\O@5*A0DE,J#4C7#4? 46=7#3lJ#A (B6A /7*J#4)0,:,? 7#>46/m["L8N}
l:,(? @587sX>5 587#>=7#46:,5*KV7#A0d46/d7#4 A /10 2 3,46587p9;:?@C587l]"3>?3fO:,>((5x5*:E,E!4J*7#A0>(/E1@CJ*7sOF7#3A` MT.o."]-@GJ0sMTL\2\6y )[U7#3,ASNZJ#A 5*>(0,A /7#>(@587#5D@/10./R>(/,A A J#5No. T,.ka6 [ 7#3,AaPE9HA /)7 4CJ#EYesNZ@CJ*7 4K"7#3,>(5I]h4CJ#_j]-@C5;? 49S2 E,?3p=7#A J@G7#:,J#AX4/a7#3,AT0 A 5*>R6/Y[,>9HE(4/Y[)@C/10DA B@46/ 4K1B@CJ#>4:5ZE,J#4C7#4? 46(R ew6eoT4)0 A 5-¬v[ H[® [ ¯l[ @/0H°>/Du>R,e!P@CJ#AM9HA 9;O!AJ#5o4CKY@I9 :?@587RJ#4:EY[/4)0,A 5 ± [1±`~[,@/10p±Xy;@GJ#AXJ#46: 7#A J#5">(/a7#3AX/,A 7^]4J#_![,@/0a7#3AX0@5*3,A0 /A 5S? 46//,A ? 7#>/Ri7#3,Aa/,4)0,A 5;@CJ#ApE3F 5*>(? @O7K 4J*]h@CJ0 5h7#3AME1@?_A 7o7#4 ¯l[ ]"3,>?3HK 4CJ*]-@GJ0,5->=77#4 z@/10x°SµZ@G7v©7#3,A;E1@C?_6A 7`>5XK : J*7#3A J`KW4J*]-@GJ0,A0x7#4Q¬ve;h3A J#>R637-3@/10HRCJ@E3D4CKuu>R,ew6³O!o5*3,4]"5h7#3AM4CB6A J#A /? A 5"/RQ¬IeSh3,>5vAr@C9HE5D@ 5*>/R=J[!]"3,>(=Jez¨h-Nu[ ¤`
Q-Nu[@/0aªk46>(0l@GJ#A`A r,@9HEB)>=7#>(A 5X@9H4/RSRCJ#46:,Ei9HA 9;O!A J#5 [ 7#3):5a>5Q4/A0we}¤T4]A BA J[M7#3AxA r >582 7#A /,? A"4KwJ#A0,:,/10,@/7? 46/,/A ?7#>(B)>=7#>A 5 **¼ ' W#% 9HA 9;O!AJ#5u7#4XJ#:/H@ J#46: 7#>/RH@C=7#39}7#4;? 46/,587*J#:? 7"/RHE@C7#3U³5 O!A 7\]hA A /x9HA 9 O!A J#5 evX@CJ@0@p@/10¤PF E!A J#? @587I@GJ#ASA r,@9HE,/RQ4/s7#3A 4GBA J#R6/,5v@l?@C(5-?@/,R >/ K 4J#9D@G7#>46/cKWJ#49Ø]"3,>?3q7#3,Ai/A r)7DK 4CJ*]-@GJ0,>/R34Eq7#4]-@GJ0,5 7#3,AM0,A 587#>/1@G7#>46/D?@/DO!A"46O 7@>/A 0meZP/(? @< /,A 7^]4J#_gA 5l@GJ#Ai7@_A /b>/)7#4d@? ? 4:/7a>/q7#3AQ? 46/587*J#:,? 2 7#>4/q@/0xJ#A ? 46/587*J#:,? 7#>46/1T4Kh7#3,AS4GBA J#/RlO)F?@< @00)J#A 5*5*A 5M?@/lJ#A 5*:(/p=J#5 e M7#>4/;>5V0 KW4J#9H>/Ra>5*46A /7X7*J#A A 2 O1@C5*A0i4GBA J*2 5TK 4CJ#9HA0m[m4/x7#3,A 4C7#3A J`3@/0m[w9;:,(? @587`E@?_A 7#5T? @/xO!A KW4J*]h@CJ0,A 0s@C/bu>(R e~)[oK 4Ja@E1@C?_6A 7 5*A /)7SO)F°²7#4sJ#A@C?3bÙj[o>=7H9;:,587;ÚJ#587 7*J@BA (0,Av4K7#3,AX7*J#A Av7#4 ÙjeoL KU]hAv@00l@C/QA r)7*J@;/_DO!A 7\]hA A /Q¬@/0i® [,5*34]"/i@5-7#3,A 0,@5*3,A0/,Aa>/7#3AHÚR6:,J#A[o0@C7@0 A (B6A J*FdO!A 7\]hA A /° @/0Ù >5P5*34J*7#A /A0QOFQ4/AI34EYeMNZ@G7#35TO!A7^]hA A /i47#3,A JT9HA 9;O!A J#5"46/ 7#3,Av7*J#A Av]46:/iR6A /A J@C587@/? A O!A 7\]hA A /Q7#3AI5*:O 7*J#A AvJ#44C7#A0@C7`®Û@C/10l7#3Av5*:O 2 7*J#A AlJ#447#A0q@C7D¬z>(5H5*3,4J*7#A /,A0bOF4/AQ3,46EmefT0,0,>/Rs@xKWA ] Ar 7*J@I/_)5k7#4 @v9 :?@587k7*J#A AT9D@ F J#A 5*:/p@/D4GBA J#=7#3x5*34J*7#? :,7#5`@gÜYÝ %8 [w7#3A;E J#4? A 5*5`4CK @00 >(/,RH5*34CJ*7#? :,7#5"7#4D@S7*J#A A`7#3AiÜYÝ %8xÞß1à³ ; áGCà³ Þaß1*Þ$%#% [ @C/10s7#3,ASE,J#4C7#4? 46(/,Rl5*3,4J*7#? : 7#5I7#3,AdÜYÝ %8lß1*Þà Þ$#Þ6 e u>R e!y;5*3,4G]"5P@/pA r,@9HE,(0,A 5M5*3,4J*7#A JMA 5MO!A 7^]A A /p9HA 9;O!A J#5>(/a7#3A`RCJ#46:EmeL\7">5 @C/,587IE1@CJ*7#>=7#>46/,>/RQ@C5`>=7`E,J#4GB)>(0,A 5TJ#A 0,:/ 2 0,@/7Z? 4//,A ? 7#>46/,5uO!A 7^]A A /v9HA 9;O!AJ#5 eU¥X: J#>/R"7*J#A AkJ#A ? 46/587*J#:,? 2 7#>4/Y[@CKW7#AJa@x9HA 9 O!A Jv=7#3,46:,7M@C/FHE1@C?_A7-(4/j0 A 7#A ? 7#>4/s>5`9;:,?3iA @5*>A JI>/j@a"
lA 5*3me;M5 46/>/,R,[Y@p"
lA 5*3j46/,=7#>46/,>(/,Rd4KT7#3Ap7*J#A A6[h7#3):5;J#A 0,:? >(/,RjE@CJ*7#>=7#>46/f0 A 7#A ? 7#>46/ 4GBAJ#3A@0me: J*7#3A J#9H4CJ#A6[uKW4JS9 :?@587 RJ#4:E,5v]">=7#3@Q5*9D@=7#346: 7IJ#://,>/Rp@ J#4:,7#>/RS@7#3,9Qe T: JhA r E!A J#>9HA /7#5o5*34]c7#3@C7@ "
lA 5*3a?@C/aJ#A0 :? AMA 5 O!A7^]hA A /b/,4)0,AaE1@C>J#5;A BA /]"3A /g5*3,4J*7#? : 7#5S@GJ#Al5*A
46E 7#>9H>(¹ @C7#>46/p>(5":,5*A K :,=7P? @/l4E!A J@C7#A`>/l@;0,>587*J#>O: 7#A0 9D@/,/A Jea.o@?3d/,4)0,AH9;:,587v0,A ? >V0 ASK 4CJ >=7#5*A =7#3p5*A B6A J@9HE587#>(? 5 K 4CJ`5*34CJ*7#? :,7P5*A 4/YeXtf3,>4:5HA /0 2 34587D9;:?@C587D4CB6A J#46/E,J#4C7#4? 46?@C(R6@C7#A 5D7#3AlA âwA ? 7p4Kv@00,>/,Rd/A ]z/_)5D7#4j7#3A 4GBA J#JMA 5 ekL^/Q A ? 7#>4/Q;]hA`5*3,4] 7#31@G7 "
lA 5*346E 7#>(9H>¹@G7#>46/?@C/dO!AH:5*A0s>(/j? 46/C8:/,? 7#>46/j]">=7#3 7#3A 7*J#A A 2 O1@C5*A0xªk46>(0A /10)2\3,46587`9 :?@587IE J#47#4? 4A BA =JoA 5 eZtdA"@C46:5TRJ#46:,Ej5*>¹ A 5 eItjA;5*A AS? 46/5*>587#A /7`E!AJ*2 K 4CJ#9D@/,? A`>9HE,J#4GBA 9HA /7>(/Q@/RS7*J#A A6[!7#3Av3A : J#>587#>(? 5T]hAvE,J#4C2 E!465*ASKW4JI5*3,4J*7#? : 7I5*A 46/d? @/dO!A A:1@? :,/,? A@M"
lA 5*3 >5O,:,7@I9HA 5*3Y[]AM]h@/77#4I_)/4]c3,4]c>=7h? 49HE1@GJ#A 5k]">=7#3DA r >587*2 >/RH9HA 5*3 2 O1@5*A 0p4GBA J#(?I]hAS@60,4E,7`>/x7#3>5XE1@CE!A J[mR6>BA /x7#31@G7X7#3AvK 4? :,5 4Ku46:,JM587#:0 FD>5"46/Q/,4)0,A 2 E1@C>=J"(A BA0p:,/10 A J-B@CJ#>46:,5 4GBA J#5o7#3,APãMä *å"æ" à³ ä -çv èTéP16 à³èDê ã æ"çPéZë e)P5 0,AÚ1/A 0p>/d G[!MA BA`¥XA 4H4K 7#3AP=J"ðo@/0;ñS4/a7#3,AX4GBA J#(5P7#3Av/ :,9;O!A JM4CK9HA 9 O!A J#5">/7#3,A 9 :?@587PRJ#4:E ³/4)0 A 5I>/d7#3AS4GBA J#?3H>(5@`9HA 5*3,2 O1@C5*A0;E J#47#4? 4(/7#3AIÚ1R:,J#AI]hA J#A 46O 7@>/A0QKVJ#469 5*>9 :46/,5X46/x@ ,[ {{6{C2 /,4)0,AD7#46E!46(/,Rl7#3AHL\/A 7*2\y)e {l7#4E!465"5*34]"5P7#3@C7"7#3A`9 :?@587M4GBA J#(/5*>¹ AxKWJ#469ÿ{d7#4f6[ {6{{b9HA 9 O!A J#5 eÛ4CJQA@C?3 9HA 9 O!A J#5*3>EH5*>¹ A6[ K 4CJ"A@?3l4GBA J#(4/lE J#47#4? 4(9 :4/7#A /c7#>(9HA 5 [P]">=7#30,>=âwA J#A /7p5*A 7Q4CKv/4)0,A 5 ¬T±T¯Hóô
R
R
Tree links Shortcut links
A
B
A
C
B
C A
E
F
G
E
H
@/0H@/_)5 >(/b@/ 4GBAJ#/R5l4CK;B@CJ#>=2 4:5IE1@GJ@9HA 7#AJ#5`:5*A0i]">=7#3j7#3A E,J#47#4? 46J"A 5"4/l7#3AX¤X
Q-N7*J#A A 5M@CJ#Av~)| 7#4a~C«|}(0p7*J#A A 5 ehtc3>(0I7*J*F`7#4P9H>(/,>9H>(¹ Ao7#3,A46/5 [ S¤`
Q-N >/,? 4J#E!4CJ@C7#A 5I5*A BAJ@587#>(? 5X7#4aJ#A ? 46R6/,>¹ AD@/0s@B4>V0/,>(9D@a>/d7#3AS7*J#A AH? 4/587*J#:,? 7#>46/E,J#4? A 5*5p³5*A Ax yG e TA B6A J*2 7#3,A ?3x:5*A 5T9H4J#A 7#3@/xõ²öc;(/,_)5X46/7#3Av4GBA J*2 =J-A 5"46/p¤`
Q-N7*J#A A 5"@GJ#A`«|7#4H~C| 3,>R63AJU7#31@C/X7#345*Ao4/`X@GJ@60@-4GBA J#=7#3l:,/>=K 4CJ#9}E,J#4O1@O,>=7\Feh3AT7#4C7@< /):,9;O!A J"4CK/,_ 5M>/l7#3A`J#A 5*:,(/,RD"
lA 5*3i>5M7#3,AI5#@9HAI@5"7#31@G7 4/g7#3,ApT@CJ@0@4CB6A J#?@CR63)O!4J"9HA 9;O!A Jh@/10D?@C?6e nY>/_)5T]">=7#3s? 46/,5*A /5*:,5 ? 4587-O!A /R5 4CK-7#3A 5*AS7#3 J#A 5*34=7#>A 5-4K 6 õÛösT/_)5hO!A7^]hA A /D>7#5*A 7\Fg:/,2 7#>=7#37#3,AI/? : J*J#A0m[Y]hAD0 4Q/4C7IA r E!A ? 7;¡PJ#A A0)FsT@CJ@0@p7#4 O!AME,J@?7#>(? @7#3X7#3,AX@CJ@0@ E,J#4C7#4? 46R,eml5*3,4G]"5X7#3@C7T46:,JI5*>9HE,=7H>5H? 5I@00,A 0m[Y>7I? @/jO!A >/? 4CJ#E!4J@C7#A 0j>/)7#4a7#3A 5*34J*7#A 587 E1@G7#35P4Kk9;:E=J#5 [Y0,A E!A /10 >(/,RH46/7#3Av46: 7#? 469HAv4K 7#3AD¥X> ^_ 587*J@ Nk? 49HE:,7@G7#>46/Yel¤TA /,? AS7#3ADM¥`NR6@>/4KM@ 5*34CJ*7#? :,7h>(5/47h/A ? A 5*5#@CJ#>(9HE J#4GBA 9HA /7`]"3A /7#3,AD5*34J*7#? :,7S>5H@00 A0mesh3A /):9 O!A J#5Z@CJ#AM@BA J@CR6A0vKWJ#469¸7#A /S5*>9;:(4/5Z]">=7#3S4GBA J#¹ A 4Kh«6{{p/4)0 A 5 evh3A;PM¥`Nq>9HE,J#4GBA 9HA /7#5T@GJ#A;5*9D@9HE!4J*7@C/? Av4Ko7#3Av>/>=7#>(@< 4GBA J#(/H7#3,AM7*J#A A ? 4/587*J#:?7#>(4/SE,J#4? A 5*5 eP5ZA B >(0 A /7>(/;u>R,e,[¤X
Q-N 54GBA J#7#>(@C9D@->/I7#3,A? 4/587*J#:,? 7#>46/vE,J#4? A 5*5 [A@C?3v>/10,>B)>(0,:@9HE,J#4GBASPM¥`NOFs@Q(@/Ye ,J#497#3A-@CO!4GBAJ#A 5*:,587#>? 5Z7#4X@00 46/,V@C< 5*34CJ*7#? :,7#5i 2\@Cr >5;31@BAl@sR>(B6A /qM¥`N R@>/³þ2\@Cr >5ef.BA / K 4CJ7#3,AM¤X
Q-Nd4GBA J#=7#3dM¥`NR@>/d?3iA@?3/4)0 AIJ#A7@>/5T@HJ#44C7XE@C7#3 7#3AIE@C7#3 4KP7#3Aa/4)0 Ap7#47#3ADJ#447D46/7#3AD7*J#A AG[5*:?3g@5S¤X
Q-N@C/10 ªk46>(0m[MA 5Q4/c7#3A4GBA J#(9HE,/Rx7#3Aa7^]h4xJ#447aE1@G7#35 egtdA ]">5*? :5*5T5*469HAvE,J@?7#>(? @9HE4/Q>5*5*:A 5`>/ 5*A 7*7#>/R 7#3AI@E,E,J#4E,J#>(@C7#AX7#3 J#A 5*3446/e
^
^
H
M
L
\L
M
GwxzyX{
D|
3.2 hUtil
L^/I@00 >7#>4/v7#4"3M¥`Nu[ 4/Ao?@/v@C587#>(? 5u5*>9H>(/R`/4)0 A 5>/,? >=2 0,A /)7k7#4;>=7h7#4 6 0,A 587#>/@C7#>46/,5 eo¨kFp0,A 5*>R6/m[ A@?3p/,4)0,AMJ#://,>/R X@GJ@60,@T? 469HE,:,7#A 5u7#3,Ah5*34CJ*7#A 587oE1@G7#35u7#4`@C=7#>(4/A0weL\K 7#3Al@E,E?@C7#>46/b:5*>/R7#3Ap4GBA J#=J#Al/)7@C>/5">=7#5T0 >(587@C/? AI>/,KW4J#9D@G7#>(4/i7#4H@7\F`4K1@M5*3,4J*7#? : 7- m>(5U? 469HE,:,7#A0`46/,R eT5*3,4G]"5Z7#3,Ah? 4J*J#A 46/DO!A 7^]A A /v7#3Ah9HE,J#4GBA 9HA /7#5ZKWJ#497#A /D5*>9;: 2 (4/5M4Ko«{6{C2 /,4)0,A`4GBA J#/RT7#3,A ? 46/587*J#:,? 7#>46/bE,J#4? A 5*5 efu>(R ehiK : J*7#3A JD5*3,4]"5S7#31@C7H7#3,A J#AQ@GJ#A 9H4CJ#APE!4C7#A /7#>(@=7#>(A 5->(/H7#3,A ¤X
Q-Ng? @5*AP7#3@/D>/aªk46>(0 5?@5*A6eoh3,AT9H4CJ#AP5*: J#E,J#>5*>/RIJ#A 5*:R,e, >5-3,4G]c5*34J*7#? :,7#5h7#31@G7->9HE,J#4GBAP@BA J@RA
^
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
0.35
0.4
0.45
0.5
Average Utility
¿"ÀWÁ1ÂUÃGÄ
@ /4)0,AH !h@/10pE!47#A /7#>(@=7^Fp7#4H@S5*9D@9;:,9Û@/10D9H>/>9;:,9ÛPM¥`N>(9S2 E,J#4GBA 9HA /7#5-@CJ#A`K : J*7#3A J"KVJ#469}7#3A`9HA @/p7#3@/a]"3A /l7#3,A J#AI@CJ#A @;/Q7#3A`E J#A B)>(4:5M5*A ? 7#>46/i7#3@C7P/ 2 0,>?@G7#4J#5KW4J>7#5k4GBA J@(5k5*A ? 7#>46/H]APA B@/l4CKu7#3A 5*AT3A : J#>(587#>? 5">/l? 46/587*J#:,? 7#>/R @a"
lA 5*3YeIL\/xE@CJ*7#>? :,5"? 46/,5*>V0 A J#A0 ½8:@=Ú1A0 ¾ >=KuA >7#3,A J->=7#5-M¥`NdR@C>(/p4J"@BAJ@R6AP:,7#>=7^FD>5"@O!4GBA ? A J*7@C>/l7#3,J#A 5*3,46(/,R;4/l7#3AX3,A :,J#>587#>? 5MA 9HEA FS0,>5*? :5*5o5*469HA"E J@? 7#>?@C5*5*:A 5oJ#A /R4KM7#3A 5*Aa7#3 J#A 5*34/b A ? 7#>4/qe4CJ;7#3,Ap5*>9;:,46/,5 J#A E!4CJ*7#A0l3AJ#A6[1O@5*A0l4/i0@G7@;E,J#A 5*A /7#A0l>/l7#3ATE,J#A B)>46:,5M5*A ? 2 7#>46/m[]hAT5*A7h7#3AMP¥XNjR@C>(/D7#3,J#A 5*346/a7#3,AP3,P¥XNj3A : J#>587#>(? 5 õs[o]"3A J#Alõ >5;7#3AaRJ#4:E5*>¹ A6eg4CJS7#3Aa3M7#>582 7#4 7#>? 5 [-]hAQ@5*5*:9HAs{| 4CK`7#3Ap9HA 9;O!A J#5S@CJ#Ai5*A /0,A J#5D@C/10b5*A7 7#3AP@BA J@CR6AT: 7#>=7\FS7#3,J#A 5*3,46
¿"ÀWÁ!ÂUÃGÄÅ mÆ
1 Unicast Narada TMesh w/hRDP TMesh w/hUtil (100% Senders) TMesh w/hUtil (10% Senders)
10000
0.9 Number of Physical Links
0.8 0.7
CDF
0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 Narada TMesh w/Rand TMesh w/hRDP TMesh w/hUtil (100% Senders) TMesh w/hUtil (10% Senders)
0.2 0.1 0
1000
100
10
1 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1
~ '©($
$
$ D k
!U !3 =%
2
tjA;?@G7#A R64CJ#>¹ AHE,J#4C7#4? 46/7#4p7^]4a7\F E!A 5 ò"J#46:,7#>/,R 4GBAJ#3A@0d@/0s7*J#A AH9D@>/7#A /@/? AS4GBA J#3A @60meDtjAH0,4Q/,47v? 4/,2 5*>(0 A JME1@?_A 7"3,A@60 A JM4GBA J#3A @60l@C5">7M0 4A 5"/4C7P3@BAT7#4;O!A`B6A J*F 0 >=âwA J#A /7hO!A 7\]hA A /aE J#47#4? 4/R`7#3@C7-"
lA 5*3p:,5*A 5k7#3,A 5#@C9HAIE1@C7#3lBA ? 7#4CJX@C=7#39²:5*A0p46/iX@GJ@60,@ [wu>R,eUH5*34]"5 7#3@C7M7#3AI? 4587T7#4H9D@>/7@>/iE@C7#3iBA ?7#4J#5"7#4p@C/,Rg4GBAJ#3A@0q>/? : J*J#A0cOFqA@C?3 /,4)0,AQ>/b0,A 5*? A /10 >(/,Rj4CJ0,A Je ºtf3A /J#A ? A >BA J*2 O1@C5*A0b5*3,4J*7#? : 7 ? 46/587*J#:,? 7#>46/x>5XA 9HE46/sy[w]">=7#3x4//RI@C5k5*A /10,AJ#5 [9D@Cr >9;:,9J#4:,7#>/RX4GBAJ#3A@0;?@/ O!A`? :,7-7#4H@CO!46:,7T~Cy6yS`O>=7#5-E!A JM:,Ew0@C7#Ae
16
32
64
128
¿"ÀWÁ1ÂUÃGÄÅ wÆ
2500 100% Senders 10% Senders
^
4.3 Protocol Overhead
8
Link Load
¿"ÀWÁ!ÂUÃGÄÅ mÆ
tc3A /i@ /4)0,AI3@5M@S3>R63,A JP0,A RCJ#A AI46/l7#3,A`4GBA J#=7#5 /):,9;O!A JM4KoE,3)F 5*>?@C(4/5 [m@G7T=7#5PE3F 5*>(? @< ? 46//,A ? 7#>46/a]">(O,:,7#>46/j4K"/_ 9 :46/,5I4K"«{6{C2 /,4)0,AD4GBA J#?@5I>9HE?@C587a0,A BA J*Fg>5D@5*5*:,9HA0mebtf>=7#3b:,/>?@587a0 A BA J*F[ 7#3,AP5*4:,J#? AM5*A /0,5k@I? 46EFS4CKY7#3,AP0,@C7@X7#4IA@?3H9HA 9 O!A Jk0,>=J#A ? 7#/Rg@d5*A E1@GJ@C7#Ax:/,>(? @587Q? 46//,A ? 7#>46/meÛh3A9D@Cr >9;:,9 /_ (/d7#3,Ap:,/>?@C587S?@C5*Ap>5HC³/4C7S5*34]"/1[0 :AH7#4/4)0 A 5 3@B >/,Rs9 :E(? @46/5 egh3,Al9D@Gr,>9 :9»/_ (9HE,/R"7#3Ah3,P¥`N@C/10 3M7#>(587#>? 5 e;h3A 9H4)0,>=Ú1A 0xT@CJ@60,@a_6A A E5T46/(587@C/? A >/,KW4J#9D@C7#>4/l7#4;7#3A {|}4CKZ/4)0 A 5-7#31@C7P@GJ#A`E!47#A /7#>(@5P9H4)0,>=Ú1A0QT@CJ@0@S>5T>/? 46/9HA ?31@C/>5*9ý@60,0,A0w[u]"3>?3d]">((9 :4/5u]hA-:,5*A-@MJ#4:,7#>/RT:Ew0@G7#AE!A J#>4)0 4KTGl5*A ? 4/10 5 ep 34CJ*7#? :,7#5I@GJ#AD@60,0,A0x>(/j"
lA 5*346/,/,A0p? 4//,A ? 7#A0D7#4H@;E1@GJ#A /7-K 4CJP 5*A ? 4/10 5 ]">=7#34:,7H58]">=7#?3>/R e}9HA 9;O!AJ;?3A ?_)5vKW4JHO!A7*7#A JS5*3,4J*7#? : 7#5 A BAJ*Fay6{;5*A ? 46/10 5 [,]"3,>?3p>(5"0 46:,O46/4K"7#3,AD7#4E!464/gE J#4? A 5*5e h3,ApJ#A 5*:,(/,Rx7#4E!46(/,5l6[ ~«s/,4)0,A 5 estdADJ#:/d7#A / 5*>9 :46/,5QK 4CJsA @?34GBA J#4/E,J#4? A 5*5i46/7#3>5 7#4E!46(9 :4/Y[ ]hAXJ@/0,49H?_p~{{S/4)0 A 5 7#45*AJ#BA@5a9HA 9;O!AJ#5H4Kv@/fA /10 2 3,46587D9;:,(? @587pRJ#46:,EY[-7#3,A 9D@Gr >(9 :9c/,4)0,Ao0,A RJ#A Ao(9H>=7Y>5Y5*A 7Y7#4" euh3AJ#A 5*:/R"MP¥`N5 @GJ#A6òo6e «I³X@GJ@60@6[6e y6I"
lA 5*3X]P¢G3M¥`N[@/10;e ~«`"
lA 5*3 ]P¢G3M7#>((/l"
lA 5*3lE,J#4C7#4? 46(R/YeZtjA 587#>E,:/Ri"
lA 5*30,4A 5v/4C7 /,A A0s7#4 _6A A Ei@ KW:4/Q9;:,587"O!A 9D@0,AMOFSA@C?3a/4)0 AP>/10 A E!A /0,A /7#4/Hy [646// 4CJS@BAJ@R6AD: 7#>(=7^Fs>5;@CO!4GBAH? A J*7@C>(/d7#3 J#A 5*34=7#3H3,>(R3SE!47#A /,2 7#>(@CR6/>=Ú?@/7#=7#>46/Y[m]"3>?3s:,/,KW4J*7#:/@C7#A 7587#>4/ O!A >(/,R7#31@C7p/4C7Q@C=7#3j=KY7#3,APM¥`N R6@>/l7#3 J#A 5*34(5"5*A 7"7#44S¹ A6[46/,A ? 46:=7#3sB@? 5 [7#3,Ah? 49HE:,7@G2 7#>4/x4CKk@D5*3,4J*7#? : 7 5X@BA J@CR6A;: 7#>=7\Fi@¹ A >/7#4H@C? ? 46:,/7e
á
â
e "ã
^
6. CONCLUSION
L^/x7#3>5IE1@CE!A JI]hAHE,J#A 5*A /7#A0j@l58F 587#A 9D@G7#>?H587#:10 F4/d? 4CJ*J#A 2 /Ri=7#3j7#3A E!47#A /)7#>(@C4/;4K1/4)0,A2\E@>=JA 5o>(/ 34587*2\O@5*A0v9;:,?@587`0@C7@D0 A (B6A J*Fe"tdAIE,J#4E!465*A0x@HE,J#47#4? 467#3S@/FvA r >(587#>/,RT7*J#A A 2 O1@C5*A0 34587S9 :?@587 E,J#4C7#4? 46=J;A 5 extdA 5*34]A0q7#31@G7["A BA /q]">=7#3cJ@C/10,49H/R;"
lA 5*3a31@5@`? J#>=7#>(? @A B@O,? :=7S>5H>9HE!4J*7@/7v7#31@G7S7#3AaE,J#4C7#4? 46?@G7#>(4/lP5*>(/,RD)]">=7#?3,2\YJ#A A 5"NJ#4C7#4? 46/Y[@/10pnoe w3@/,R,e,¤T46587T
l:,?@C587òk ,J@9HA ]4J#_D¥XA BA J#>/,RD
l:?@587TU4H./10aT5*A J#5 e é-8Þ$G&oÞ kÝ [~C{6{~e Cv¦,e1nm>A O!A 3AJ*JT@C/10QTe¨A@C9Qe¤MF E!A J @587òo¸NZJ#47#4? 46/7@>/>/Ra
l:,(? @587X¡PJ#46:EQ
lA 9;O!AJ#5M>/l@SnY4R6>?@< à³kÞ # *ÞC'Cß ¤PF E!A J#? :,O!AXU4E!46/me ') ³ W)åD $#6 ( 8%#à³',$ à³')# Ü *Þèa! é-8$ à³ $ ewN3¥7#3,A 5*>5 [ T/>BAJ#5*>7\Fa4Ko
l>?3>R@C/Y[w~C{6{6~)e
î
5ñ
±
ï 0ï
å
æ
$ñ Nä èNò¢òòóèUô\õoêåoê ìë ö ÷
å
} øä
1î
ô
ô
è 1ä
Nä å çæ è éåoê ìë í.í
Uv Cú
1û
8ô 1î $ñ å çæ
*ð
oé ±
æ
Uv é
å Où èNò¢ò¢ò Uv 1î å ù èNòò¢ò 1î æ ± ô Uv
î
