Alex Francois - Verbal aspect and personal pronouns

1sg Aorist includes /k/ as in Mwotlap nk, but this /k/ is a prefix to the verb. obvious when pronoun and verb are separated: Vera'a. Mwotlap. n s k- an. 1sg. PROSP ...
483KB taille 2 téléchargements 449 vues
Torres Is.

Alex François

Banks Is.

LACITO-CNRS, Paris

Maewo

Santo

Verbal aspect and personal pronouns

Ambae

Malekula

The history of aorist markers in north Vanuatu

Efate

Tanna

5 July 2007 — COOL7, Nouméa

The personal pronouns of Mwotlap

A special form for the 1sg pronoun The 1sg subject pronoun has two forms: n vs depending on the predicate’s TAM marking.

The subject and object clitics of POc have been replaced in Mwotlap with a unique set of free pronouns: SING

DUAL

TRIAL

PLUR

n nk k

dj kamj kmj kj

dtl kamtl kmtl kjtl

n kmm kimi kj

1 incl 1 excl 2 3

(2)

m-tsas k,

k

m-tsas

n.

1sg

PRF-see

3sg

PRF-see

1sg

3sg

nk

[*n ]

1sg:AO

ml. return

‘I went back.’

nk = ‘1sg:AO’

স 3sg subjects encode the Aorist with a prefix ni-: (3)

k

ni-

ml.

3sg

AO:3sg-

return

‘He went back.’

n

nk,

স nk encodes one TAM category, called the Aorist

These pronouns are generally invariant: (1)

Pentecost

ni- = ‘AO:3sg’

… and other persons with zero: (4)

‘I saw her and she saw me.’

kj (Ø-)

ml.

3du

return

(AO-)

‘They went back.’ 4

5

Semantic definition of Mwotlap's Aorist „

The Aorist of Mwotlap has a wide polysemy / polyfunctionality.

„

Five major functions (see François 2003) স Sequential actions in sequence, typically in narratives… স Generic definitions, procedure descriptions, conditional… স Subjunctive required in modality-bound subordinate clauses স Optative optative; volitional modality; imperative স Imperfective with reduplicated verb: habitual; progressive

Hiw

স Can surrounding languages help understand the unusual morphology of Mwotlap's aorist?

LoToga Löyöp Lehali Volow Mwotlap

(nk) | Ø | ni- | Ø

Lemerig

Mota

Veraa „

Mwesen

The Aorist construes a new event which is deictically indeterminate with regard to tense and modality.

Vurës

স Could be called “Indefinite”, “Minimal”, “Dependent” or “Zero aspect” Nume „

This complex aspect category matches narrowly several cases of aorist described for other languages of the world

Lakon

(Wolof; Hausa; Berber; Coptic; Turkish …)

Olrat

স "Aorist" originally means 'indefinite' স

Aspect studies in Benveniste (1966); Culioli (1978); Robert (1996)…

6

Hiw

The Quest for the Aorist „

Sequential

DRG

ti

t

s

Generic

?



Subjunctive

The 11 northernmost languages possess a genuine “Aorist”

OLR

LKN

Ø

t

Lehali Volow

(nk) | Ø | ni- | Ø

Lemerig

Mota

Veraa

Mwesen Vurës

s-

s-

()a

()a

t

Optative Imperfective

KRO

Mwerlap

Löyöp

স They possess no single TAM category that encompasses the five basic functions of Mwotlap's Aorist. স The equivalent morphemes resemble neither nk nor ni-. NUM

Dorig

LoToga

The six “South Banks” languages

MRL

Koro

Aorist markers in North Vanuatu

st … ti

t-… ti

t-… ti

t-… ti t-… t 10

Aorist markers in North Vanuatu

11

The Quest for the Aorist „

The Quest for the Aorist

The eleven northernmost languages

„

স Each language possesses a single TAM category that essentially encompasses the five basic functions of Mwotlap's Aorist.

The three “Central Banks” languages স Aorist encoded by a set of clitics or pronoun variation

স The formal coding of the Aorist varies with the person of the subject

1sg

2sg

3sg

non-singular

‘let me see’

‘you see’

‘let him see’

‘let us see’

Mota

(nau) na ilo

(ko) ka ilo

(ni) ni ilo

nina a ilo

Mwesen

na na l

nk a l

n ni l

nin a l

Vurës

(n) na l

nk i l

n ni l

nn a l

স স স স

a vowel a where Mwotlap had Ø. ni ‘AO:3sg’. a single vowel: i ; or a < spread of non-sg. MTA ka < ko+a. alternation between pronoun n (or nau) and Aorist na MTA/VRS na < nau/n + a.

স Forms for 3sg: HIW

3sg

LTG

LYP

LHI

MTP

VLW

LMG

VRA

VRS

MSN

MTA

Sequential Generic Subjunctive

n

ni

n-

n-

ni-

n-

n-

n

ni

ni

ni

Optative Imperfective

non-sg: 3sg: 2sg: 1sg:

13

16

The Quest for the Aorist „

The Quest for the Aorist

The three “Central Banks” languages

„

স Aorist encoded by a set of clitics or pronoun variation 1sg

2sg

3sg

Volow স Extinct dialect of Mwotlap (1 passive speaker) স 1sg pronoun alternation n/n,

non-singular

… pointing to a prenasalised stop *[ g]. Mota

(na)

(ka)

ni

a

Mwesen

(na)

a

ni

a

Vurës

(na)

i

ni

a

স Too parallel to Mwotlap to be really helpful.

স Extension of non-singular /a/ to some singular forms স The language with most formal diversity is Vurës.

17

1sg

2sg

3sg

non-singular

‘let me see’

‘you see’

‘let him see’

‘let us see’

Mwotlap

(n) nk t

nk (Ø-) t

k ni-t

n (Ø-) t

Volow

(n) n t

n (Ø-) t

g n-t

n (Ø-) t

19

Hiw

4 “Northwest Banks” languages

LoToga

The Quest for the Aorist „

Löyöp Lehali

The four “Northwest Banks” languages স 1sg Aorist includes /k/ as in Mwotlap nk, but this /k/ is a prefix to the verb.

(n) | Ø | n- | Ø

স obvious when pronoun and verb are separated: Lemerig

(nk) | Ø | ni- | Ø

Veraa

na | ka | ni | a

na | i | ni | a

Mwotlap

na | a | ni | a

Vera'a

nk

s

an

n

s

k- an

1sg:AO

PROSP

go

1sg

PROSP

AO:1sg-go

‘I want to go.’

‘I want to go.’

স The same surface form [nkan] ‘let me go’ will be parsed /nk an/ in Mwotlap, but /n k-an/ in Vera'a. Aorist markers in North Vanuatu

21

20

The Quest for the Aorist „

The Quest for the Aorist „

The four “Northwest Banks” languages

The two Torres languages

স Set of Aorist prefixes: k- ‘1sg’; n(V)- ‘3sg’; (Ø-) elsewhere… 1sg ‘let me see’

2sg ‘you see’

3sg ‘let him see’

non-singular ‘let us see’

Löyöp

nø k-t

ni (Ø-) t

k n-t

jn (Ø-) t

Lehali

n k-t

nek (Ø-) t

k n-t

en (Ø-) t

Lemerig

n k- t

næk (Ø-) t

ti n- t

Hiw

æt (Ø-) t

Lo-Toga

free pr.

Aor. clitic

free pr.

Aor. clitic

nk

k

nk

k

2sg

ik

wt

nik

w

3sg

nin

n

ni

ni

1sg

1in:du

t 

or

1ex:du

kama

kmr

2du

kimi

3du

s 



kmor

Vera'a

n k- n

nik (Ø-) n

di n- n

id k- n

Mwotlap

nk t

nk (Ø-) t

k ni-t

n (Ø-) t

1in:pl

tit

t

i

Volow

n t

n (Ø-) t

g n-t

n (Ø-) t

1ex:pl

kama



kmm

2pl

kimi



kmi

3pl

sis

s

nih

স Historical hypothesis:

nk < reanalysis of n ‘1sg’+ *k- ‘AO:1sg’ 23

or

hor



25

k | wt | n | …

• •

A proto-system can be reconstructed for the ancestor of these languages (PNCV, or one of its branches) Set of four “Aorist” clitics

Non-singular Aorist:



*a *(k)a



k- | Ø | n- | Ø

Ø

k | w | ni | 

(n) | Ø | n- | Ø

Ø

Ø

k- | Ø | n- | Ø k- | Ø | n- | Ø

(nk) | Ø | ni- | Ø

Ø

Ø

k- | Ø | n | k-

na | ka | ni | a

k-

a

na | i | ni | a

na | a | ni | a

a a

()a Aorist markers in North Vanuatu

26

3 sg Aorist:

n

*ni

()a

Aorist markers in North Vanuatu

27

2 sg Aorist: *(w)u? *(w)u *u? *u

wt

ni

w

n-

Ø n-

nn-

ni-

n

ni

Ø

Ø Ø

Ø a

Ø a

ni ni

Aorist markers in North Vanuatu

i

28

Aorist markers in North Vanuatu

29

1 sg Aorist: *gV = *gu ?

k

Reconstructing the protosystem

k

স Set of four clitics combining aspect and person:

k-

*gu | *u | *ni | *(k)a

(n)

k-

ƒ k-

(nk) ƒ

na

na

gu =

ano

gu =

maturu.

1sg

AO:1sg

go

AO:1sg

sleep

‘I went to sleep.’ / ‘Let me go to sleep!’

na

k-

*nau

ƒ

*nigo

u=

ano

u=

maturu.

2sg

AO:2sg

go

AO:2sg

sleep

*nia

ni =

‘You went to sleep.’ / ‘Go to sleep!’ ano ni = maturu.

3sg

AO:3sg

go

AO:3sg

sleep

‘He went to sleep.’ / ‘Let him go to sleep!’ ƒ

*kida 1inc:pl

Aorist markers in North Vanuatu

স These clitics underwent normal sound change (esp. vowel reduction)



*nigo

u=

næk – an.

*nia

ni = ano. (k)a = ano.

ti

n- an.

Conclusion „

স Mtp + Vlw:

Reanalysis of *nau gu > nk / n.

স Torres lgs:

nk ( a; ka; na)

k- ( grammaticalised into aorist markers

This is a starting point for further research, and for future discussions…